Seeking advice on an ambitious plan to fly commercial
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2023
Location: united kingdom
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Seeking advice on an ambitious plan to fly commercial
It has come to light that I am ineligible for the CAA Class 1 certification following my attempts to rectify a failed medical assessment. Consequently, I find myself temporarily turning to instructing, a measure I'll elaborate on shortly. Regrettably, the prospect of commercial flight within the United Kingdom now eludes me. Nevertheless, I am able to secure a Class 2, allowing me the opportunity to pursue an instructor's license.
My strategic course from this point forward entails embarking on said path and, in due course, relocating to somewhere such as the United States to seek employment as an instructor, in hopes that the school will assist in the acquisition of a work visa. One compelling reason behind this decision stems from the lack of students in my current residence of Wales, UK. Even my father, who occupies a role as a PPL instructor at the preeminent flying school in Wales, finds himself constrained to part-time work due to the scarcity of students. It is my fervent hope that a move to America will present avenues for full-time employment.
As previously alluded to, my aspirations extend beyond instructing, encompassing the attainment of a commercial pilot's license. Sadly, such aspirations find scant feasibility within the UK. Hence, I contemplate the feasibility of pursuing an FAA license while under a work visa in the US, thereafter seeking employment with an airline, thereby extending my visa tenure.
I am acutely aware that my proposed course of action is packed with ambition and plenty of risks. Nonetheless, if I am to realize my ambition of ascending to the realm of jet flying, I must undertake calculated risks. Moreover, the pursuit of the ATPL modular curriculum in the US while engaged in instructing stands to render the endeavour significantly cheaper than the UK (a sum >£120,000).
Certainly, further thought will be put into it before any financial commitments, but that's why I've turned to this forum for input once again.
Any insights, past experiences, or just general advice would be received with utmost appreciation.
bakerin
My strategic course from this point forward entails embarking on said path and, in due course, relocating to somewhere such as the United States to seek employment as an instructor, in hopes that the school will assist in the acquisition of a work visa. One compelling reason behind this decision stems from the lack of students in my current residence of Wales, UK. Even my father, who occupies a role as a PPL instructor at the preeminent flying school in Wales, finds himself constrained to part-time work due to the scarcity of students. It is my fervent hope that a move to America will present avenues for full-time employment.
As previously alluded to, my aspirations extend beyond instructing, encompassing the attainment of a commercial pilot's license. Sadly, such aspirations find scant feasibility within the UK. Hence, I contemplate the feasibility of pursuing an FAA license while under a work visa in the US, thereafter seeking employment with an airline, thereby extending my visa tenure.
I am acutely aware that my proposed course of action is packed with ambition and plenty of risks. Nonetheless, if I am to realize my ambition of ascending to the realm of jet flying, I must undertake calculated risks. Moreover, the pursuit of the ATPL modular curriculum in the US while engaged in instructing stands to render the endeavour significantly cheaper than the UK (a sum >£120,000).
Certainly, further thought will be put into it before any financial commitments, but that's why I've turned to this forum for input once again.
Any insights, past experiences, or just general advice would be received with utmost appreciation.
bakerin
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: UK
Posts: 747
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I am sorry to hear of your inability to obtain a class one medical. It is never nice to have dreams quashed by something outside of your control. In your shoes I would probably pursue a different career and use my spare cash to enjoy flying for fun, but that’s just me.
I do not know much about the FAA’s medical requirements, but before you consider starting down that path, go get whatever medical certification they require.
If your father is looking for additional work, I think Magnus Flying School at Welshpool have been looking for a CAA instructor.
Good luck.
I do not know much about the FAA’s medical requirements, but before you consider starting down that path, go get whatever medical certification they require.
If your father is looking for additional work, I think Magnus Flying School at Welshpool have been looking for a CAA instructor.
Good luck.
1. Get an FAA class one medical
2. Get F1 Visa and get FAA certified
3. Get on Tinder/Bumble etc
4. Get married
5. Get green card and airline job
--- --- --- ---
6. Get Divorced
7. Lose half your sh1t
8. Get married
9. >> Go to step 6
.
