Jessica Starmer - BALPA's view (Update - Appeal decision)
Join Date: Mar 2000
Location: UK
Posts: 5,197
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Mrs Starmer's activities have certainly generated a lot of interest, and excellent discussion.
Between this thread and the original (linked below) we've just gone through 762 posts and 100,000 views.
BA pilot's sex discrimination case. (incl Tribunal Judgment)
Between this thread and the original (linked below) we've just gone through 762 posts and 100,000 views.
BA pilot's sex discrimination case. (incl Tribunal Judgment)
PPRuNe Playmate of the Month
Join Date: Feb 1999
Location: Donington, Lincolnshire
Age: 69
Posts: 593
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It is reported that efforts to find a compromise have failed and the appeal by BA is being heard today.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/dorset/4651801.stm
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/dorset/4651801.stm
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: London
Posts: 2,916
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
There's been lots of comment and some confusion here about the 2000 hours rule.
Just to avoid any misunderstanding about the appeal -
There's no dispute that formal rule was introduced after the refusal so the rule itself is irrelevant in this particular case. However, BA will still be able to argue the safety aspects.
To win the appeal, BA will have to show its refusal to grant Mrs Starmer part-time working was justified and not discriminatory.
The hearing continues today.
Just to avoid any misunderstanding about the appeal -
There's no dispute that formal rule was introduced after the refusal so the rule itself is irrelevant in this particular case. However, BA will still be able to argue the safety aspects.
To win the appeal, BA will have to show its refusal to grant Mrs Starmer part-time working was justified and not discriminatory.
The hearing continues today.
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: Abroad
Posts: 520
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Not if the dismissal was found to be on the grounds of sexual discrimination....then there isn't a ceiling to the damages that could be awarded. (I'm sure Flying Lawyer could correct me if I'm mistaken)
DIRECTOR
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: U.K.
Posts: 664
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
maxy 101 You may be right but this has nothing to do with sexual discrimination but that BA do not want ANY Pilot with her level of inexperience working just 50%
Sack her and lets see how easy she finds getting a job from the wilds of Dorset as and when she stops having children.
BA need to send a strong message that they want 100% work from the workforce until they have more experience. Perhaps BA are paying their Pilots too much if they can afford 50% working??
Sack her and lets see how easy she finds getting a job from the wilds of Dorset as and when she stops having children.
BA need to send a strong message that they want 100% work from the workforce until they have more experience. Perhaps BA are paying their Pilots too much if they can afford 50% working??
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: UK
Posts: 1,691
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
put her on part time and fail her opc/lpc.
Sack her and lets see how easy she finds getting a job from the wilds of Dorset as and when she stops having children.
BA need to send a strong message that they want 100% work from the workforce until they have more experience
BA need to send a strong message that they want 100% work from the workforce until they have more experience
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Oxford
Posts: 70
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Umm
Too many GCSE's to count
Four grade A a-levels
First class honours degree from Oxford
British Gliding champ
Probably the highest marks in Western Europe for her JAR Op exams.
Extremley competent pilot.
Liked and respected by all those who have flown with her.
Yeah Jess would find it really tough to find another job......... I would so like to see "thegypsey" and Jess side by side in the sim to see who could really cut the mustard. I know who my money wold be on.
As far as the interview stage I wouldn't even have the heart to put thegypsy through the humiliation of trying to compete with such a quick and interesting intellect.
Sack her and lets see how easy she finds getting a job from the wilds of Dorset as and when she stops having children.
Four grade A a-levels
First class honours degree from Oxford
British Gliding champ
Probably the highest marks in Western Europe for her JAR Op exams.
Extremley competent pilot.
Liked and respected by all those who have flown with her.
Yeah Jess would find it really tough to find another job......... I would so like to see "thegypsey" and Jess side by side in the sim to see who could really cut the mustard. I know who my money wold be on.
As far as the interview stage I wouldn't even have the heart to put thegypsy through the humiliation of trying to compete with such a quick and interesting intellect.
