Airbus A320 crashed in Southern France
No!
Not if the pressure failure was forward of the door, in that case the cockpit door controller unit unlocks the door, and the door opens (towards the cockpit) under differential pressure.
Not if the pressure failure was forward of the door, in that case the cockpit door controller unit unlocks the door, and the door opens (towards the cockpit) under differential pressure.
Join Date: Feb 2015
Location: UK
Posts: 35
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
At the briefing, the Hollande said that the “envelope of the second black box has been found, unfortunately not the black box itself”. He said the search goes on for that.
Although its difficult terrain, its not unimaginable that a square metre by square metre search will find the missing memory unit from the flight data recorder, even if it takes weeks or months.
Although its difficult terrain, its not unimaginable that a square metre by square metre search will find the missing memory unit from the flight data recorder, even if it takes weeks or months.
Join Date: May 2001
Location: England
Posts: 1,904
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I, like most pilots have not experienced a rapid decompression but I have flown with a captain who has. The experience he shared was most enlightening. When it happens you literally feel like the back of the aircraft has exploded. Your tongue is swallowed by your throat in a second, your ears begin to hurt and teeth become a hundred times more sensitive. If you already have an ear infection or a bad filling, you're likely to pass out as a result of the instant pain. None of these can be simulated in a sim or be trained for. On top of that, the cockpit fills with a cold mist that freezes the skin. All of these aspects make it incredibly difficult to recognise and reach out for the oxygen mask and autopilot controls. Stressing or moving about rapidly to find/don the oxygen mask chews into the time of useful conciousness.
I also agree that the flight path and steady descent indicates an informed decision to initiate an emergency descent. Done correctly, the target altitude would have been set to FL100 as a minimum. However looking even 30cm ahead can be challenging and that has the potential to result in the pilot setting the wrong target altitude.
I also agree that the flight path and steady descent indicates an informed decision to initiate an emergency descent. Done correctly, the target altitude would have been set to FL100 as a minimum. However looking even 30cm ahead can be challenging and that has the potential to result in the pilot setting the wrong target altitude.
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Hampshire, UK
Posts: 207
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by arearadar
Was there a fire on impact of germanwings ?
I don't own this space under my name. I should have leased it while I still could
The 2008 Qantas event is informative. When cruising at 29 000' (cabin altitude 3 700') an oxygen bottle exploded creating a 3 square metre hole in the fuselage. One second later the A/P disconnected and the aircraft pitched nose UP. Three seconds later the cabin altitude reached 10 000'. Pilots put on oxy masks and established communications with each other. At 22 seconds descent was initiated (thrust to idle/ speed brakes extended). At approx 40 seconds the uncommanded climb was reversed and and the descent established, maximum cabin of 25 900' occurred at about this time. The mean rate of descent was about 3 000 fpm and the cabin altitude was about about 3000' below the aircraft's altitude during the descent.
The key points are that at 29 000' and with a 3 sq m hole, cabin altitude reached 10 000' within 3" and 26 000' within 40". With idle thrust, speed brakes extended snd IAS at the cruise IAS, descent rate was ~ 3 000 fpm.
The key points are that at 29 000' and with a 3 sq m hole, cabin altitude reached 10 000' within 3" and 26 000' within 40". With idle thrust, speed brakes extended snd IAS at the cruise IAS, descent rate was ~ 3 000 fpm.
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: Ireland
Posts: 596
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
BEA spokesman getting very jittery in response to questions about the CVR.
He has admitted that it has useful information (suggesting it has been listened to) but won't say what was heard!
He has admitted that it has useful information (suggesting it has been listened to) but won't say what was heard!
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: Near the end of the Earth
Posts: 1
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
BEA spokesman getting very jittery in response to questions about the CVR.
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: UK
Posts: 2,044
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I may have missed it but has anyone mentioned ACARS data transmission? If the A/C was equipped and if it was used?
I would think the BEA will prioritise what they do have in conventional data sources (CVR, FDR, Mode S, ADS-B, ATC etc.). AF447 resorted to ACARS due to a high level of integration, and absence of other sources...
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Hotel Gypsy
Posts: 2,821
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
There can only be three reasons why pilots would not communicate with ATC under such circumstances (an unplanned rapid descent):
a. They are incapacitated - 30 or so pages discussing hypoxia.
b. They are unable due to equipment failure - not much discussion.
c. They (plural or singular) chose not to communicate - no discussion at all.
I'm not pointing in any particular direction other than highlighting the fact that we, the Great pprune Collective, seem to have decided to focus on only one of the above.
a. They are incapacitated - 30 or so pages discussing hypoxia.
b. They are unable due to equipment failure - not much discussion.
c. They (plural or singular) chose not to communicate - no discussion at all.