2. Get F1 Visa and get FAA certified
3. Get on Tinder/Bumble etc
4. Get married
5. Get green card and airline job
--- --- --- ---
6. Get Divorced
7. Lose half your sh1t
8. Get married
9. >> Go to step 6
.
Join Date: Mar 2023
Location: Ireland
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Did you follow the advice previously to contact a specialist optician (head optometrist for the CAA for more than a decade in fact) for an opinion?
And have you checked the FAA's optical requirements?
https://www.faa.gov/ame_guide/standards
Anyway the first step would be to try and get the FAA Class one.
And have you checked the FAA's optical requirements?
https://www.faa.gov/ame_guide/standards
Anyway the first step would be to try and get the FAA Class one.
Join Date: Oct 2014
Location: with bosun Blue Sky and the jenny haniver "Hot Stuff"
Posts: 106
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If you are colour blind, I'm afraid I can't comment, but if its myopia, I have a personal anecdote for you. Bearing in mind it's from 2018 so might have changed.
The Canadian Class 1 has - on paper - stricter requirements than the British. I assume from your mention of an optometrist that your medical problem is eyesight.
From personal experience back in 2018 the Canadians are a lot more lenient than the CAA and I was able to get a Class 1 with a note from an optometrist explaining that my retinas were not at danger of detaching (cost of note: $100 and a short eye examination.)
How old are you?
If you are younger than 35, you can go to Canada on a three-year working holiday visa, and with the right moves, get your Permanent Residency (the younger and higher-educated you are, the better.) You might be eligible for PR right now - check. The earlier you apply the better.
On a working holiday you can work for whoever you like, although it's hard to get a "proper" job like flying without PR. Once you've got PR, you will be better eligible for "proper" jobs. I met at least a couple of flying instructors and CPL candidates who had got PR and then landed their positions.
This will be easier immigration-wise than the USA.
Disclaimer: I'm (still) not a pilot - due to cost - and I don't have my PR (possibly my biggest regret in life, although it is one I am trying to rectify.)
HOWEVER: DON'T LET TRYING TO BECOME A PILOT CONSUME YOUR LIFE. I did, and I forgot to live mine. I don't entirely regret it but I would be in a much better position now if I hadn't. The advice by others to seek out another career and fly for fun is not without merit and you should consider it very carefully.
The Canadian Class 1 has - on paper - stricter requirements than the British. I assume from your mention of an optometrist that your medical problem is eyesight.
From personal experience back in 2018 the Canadians are a lot more lenient than the CAA and I was able to get a Class 1 with a note from an optometrist explaining that my retinas were not at danger of detaching (cost of note: $100 and a short eye examination.)
How old are you?
If you are younger than 35, you can go to Canada on a three-year working holiday visa, and with the right moves, get your Permanent Residency (the younger and higher-educated you are, the better.) You might be eligible for PR right now - check. The earlier you apply the better.
On a working holiday you can work for whoever you like, although it's hard to get a "proper" job like flying without PR. Once you've got PR, you will be better eligible for "proper" jobs. I met at least a couple of flying instructors and CPL candidates who had got PR and then landed their positions.
This will be easier immigration-wise than the USA.
Disclaimer: I'm (still) not a pilot - due to cost - and I don't have my PR (possibly my biggest regret in life, although it is one I am trying to rectify.)
HOWEVER: DON'T LET TRYING TO BECOME A PILOT CONSUME YOUR LIFE. I did, and I forgot to live mine. I don't entirely regret it but I would be in a much better position now if I hadn't. The advice by others to seek out another career and fly for fun is not without merit and you should consider it very carefully.
If you are colour blind, I'm afraid I can't comment, but if its myopia, I have a personal anecdote for you. Bearing in mind it's from 2018 so might have changed.
The Canadian Class 1 has - on paper - stricter requirements than the British. I assume from your mention of an optometrist that your medical problem is eyesight.