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: Northern England, United Kingdom
Posts: 43
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Interesting debate considering Eileen Collins is about to blast off on her fourth mission as a Space Shuttle Commander. Looks like she did some gliding along the way too. Obvously not a crime in the states.
http://www.nasa.gov/vision/space/pre...s_profile.html
I believe I read somewher that she has a couple of children. I wonder how NASA viewed her request for maternity leave? Did they consider writing her off as a waste of space and money?
I will think of this as I help develop a debate in my own company, part of which involves the question of whether manning the photocopier is appropriate work for a Captain temporarily grounded for reason's of maternity.
Come on BA, wake up, we are in a new century. The trouble is that most of the senior managers in the industry are left over from 1960's Transport Command, where chaps who flew the kites were Chaps.
The Gypsy and others, fancy offering your services and standing in for Eileen next week. Obviously, she is only a woman with kids, chop her on her next base check. There are plenty pruners like yourselvs out there (male) willing to jump in and do a better job.
Good on you NASA and good luck.
http://www.nasa.gov/vision/space/pre...s_profile.html
I believe I read somewher that she has a couple of children. I wonder how NASA viewed her request for maternity leave? Did they consider writing her off as a waste of space and money?
I will think of this as I help develop a debate in my own company, part of which involves the question of whether manning the photocopier is appropriate work for a Captain temporarily grounded for reason's of maternity.
Come on BA, wake up, we are in a new century. The trouble is that most of the senior managers in the industry are left over from 1960's Transport Command, where chaps who flew the kites were Chaps.
The Gypsy and others, fancy offering your services and standing in for Eileen next week. Obviously, she is only a woman with kids, chop her on her next base check. There are plenty pruners like yourselvs out there (male) willing to jump in and do a better job.
Good on you NASA and good luck.
Last edited by Kirkwall; 8th Jul 2005 at 12:17.
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: UK
Posts: 119
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Kirkwall
Looks like Collins has a little more experience to me - guess she didn't spend her career part time!
Next...
Casting new light on the term 'frequent flyer,' she has logged more than 6,280 hours in 30 different types of aircraft. More than 537 of those hours were logged in space
Next...
DIRECTOR
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: U.K.
Posts: 664
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Justbelowcap Yes we all know Jess is a clever Bunny! Perhaps too clever for her own good as it has turned out.
Getting a job from the wilds of Dorset has nothing to do with her Intellect or Degree but the fact that she is labelled a "trouble maker" Perhaps Branson would give her a job just to get one up on BA.!!?? Other Airlines would not touch her with a bargepole I suspect.
The late Roger Green from RAF Farnborough ( Chirps) once said that Airline Pilots only need to have the same Academic qualifications as a Primary School Teacher ie a couple of lowgrade A Levels.
Perhaps with her high Intellect Jess cannot stand the thought of working 100%??
Kirkwall Don't be silly. We are talking about Jess not Eileen.
Getting a job from the wilds of Dorset has nothing to do with her Intellect or Degree but the fact that she is labelled a "trouble maker" Perhaps Branson would give her a job just to get one up on BA.!!?? Other Airlines would not touch her with a bargepole I suspect.
The late Roger Green from RAF Farnborough ( Chirps) once said that Airline Pilots only need to have the same Academic qualifications as a Primary School Teacher ie a couple of lowgrade A Levels.
Perhaps with her high Intellect Jess cannot stand the thought of working 100%??
Kirkwall Don't be silly. We are talking about Jess not Eileen.
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: A home for the bewildered
Posts: 86
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Too many GCSE's to count
Four grade A a-levels
First class honours degree from Oxford
British Gliding champ
Probably the highest marks in Western Europe for her JAR Op exams
Extremeley competent pilot
Liked and respected by all those who have flown with her
Four grade A a-levels
First class honours degree from Oxford
British Gliding champ
Probably the highest marks in Western Europe for her JAR Op exams
Extremeley competent pilot
Liked and respected by all those who have flown with her
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Oxford
Posts: 70
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Getting a job from the wilds of Dorset has nothing to do with her Intellect or Degree but the fact that she is labelled a "trouble maker" Perhaps Branson would give her a job just to get one up on BA.!!?? Other Airlines would not touch her with a bargepole I suspect.
