PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rotorheads (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads-23/)
-   -   Helicopter missing - Mt Disappointment VIC (AU) (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads/645960-helicopter-missing-mt-disappointment-vic-au.html)

RVDT 6th Apr 2022 06:59

The original "tale", of which it isn't, was from the Bell 214B for the reasons here and the resultant "ballistic" trajectory.

6000 FPM at SL wasn't/isn't difficult light but you could also cave in the greenhouse windows above your head. Not rated for 60 knots vertical and above. Even an old 205 will surprise some when light and you can bust the windows in one as well.

Apparently a 214 back in the day established a couple of records and sustained ~2000 FPM to 30,000' and ~5200 FPM to 10,000'. So the rate numbers at sea level would have been higher.

HissingSyd 6th Apr 2022 13:08


Originally Posted by John Eacott (Post 11211104)
C'mon, don't spoil the dit :p

I was too succinct. You got it, but the following posts suggest I was misunderstood.

The ROC, or vertical speed, indicator only shows +-2000 fpm. In an auto in a Wasp you had no idea how fast you were descending. ;-)

[email protected] 6th Apr 2022 15:57


In an auto in a Wasp you had no idea how fast you were descending. ;-)
I believe the answer was always - VERY!

Squawk7700 12th May 2022 02:08

Preliminary report released.

Investigation: AO-2022-016 - Collision with terrain involving Airbus Helicopters EC130 T2, VH-XWD near Mount Disappointment, Victoria, on 31 March 2022 (atsb.gov.au)

OMG. the first heli flew into the cloud first and did a U-turn and the second one followed.


The passenger in the front right seat had flown in helicopters for about 30 years. The passenger recalled that, as they crossed Mount Disappointment, heavy cloud rolled in resulting in ‘a white-out with ground visibility no longer evident’. The pilot radioed XWD and said words to the effect of ‘U‑turn, U-turn, U-turn’. Then the pilot of WVV immediately completed a U‑turn. The pilot of XWD radioed back with words to the effect ‘aren’t we going to cut through?’ The passenger then saw XWD pass just below them

[email protected] 12th May 2022 07:46

VFR pilot ignores VFR rules, enters cloud and crashes - nothing new there unfortunately...........5 lives lost for the sake of a 180 turn........

212man 12th May 2022 08:22

Website might need a refresh.....


Squawk7700 12th May 2022 09:10


Originally Posted by 212man (Post 11228988)
Website might need a refresh.....

Which website?

212man 12th May 2022 09:23


Originally Posted by Squawk7700 (Post 11229009)
Which website?

The operator

Squawk7700 12th May 2022 12:10


Originally Posted by 212man (Post 11229017)
The operator


https://microflite.com.au/content/th...-circle-26.pngDAY AND NIGHT
Our highly-trained pilots have the skills and certifications to fly in all conditions, and at any time of day.
This?

…..

212man 12th May 2022 14:52


Originally Posted by Squawk7700 (Post 11229107)
This?

…..

plus the references to enviable safety history and accident free record.....

rotorspeed 12th May 2022 18:40

Perfectly put Crab. And it would seem, not for the first time:

'The pilot of XWD radioed back with words to the effect ‘aren’t we going to cut through?’

EMS R22 12th May 2022 19:26

Got to love this industry…. Everyone quick to put the knife in.

My thoughts are with the friends and family’s.

Let’s all learn from this.

[email protected] 12th May 2022 21:30


Got to love this industry…. Everyone quick to put the knife in.

My thoughts are with the friends and family’s.

Let’s all learn from this.
I don't think there is a poster here whose thoughts aren't with the families - no-one seems to learn from this, that is why we are frustrated.

It's not a knife, it is a frigging big neon sign that says ' Don't scud run - turn around or land'

Squawk7700 12th May 2022 21:36

“Walls of cloud” don’t generally just “roll in” based on my 20 years of VFR flying… you fly into them as they remain mostly stationary.

[email protected] 13th May 2022 17:32

Weather deterioration around high ground - how unexpected............

Squawk7700 11th Jan 2024 19:53

The final report has been released:

VFR into IMC, loss of control and collision with terrain involving Airbus Helicopters EC130 T2, VH-XWD, near Mount Disappointment, Victoria, on 31 March 2022 | ATSB

https://australianaviation.com.au/20...db8e5f458c47bf


ShyTorque 12th Jan 2024 09:38

Sadly, it really does appear that this was a case of “same old, same old”. The cliche about old, bold pilots definitely applies here. Two pilots, two aircraft, same way, same time, same conditions. Two opinions of whether to turn back or not. It’s a fine line.

Having been in the situation of commercial pressure to fly or not and whether to continue a flight once airborne many times, I’m beginning to realise how glad I am to be retired and away from it all.

However, I must say that I’m very, very surprised that the standby horizon wasn’t even switched on! That indicates a certain mindset about the flight.

Also, a pilot with a few thousand hours but no IFR training at all? I recall flying under the IMC training hood very early on in my basic helicopter training, in an unstabilised Whirlwind 10. IR training long after first solo unless I’m very much mistaken and certainly with a lot less than 100 hours total. Might have even been before night flying…maybe Teetering Head can confirm? Before that we were required to gain a basic “white rating” IR in fixed wing.

RVDT 12th Jan 2024 18:58

Never really understood the term "Inadvertent IMC" Day VFR. It's fairly apparent looking out the window?

Maybe it should be "inadvertent lack of training / understanding"?

Measures taken -

  • drafted a dedicated risk assessment addressing visual flight rules into IMC
  • upgrading their fleet of EC130 and AS350 helicopters with the Garmin G500H primary flight display and multifunction display incorporating synthetic vision and a terrain alerting functionality
  • modifying their AS350 helicopters with the Garmin GFC 600H helicopter flight control system (approved data for the EC130 was not available at the time of the investigation)
  • acquired ICARUS (instrument conditions awareness recognition and understanding system) instrument flying training hoods
  • introduced basic instrument flying training and inadvertent IMC recovery training
  • updated their operator proficiency check syllabus to include knowledge and practical skills checks for avoiding and recovering from inadvertent IMC
  • added the Helicopter Association International online academy ‘56 Seconds to Live’ inadvertent IMC avoidance course to their pilot training program
  • introduced a pre-flight risk assessment tool
  • introduced a company ‘Task rejection’ policy statement into their operations manual
  • obtained an Airbus Helicopter Training Centre approval.

All that might do is make pilots "think" they can now randomly operate IMC?

Somehow I think the priorities are a little backwards.

Never really understood how the old NGT VFR rules were workable in Australia and look how that turned out.


All times are GMT. The time now is 21:53.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.