PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rotorheads (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads-23/)
-   -   R44 crash w/video - Forresters Beach NSW - 19/11/2022 (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads/649929-r44-crash-w-video-forresters-beach-nsw-19-11-2022-a.html)

Bell_ringer 25th Nov 2022 16:09


Originally Posted by Robbiee (Post 11337183)
Wow,...if you're doing that, you need a better instructor, lol.

Robbiee old chum, a grown man saying “lol” in the twenty-twenties is as wrong as the same ageing bloke wearing a budgie smuggler. It’s very hard to take anything seriously when it’s followed by a #rofl..
:E

Robbiee 25th Nov 2022 16:55


Originally Posted by Bell_ringer (Post 11337243)
Robbiee old chum, a grown man saying “lol” in the twenty-twenties is as wrong as the same ageing bloke wearing a budgie smuggler. It’s very hard to take anything seriously when it’s followed by a #rofl..
:E

Hmm, I don't know what "#rofl.." means, so maybe you're right. Guess I'll just go back to emojis. :}

Ascend Charlie 25th Nov 2022 22:38

Robbiieee, it's a natural progression from LOL to ROFL to the ultimate of LMFAO, any teenybopper knows that.

nomorehelosforme 25th Nov 2022 23:18

Robbiee,

Not understanding “old chum” might put you on a “sticky wicket” don’t take everything in life too seriously….

[email protected] 26th Nov 2022 08:43

Someone in California doesn't know what ROFL means??????? Like wow dude.........

Robbiee 26th Nov 2022 14:53


Originally Posted by [email protected] (Post 11337548)
Someone in California doesn't know what ROFL means??????? Like wow dude.........

I don't know what "California Cuisine" is either. :(

Aluminium Mallard 27th Nov 2022 23:36


Originally Posted by Robbiee (Post 11337183)
Wow,...if you're doing that, you need a better instructor, lol.

When you say you/you're, you mean them/they right? :)

Restricting the governor with a overly firm grip is an issue with tense students and low time pilots.
On some older machines the governor stepper motor gets tired and the (non-adjustable) friction clutch wears resulting in a "weak" governor that is easily overridden.

Some examples from the archives below:




Robbiee 28th Nov 2022 00:47


Originally Posted by Aluminium Mallard (Post 11338382)
When you say you/you're, you mean them/they right? :)

Restricting the governor with a overly firm grip is an issue with tense students and low time pilots.
On some older machines the governor stepper motor gets tired and the (non-adjustable) friction clutch wears resulting in a "weak" governor that is easily overridden.

Some examples from the archives below:

https://youtu.be/0blbra-bUIY
https://youtu.be/fe2CN0SIwTk

The way good (experienced) Robby instructors deal with the death grip, is to instruct the student to place their three back fingers on the collective so that only the thumb and indext fingers are lightly touching the throttle. This way as the student tightens their grip it doesn't override the governor.

I was taught this in 2003 and still do it to this day.


Ascend Charlie 28th Nov 2022 04:43

LTE, if it existed, would cease after maybe 180 degrees of yaw and the T/R is out of the problem area. That news chopper had the low RPM warning on for AGES, spinning for ages, so I am wondering what the heck she was doing (apart from breathing heavily) - it wasn't anything useful.

The R44 video didn't really show anything except a high power setting resulting in RPM decay.

And yes, the grip on the collective should be the little and third fingers around the collective shaft and the thumb, forefinger and middle finger operating/monitoring the throttle.

ShyTorque 28th Nov 2022 07:11


Originally Posted by Bell_ringer (Post 11337243)
Robbiee old chum, a grown man saying “lol” in the twenty-twenties is as wrong as the same ageing bloke wearing a budgie smuggler. It’s very hard to take anything seriously when it’s followed by a #rofl..
:E

According to Robbie’s profile, she’s not a man.

Bell_ringer 28th Nov 2022 09:40


Originally Posted by ShyTorque (Post 11338479)
she’s not a man.

It’s California. Who is?