From personal experience back in 2018 the Canadians are a lot more lenient than the CAA and I was able to get a Class 1 with a note from an optometrist explaining that my retinas were not at danger of detaching (cost of note: $100 and a short eye examination.)
How old are you?
If you are younger than 35, you can go to Canada on a three-year working holiday visa, and with the right moves, get your Permanent Residency (the younger and higher-educated you are, the better.) You might be eligible for PR right now - check. The earlier you apply the better.
On a working holiday you can work for whoever you like, although it's hard to get a "proper" job like flying without PR. Once you've got PR, you will be better eligible for "proper" jobs. I met at least a couple of flying instructors and CPL candidates who had got PR and then landed their positions.
This will be easier immigration-wise than the USA.
Disclaimer: I'm (still) not a pilot - due to cost - and I don't have my PR (possibly my biggest regret in life, although it is one I am trying to rectify.)
HOWEVER: DON'T LET TRYING TO BECOME A PILOT CONSUME YOUR LIFE. I did, and I forgot to live mine. I don't entirely regret it but I would be in a much better position now if I hadn't. The advice by others to seek out another career and fly for fun is not without merit and you should consider it very carefully.
The Canadian Class 1 has - on paper - stricter requirements than the British. I assume from your mention of an optometrist that your medical problem is eyesight.
From personal experience back in 2018 the Canadians are a lot more lenient than the CAA and I was able to get a Class 1 with a note from an optometrist explaining that my retinas were not at danger of detaching (cost of note: $100 and a short eye examination.)
How old are you?
If you are younger than 35, you can go to Canada on a three-year working holiday visa, and with the right moves, get your Permanent Residency (the younger and higher-educated you are, the better.) You might be eligible for PR right now - check. The earlier you apply the better.
On a working holiday you can work for whoever you like, although it's hard to get a "proper" job like flying without PR. Once you've got PR, you will be better eligible for "proper" jobs. I met at least a couple of flying instructors and CPL candidates who had got PR and then landed their positions.
This will be easier immigration-wise than the USA.
Disclaimer: I'm (still) not a pilot - due to cost - and I don't have my PR (possibly my biggest regret in life, although it is one I am trying to rectify.)
HOWEVER: DON'T LET TRYING TO BECOME A PILOT CONSUME YOUR LIFE. I did, and I forgot to live mine. I don't entirely regret it but I would be in a much better position now if I hadn't. The advice by others to seek out another career and fly for fun is not without merit and you should consider it very carefully.
Get both an FAA and a Canadian medical, the cost is peanuts compared to what you’re planning on spending.
Canada is relatively speaking easier then US as far as Immigration is concerned.
We can only point you in the right direction so many times.
You are not going to get a visa that will allow you to work in the US. "I'm a pilot" isn't going to cut it. There is a visa program for highly experienced pilots, but meeting the minimum threshold for a job is not "highly experienced." Sorry.
There are people who get a flight training visa with ATP as a goal, so they are allowed to work as a CFI to build time to 1,500. But getting an ATP will not get them a visa or a job.
Can you move to Australia? Same King/etc. Australians are eligible for pilot work visas.
There are people who get a flight training visa with ATP as a goal, so they are allowed to work as a CFI to build time to 1,500. But getting an ATP will not get them a visa or a job.
Can you move to Australia? Same King/etc. Australians are eligible for pilot work visas.
There are places in the UK to get an FAA class 1. The last time I got one done here it was by a company called Centreline near Gatwick - I'd suggest taking nobody's word for your ability to get an FAA class 1, until you actually have an FAA class 1.
Definitely worth looking at the Canadian options, and also going all the way down the line seeing if there are workarounds to get a CAA class 1. Heck, most people who've worked in both countries would pick Canada in preference to the USA as a place to live and work.
And if all else fails, there are other jobs in aviation: I've done several ! During Covid lockdowns my PhD in airworthiness made me a lot more money than my CPL.
G
Definitely worth looking at the Canadian options, and also going all the way down the line seeing if there are workarounds to get a CAA class 1. Heck, most people who've worked in both countries would pick Canada in preference to the USA as a place to live and work.
