Left-Right, dyslexia
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Australia
Posts: 299
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Left-Right, dyslexia
I have a student who has trouble with left and right, I'm trying clock wise and anti clockwise which seems to be working so far. I have in the past heard of that the condition of getting left and right mixed up has a name, but I can't remember what that name is. can any one shed some light on this or lend any suggestions for tackleing the problem ?
PPRuNe Co-Pilot
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: The Sky
Posts: 931
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
G'day,
I think i have the same problem i sometimes mix up but the stange thing is that i know left and right in my native language the Portuguese.
Would be interested in hearing from others.
Cheers
I think i have the same problem i sometimes mix up but the stange thing is that i know left and right in my native language the Portuguese.
Would be interested in hearing from others.
Cheers
Spicy Meatball
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Liverpool UK
Age: 41
Posts: 1,115
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I have a friend who has this problem too. We decided that if he could associate something to his left and right hands, then he could then distinguish more easily. (jokes aside)!
For example, if you WRITE with your RIGHT hand: So next time you needed to distinguish RIGHT - you would remember your RIGHT (WRITING) hand ?
Does this make sense?
Regards
Maz
For example, if you WRITE with your RIGHT hand: So next time you needed to distinguish RIGHT - you would remember your RIGHT (WRITING) hand ?
Does this make sense?
Regards
Maz
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: UK
Posts: 386
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
there are different types of dislexia and the way it comes to the surface.
my girlfriend has got the same problem.she thinks she writes a complete sentence but leaves some key words out. she thinks about it she says, and has the full sentence in her mind but somehow her unconscious mind/conscious mind doesn't register and it doesn't get down on paper.
she also suffers from left and right problems.she means left but says right, very confusing.
the funny thing is, speakingwise she doesn't leave things out of her sentences...only confusing left and right.
my girlfriend has got the same problem.she thinks she writes a complete sentence but leaves some key words out. she thinks about it she says, and has the full sentence in her mind but somehow her unconscious mind/conscious mind doesn't register and it doesn't get down on paper.
she also suffers from left and right problems.she means left but says right, very confusing.
the funny thing is, speakingwise she doesn't leave things out of her sentences...only confusing left and right.
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: Europe
Posts: 655
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Laterality
Green for Danger
---
Here lie the bones of Emily Bright
Who put out her left hand
And turned to the right.
---
See chapter 14 of The Naked Pilot by David Beaty
ISBN 1-85310-482-5
---
Here lie the bones of Emily Bright
Who put out her left hand
And turned to the right.
---
See chapter 14 of The Naked Pilot by David Beaty
ISBN 1-85310-482-5
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: UK
Posts: 40
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I had a student (probably the best and most naturally skilled of all of them) who had the same problem. We overcame it by using post-it notes for left and right with big arrows drawn on, and sticking them over unused instruments eg AH and ILS (VFR obviously!). After a few trips we lost the right one, but just having the left one did the trick. As far as I know, he still uses this today (don't know what they'll say if he ever goes for an airline job)!
In my far off days of UAS flying, one student annoyed the QFI so much with this little problem that he used a big magic marker to put L and R on the backs of her white flying gloves - not good for the Top Gun image!
I think the main CRM point to remember is that it is quite common and should not be made fun of, whatever method is used.
In my far off days of UAS flying, one student annoyed the QFI so much with this little problem that he used a big magic marker to put L and R on the backs of her white flying gloves - not good for the Top Gun image!
I think the main CRM point to remember is that it is quite common and should not be made fun of, whatever method is used.
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Frimley, Surrey.
Posts: 182
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Could be Dyspraxia? aka Developmental Co-ordination Disorder (DCD), Perceptuo-Motor Dysfunction, and (more simply) Motor Learning Difficulties. It was once known as Clumsy Child Syndrome, but in this PC world we could never call it that now. Males are four times more likely to be affected than females.
Avoid imitations
Join Date: Nov 2000
Location: Wandering the FIR and cyberspace often at highly unsociable times
Posts: 14,578
Received 435 Likes
on
229 Posts
I had a helicopter student once who had this problem.
It was potentially very dangerous because of the requirement to manoeuvre a big helicopter in small confined areas and to get the crewman to clear the tail of the aircraft. There was a case of a Wessex crew who got it wrong and the pilot went left instead of right or vice versa. The aircraft hit a mast by a helipad and rolled down the hill, killing at least one of the pax and very seriously injuring one of the pilots.
Similar to the UAS QFI who drew on the stude's flying gloves, (actually I think I did that once, too) I made 2 inch high letters "L" and "R" in sticky orange dayglo and put them on the back of his green leather gloves. It worked. He's still around! I think the stigma of having the gloves made him concentrate more and it cured him.
Now. Why do my wife's knickers say "C and A" in them?
It was potentially very dangerous because of the requirement to manoeuvre a big helicopter in small confined areas and to get the crewman to clear the tail of the aircraft. There was a case of a Wessex crew who got it wrong and the pilot went left instead of right or vice versa. The aircraft hit a mast by a helipad and rolled down the hill, killing at least one of the pax and very seriously injuring one of the pilots.
Similar to the UAS QFI who drew on the stude's flying gloves, (actually I think I did that once, too) I made 2 inch high letters "L" and "R" in sticky orange dayglo and put them on the back of his green leather gloves. It worked. He's still around! I think the stigma of having the gloves made him concentrate more and it cured him.
Now. Why do my wife's knickers say "C and A" in them?
This reminds me of a story I heard many more years ago than I care to remember. An ancient Imperial Airways captain, who had served for years on the HP42 and the Empire boats, died.