The law says she is entitled to percentage working.
BA have lost on this ground. They have then moved the goal posts by insisting that for somebody to have less than 2000 hrs this is not safe. Nobody would object to BA choosing their own levels of safety but this is an arbitary figure plucked out the air just because Jess has slightly less than this figure. In BA 1500 hours has always been the cut off point. To suddenly change this figure is almost obscene in it's arrogance.
The 50% working figure that Jess will fly will give her far more flying than 100% on the 747. Which she could easily transfer to if she so desired.
10 years ago cadets flying 100% on the airbus flew a lot less than Jess will fly on 50% now.
Cadets used to go striaght on to the Tristar and flew way, way less than Jess will fly.
This is not about safety (find ONE BA airbus trainer that will state publically that Jess would not be safe to fly a 50% contract. You can't because not one non-management trainer would agree to to make that statement.) it is simply that BA are trying to not allow Jess her legal rights because it will cost them money. She is entitled to those rights. Eventually she is paving the way for women and mothers to be able to have careers as pilots AND have a family. The law, and common sense, say that this is the way it should be for all employees. That includes pilots.
I pity the companies who think that the ability to work non-stop outways the ability to command an aircraft to the highest standards. These companies will pay the price if they employ "primary school teachers" instead of the most able individuals they can find. Unfortunately it will only be time before there is a major hull loss. Those responsible will have long gone, enjoying the vast fortunes made from stock options and bonus payments. Whilst some poor git will get the blame for failing to to do a job that he was probably never able to do since day one.
That is why the industry MUST keep employing those of the highest calibre. The less hand flying we do and the more automated the AC become the much more important it is that the truely able get selected. There is no time for practise anymore. The first time you deal with an aircraft that has no protections will be for real! That is why it is important that Jess wins. We need the most skilled people we can find in this industry. It simply cannot afford to overlook 50% of the population because they want to have a family.
Join Date: Oct 1998
Location: Silly Cone Valley
Posts: 122
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
This appeal has nothing to do with whether Jess is entitled to part-time, or whether BA is obliged to employ her.
This is all to do with PoD publicly losing face, and desparate to retsore some shred of credibilty in big-BA.
I hope he loses, and I hope he resigns.
I'll take on the opposition anyday - it's my management I can't beat!
This is all to do with PoD publicly losing face, and desparate to retsore some shred of credibilty in big-BA.
I hope he loses, and I hope he resigns.
I'll take on the opposition anyday - it's my management I can't beat!
Join Date: Dec 1999
Location: UK
Posts: 1,608
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The late Roger Green from RAF Farnborough ( Chirps) once said that Airline Pilots only need to have the same Academic qualifications as a Primary School Teacher ie a couple of lowgrade A Levels.
Both that - and indeed her motivation (though I somehow doubt that with her background) - are irrelevant. I agree again that BA have placed themselves in a hole due to trying to save money at the expense of work/life balance. All companies must equally share the burden of cost of the social rights that we all possess.
How many hours did MS - former LGW chief pilot - achieve before going to very low levels of flying and management? Was that deemed to be unsafe at the time? You know the answer - sanctioned by PD - and indeed the CAA.
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: Northern England, United Kingdom
Posts: 43
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
PoD resign.
Excellent. A great opportunity for the first woman to achieve status of GMFO in BA. There must be loads of them queueing up in the lower levels of managment just waiting to step into his shoes.
Aren't there??
Excellent. A great opportunity for the first woman to achieve status of GMFO in BA. There must be loads of them queueing up in the lower levels of managment just waiting to step into his shoes.
Aren't there??