And if all else fails, there are other jobs in aviation: I've done several ! During Covid lockdowns my PhD in airworthiness made me a lot more money than my CPL.
G
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2023
Location: united kingdom
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Request for clarification to your post
Hey, thank you for the advice, it's had me thinking a lot, I wondered if you could provide more clarification on the following:
" If you are younger than 35, you can go to Canada on a three-year working holiday visa, and with the right moves, get your Permanent Residency (the younger and higher-educated you are, the better.) You might be eligible for PR right now - check. The earlier you apply the better.
On a working holiday you can work for whoever you like, although it's hard to get a "proper" job like flying without PR. Once you've got PR, you will be better eligible for "proper" jobs. I met at least a couple of flying instructors and CPL candidates who had got PR and then landed their positions."
For some context I am 18.Firstly how hard is it to obtain the working holiday visa? Assuming PR is permanent residency, how can I go about getting it, do they consider a flight instructor as a sort of education? In terms of school, I have my basic school qualifications but no degree or anything.
As for the second part, it makes sense that an airline for example wouldn't want to hire someone on a temporary stay, but what if I get some sort of agreement with the Canadian government that if I can secure a long term position within an airline, they will provide me with my PR, which I could then show the airline, or something along those lines.
A lot of questions but this could be the way forward, I hope you or anyone else could help answer my questions. Thanks again!
" If you are younger than 35, you can go to Canada on a three-year working holiday visa, and with the right moves, get your Permanent Residency (the younger and higher-educated you are, the better.) You might be eligible for PR right now - check. The earlier you apply the better.
On a working holiday you can work for whoever you like, although it's hard to get a "proper" job like flying without PR. Once you've got PR, you will be better eligible for "proper" jobs. I met at least a couple of flying instructors and CPL candidates who had got PR and then landed their positions."
For some context I am 18.Firstly how hard is it to obtain the working holiday visa? Assuming PR is permanent residency, how can I go about getting it, do they consider a flight instructor as a sort of education? In terms of school, I have my basic school qualifications but no degree or anything.
As for the second part, it makes sense that an airline for example wouldn't want to hire someone on a temporary stay, but what if I get some sort of agreement with the Canadian government that if I can secure a long term position within an airline, they will provide me with my PR, which I could then show the airline, or something along those lines.
A lot of questions but this could be the way forward, I hope you or anyone else could help answer my questions. Thanks again!
I hate to say it but someone needs to.
Stop putting the cart in front of the horse
You are 18, get a medical and start with your PPL in the UK, part time while you continue your education.
Throwing everything at “becoming a pilot” without any regard for reality and it’s pitfalls is not the way.
You can’t just go to the US or Canada and just hope for the best without any higher education to help you sustain at least a moderate lifestyle during the times you don’t have a flying job.
Getting minimum wage and sleeping on someone’s couch may seem romantic but it’s not. It’s harsh and soulless.
Having a degree in a useful field will make immigration a whole lot less difficult.
You need to prepare for success not for failure
Stop putting the cart in front of the horse
You are 18, get a medical and start with your PPL in the UK, part time while you continue your education.
Throwing everything at “becoming a pilot” without any regard for reality and it’s pitfalls is not the way.
You can’t just go to the US or Canada and just hope for the best without any higher education to help you sustain at least a moderate lifestyle during the times you don’t have a flying job.
Getting minimum wage and sleeping on someone’s couch may seem romantic but it’s not. It’s harsh and soulless.
Having a degree in a useful field will make immigration a whole lot less difficult.
You need to prepare for success not for failure
Last edited by B2N2; 22nd Apr 2024 at 20:38.
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2023
Location: united kingdom
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I hate to say it but someone needs to.
Stop putting the cart in front of the horse
You are 18, get a medical and start with your PPL in the UK, part time while you continue your education.
Throwing everything at “becoming a pilot” without any regard for reality and it’s pitfalls is not the way.