Throughout his flying career he had this infallible habit of extracting a little walnut box lined with green baize from his flight bag, opening it and then studying the contents intensely, before he would even consider starting the first engine.
Lots of his colleagues were invited to the reading of his last Will and Testament. The solicitor duly read the will and asked if there were any questions. One F/O stuck his hand up and asked if there was anything in there about the walnut box and what on earth was in it.
The box was duly produced and when it was opened, there was an ivory coloured card secured to the bottom with a drawing pin. On it was written "Port - Left, Starboard - Right"!
Throughout his flying career he had this infallible habit of extracting a little walnut box lined with green baize from his flight bag, opening it and then studying the contents intensely, before he would even consider starting the first engine.
Lots of his colleagues were invited to the reading of his last Will and Testament. The solicitor duly read the will and asked if there were any questions. One F/O stuck his hand up and asked if there was anything in there about the walnut box and what on earth was in it.
The box was duly produced and when it was opened, there was an ivory coloured card secured to the bottom with a drawing pin. On it was written "Port - Left, Starboard - Right"!
Last edited by JW411; 27th Jul 2004 at 18:37.
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: Liverpool based Geordie, so calm down, calm down kidda!!
Age: 60
Posts: 2,051
Likes: 0
Received 17 Likes
on
6 Posts
Shytorque, didn't the board of enquiry find the pilots 'not guilty'? They reckoned the crewman was facing backwards in the door and got his left/right wrong??
There was a student at a unit I instructed on who had this problem and we chopped him because he often turned towards danger when we called it. We made the mistake of calling him dyslexic on the suspension report. When he produced a medical report showing he wasn't dyslexic, he was reinstated and gained his wings.
From here, I do not know the exact details, but he was removed from the SAR force after some time on the squadron. It is said that when hovering close to a cliff, the crewman called 'right one' and he moved left!!
He now flies in another capacity!!
I now believe that a problem like this should mean suspension from flying, harsh but necessary.
There was a student at a unit I instructed on who had this problem and we chopped him because he often turned towards danger when we called it. We made the mistake of calling him dyslexic on the suspension report. When he produced a medical report showing he wasn't dyslexic, he was reinstated and gained his wings.
From here, I do not know the exact details, but he was removed from the SAR force after some time on the squadron. It is said that when hovering close to a cliff, the crewman called 'right one' and he moved left!!
He now flies in another capacity!!
I now believe that a problem like this should mean suspension from flying, harsh but necessary.
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Mahlangeni
Posts: 204
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
"left is where the thumb is right"
Hold up both hands in front of you with the palms facing away from you.
Left hand: LEFT is where the thumb is right.
Right hand: RIGHT is where the thumb is left.
That should help
Left hand: LEFT is where the thumb is right.
Right hand: RIGHT is where the thumb is left.
That should help
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: UK
Posts: 41
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
My wife seems to do this especially when driving, we get to a junction she asks where to go I say left she goes right.
Being right she then tells me I don't speak clearly enough pulls over and tells me to drive which I have no problem at all with!
Being right she then tells me I don't speak clearly enough pulls over and tells me to drive which I have no problem at all with!
Join Date: Jan 2000
Location: Hang on, I'll check my roster...
Posts: 197
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Laterality disorder is the name I believe, I know BA's computerised micropat tests include a guy with a briefcase who looks at you, turns away, turns upside down etc and you have a speed and accuracy assesment of which hand it is in.
Don't know how to solve it, but for lights and seafaring terms theres the reminder - theres no RED PORT LEFT...
Don't know how to solve it, but for lights and seafaring terms theres the reminder - theres no RED PORT LEFT...
Avoid imitations
Join Date: Nov 2000
Location: Wandering the FIR and cyberspace often at highly unsociable times
Posts: 14,578
Received 435 Likes
on
229 Posts
JT2,
I think you are correct but couldn't be sure, that's why I said "crew" rather than "pilot".
I think you are correct but couldn't be sure, that's why I said "crew" rather than "pilot".
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Australia
Posts: 299
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thank you all for your input, I will be flying with the student this weekend and will most likely try "postit" notes on the panel with left and right written on them.
Oh Shazbat!
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: Leeds, UK
Age: 64
Posts: 239
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
This is one of those silly little problems that doesn't really cause harm but is exceptionally embarassing - did the left for right trick several times learning to drive but kept it together on the test. Coaching youth baseball is also fun - number of times I have pointed authoritively out and said something like "Out in Left Field" only to get a voice saying "Coach...that's Right Field!"
Aerodynamisist - I find that it works better having just one side posted, I can work out the other much more quickly. Having two post-its just adds to confusion - if I think "Left" and look and see "L" then fine - but if I think "Right" and see "L" then I need more time to work it out in my head.
Good way is to get one of those blue plasters that they put on staff in supermarkets, restaurants etc. Put one on my left hand and now I have "Left" and "Not Left". Alternatively - write on my hand or use my watch so I have "Watch" and "Not Watch". I know these seem pretty purile but they work for me.
Aerodynamisist - I find that it works better having just one side posted, I can work out the other much more quickly. Having two post-its just adds to confusion - if I think "Left" and look and see "L" then fine - but if I think "Right" and see "L" then I need more time to work it out in my head.
Good way is to get one of those blue plasters that they put on staff in supermarkets, restaurants etc. Put one on my left hand and now I have "Left" and "Not Left". Alternatively - write on my hand or use my watch so I have "Watch" and "Not Watch". I know these seem pretty purile but they work for me.