[email protected] 28th Nov 2022 12:07

But what does she/he/they identify as???:E

i think the answer is - helicopter pilot

Robbiee 28th Nov 2022 15:37


Originally Posted by [email protected] (Post 11338634)
But what does she/he/they identify as???:E

i think the answer is - helicopter pilot

I identify as "A simple loser running out the clock".

However, in light of my State's recent decent into lunacy, I've replaced all my pronouns with "asshole". Therefore, you may refer to me as, "That asshole". Thank you, and have a nice day. :cool:

RickNRoll 29th Nov 2022 01:04

Why were they allowed to even try to land there?

Twist & Shout 29th Nov 2022 21:47


Originally Posted by RickNRoll (Post 11339010)
Why were they allowed to even try to land there?

Who would you put in charge of deciding where is suitable to land, if not the PIC?

SASless 29th Nov 2022 22:28


....you may refer to me as, "That asshole".
Mon Sweet....some. here have been doing that long before your State going completely over the edge.:oh:​​​​​​​

belly tank 29th Nov 2022 23:11

Firstly to point out, Im not a tick tokker :=

Here is another angle https://www.tiktok.com/@grants1990/v...50368413781250

RickNRoll 30th Nov 2022 05:53


Originally Posted by Twist & Shout (Post 11339499)
Who would you put in charge of deciding where is suitable to land, if not the PIC?

They say he was trying to land in the hotel carpark according to the story. That doesn't sound safe unless you are an expert and you have to land there.

Aluminium Mallard 30th Nov 2022 10:19


Originally Posted by Robbiee (Post 11338394)
The way good (experienced) Robby instructors deal with the death grip, is to instruct the student to place their three back fingers on the collective so that only the thumb and indext fingers are lightly touching the throttle. This way as the student tightens their grip it doesn't override the governor.

I was taught this in 2003 and still do it to this day.

I wasn't taught that... but used to do it as a low hour pilot. I found later on when I started instructing it prevents you from manipulating the throttle... mainly in tail rotor failures and governor off ops.

Any sign of tension in a student should be addressed, but it can be a bit of work. Much easier to get them to hold the collective differently and tick a box but you are setting them up to fail.


Robbiee 30th Nov 2022 15:04


Originally Posted by Aluminium Mallard (Post 11339766)
I wasn't taught that... but used to do it as a low hour pilot. I found later on when I started instructing it prevents you from manipulating the throttle... mainly in tail rotor failures and governor off ops.

Any sign of tension in a student should be addressed, but it can be a bit of work. Much easier to get them to hold the collective differently and tick a box but you are setting them up to fail.

Never had any problem manipulating the throttle during the once in a blue moon (i.e. during BFRs) times I've had to do Governor off and/or Tail Rotor Failure,...just slid my hand up, takes like two seconds, but as the kids say,...

you do you.


Flying Binghi 30th Nov 2022 17:30


Originally Posted by RickNRoll (Post 11339624)
They say he was trying to land in the hotel carpark according to the story. That doesn't sound safe unless you are an expert and you have to land there.

I spot a bot.

megan 1st Dec 2022 00:13

The carpark where he was going to land I am assuming, 90 by 50 feet by measurement, rotor diameter is given as 33 feet.


https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....06b1542c9f.png

[email protected] 1st Dec 2022 07:54


Much easier to get them to hold the collective differently and tick a box but you are setting them up to fail.
If you can address the issue of a student being tense on the collective by getting them to adjust their grip, why wouldn't you? Many students are nervous in the early stages and all you have to do as they gain experience and confidence is introduce a better hand position or make sure they understand that when they need to manipulate the throttle, they does as Robbiee says and slide their hand up the lever a bit.

So much better than constantly having to nag them about death grip on the throttle.

I teach people to hover over the water (not in a Robinson I might add) with a low grip on the cyclic to reduce overcontrolling but they understand they have to adjust their grip slightly if they need to use any of the buttons at the top of the cyclic.


All times are GMT. The time now is 00:32.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.