I'm not pointing in any particular direction other than highlighting the fact that we, the Great pprune Collective, seem to have decided to focus on only one of the above.
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Newfoundland
Age: 78
Posts: 17
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Two recent quotes from Remi Jouty of the BEA (accident investigation team) at the news conference.
Jouty: Sound recorder was found on site around 17:00 local time on Tuesday and was quickly sent to BEA, arriving at 09:45 on Wednesday
Jouty: We have been able to extract a usable audio file from the sound recorder.
Jouty: Sound recorder was found on site around 17:00 local time on Tuesday and was quickly sent to BEA, arriving at 09:45 on Wednesday
Jouty: We have been able to extract a usable audio file from the sound recorder.
Join Date: Jul 2013
Location: world
Posts: 1
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
giving indications that the ac flew till the end
no in air explosion indicated
audio file usable
has no info on whats on it
they haven't got or tried to get any info from the airline involved...yet
(the cnn feed translator is very good)
no in air explosion indicated
audio file usable
has no info on whats on it
they haven't got or tried to get any info from the airline involved...yet
(the cnn feed translator is very good)
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: On a roll...
Posts: 342
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Blackened mountainside
As a geologist who's done fieldwork in this area, agree with JamesT73 that these look like classic organic-rich (i.e. intensely black) shales to me and hence is their naturally colour. The more resistant, thin, lighter coloured rocks (seemingly uncharred) are white-yellow sandstone layers. Both formed in a deep ocean, but now find themselves thrust several thousand metres into mountains. When thick, these sandstone layers will make up the base of the hill and the higher summits behind.
The damage of this impact is truly phenomenal.
The damage of this impact is truly phenomenal.
Agreed. Over the ocean auto descent after pressurisation failure might be useful but in busy European & US skies a plummet without some sort of ATC clearance could lead to more serious consequences. A mid-air would clearly be more hazardous than temporary hypoxia for some passengers.
That does not mean that, if possible, once the descent has been started and immediate actions complete you wouldn't send a MAYDAY and/or select 7700 when you can.
Join Date: Oct 2013
Location: Sweden
Age: 47
Posts: 443
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
A seemingly knowing reporter with grey hair and suit asked if there were any sounds on the CVR during the time of the descent. The BEA spokesman did not answer that and/or he said something I didn't hear properly. Does anyone know of what I am talking and if so, did you happen to hear Mr BEA's answer?
The press conference is over. It was mostly uneducated questions about how a crash investigation is conducted, if there had been terrorist threats or bombs, but this gentleman in grey hair seemed to be in the know. Maybe a reporter for an aviation journal?
The press conference is over. It was mostly uneducated questions about how a crash investigation is conducted, if there had been terrorist threats or bombs, but this gentleman in grey hair seemed to be in the know. Maybe a reporter for an aviation journal?
Airbus A320 crashed in Southern France
Well just watched the press conference and not much news: they have the cvr but would not talk about its content, categorically refuted that anything was found about the FDR, no ACARS one way or another. I guess still very early in the investigation
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: on a blue balloon
Posts: 2
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Mr BEA didn't say when on the recording the sounds (at one point he did say 'voices') were heard. So he didn't say anything about noises during the descent.
And they are still searching for the FDR. So Pres Hollande's comments were BS.
And they are still searching for the FDR. So Pres Hollande's comments were BS.
His general answer (in both French and English) to all questions about the CVR was that whilst there whilst an audio file had been found it was going to be some time before the data had been fully extracted/analysed and so he was not willing to speculate on it's contents.
His comments about the FDR are consistent with all other credible local reports - it (or at least the important bit) hasn't been found yet.
His comments about the FDR are consistent with all other credible local reports - it (or at least the important bit) hasn't been found yet.
Agreed. Over the ocean auto descent after pressurisation failure might be useful but in busy European & US skies a plummet without some sort of ATC clearance could lead to more serious consequences. A mid-air would clearly be more hazardous than temporary hypoxia for some passengers.
Yes, a midair will ruin your day, no argument there. But if you turn off course, it's so freakishly unlikely that it's hardly worth considering. Can anyone reference a single midair resulting from an airline pilot doing what he felt was necessary during a serious emergency?
In an airliner suffering decompression, if you do everything correctly, the pilots are still in serious danger as long as they are at an altitude above which they can operate without supplemental oxygen. If it were me, I'd be on my way to a lower altitude immediately.
Waiting for ATC clearance during ANY very serious emergency was NOT in my bag of tricks back when I was flying over the North Atlantic and Europe. I suspect more people have died by turning control of their aircraft over to ATC than have died by doing what was necessary during a genuine emergency and then telling ATC about it later.