You can’t just go to the US or Canada and just hope for the best without any higher education to help you sustain at least a moderate lifestyle during the times you don’t have a flying job.
Getting minimum wage and sleeping on someone’s couch may seem romantic but it’s not. It’s harsh and soulless.
Having a degree in a useful field will make emigration a whole lot less difficult.
You need to prepare for success not for failure
Stop putting the cart in front of the horse
You are 18, get a medical and start with your PPL in the UK, part time while you continue your education.
Throwing everything at “becoming a pilot” without any regard for reality and it’s pitfalls is not the way.
You can’t just go to the US or Canada and just hope for the best without any higher education to help you sustain at least a moderate lifestyle during the times you don’t have a flying job.
Getting minimum wage and sleeping on someone’s couch may seem romantic but it’s not. It’s harsh and soulless.
Having a degree in a useful field will make emigration a whole lot less difficult.
You need to prepare for success not for failure
Of course and thank you for the concern, I am currently in a stable office job on a full time salary, so at the bare minimum I have that for the next 50 years... My PPRuNe account is just for all things flying, I tend not to talk about my current job / education as in my eyes it is not relevant to my posts.
You’re still 18 without a degree correct?
Im not saying to not think about a flying career abroad but ‘hope’ is not a strategy.
Start thinking about what kind of additional higher education will make you a more successful immigrant?
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2023
Location: united kingdom
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Good point, I am without a degree at the moment but I don't think it's worth the 4 years and ~£40,000 for a degree that at most will help with my immigration, especially since I will not use it during my stay. Hope definitely is not the strategy, I don't really understand what you mean?
I don't think it's worth the 4 years and ~£40,000 for a degree
Nor Canada not the US are waiting for or very welcoming to ….uneducated immigrants.
If you intend to apply for some sort of work visa or residency permit you cannot apply as “pilot”.
”Pilot” is not an immigration category nor do either country have a shortage.
If you apply as “mechanical engineer” or “registered nurse” you’ll have a much better chance.
Once you’re in and a legal resident you can change to whichever.
Again, i hate to be this blunt but your only option is to emigrate outside of EASA medical territory.
Just consider for a moment what they need and not what you want.
Join Date: Mar 2024
Location: England
Posts: 6
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
You’re missing the point by a country mile.
Nor Canada not the US are waiting for or very welcoming to ….uneducated immigrants.
If you intend to apply for some sort of work visa or residency permit you cannot apply as “pilot”.
”Pilot” is not an immigration category nor do either country have a shortage.
If you apply as “mechanical engineer” or “registered nurse” you’ll have a much better chance.
Once you’re in and a legal resident you can change to whichever.
Again, i hate to be this blunt but your only option is to emigrate outside of EASA medical territory.
Just consider for a moment what they need and not what you want.
Nor Canada not the US are waiting for or very welcoming to ….uneducated immigrants.
If you intend to apply for some sort of work visa or residency permit you cannot apply as “pilot”.
”Pilot” is not an immigration category nor do either country have a shortage.
If you apply as “mechanical engineer” or “registered nurse” you’ll have a much better chance.
Once you’re in and a legal resident you can change to whichever.
Again, i hate to be this blunt but your only option is to emigrate outside of EASA medical territory.
Just consider for a moment what they need and not what you want.
I assume it’s easier for some areas of engineering but even if he gets an MEng in an area that’s in demand and he gets a first from a top British uni and his course is accredited by an engineering society/body etc - he’s still pretty worthless unless he has at least a PhD but ideally work experience as an engineer.
Good point, I am without a degree at the moment but I don't think it's worth the 4 years and ~£40,000 for a degree that at most will help with my immigration, especially since I will not use it during my stay. Hope definitely is not the strategy, I don't really understand what you mean?
I do have sympathy for your POV regarding degrees, especially since most graduates of even STEM subjects don’t end up with jobs that are particularly highly skilled or utilise knowledge from their degree. Nonetheless having real in-demand skills is important and a good degree is usually (for most people but not all) the first step in acquiring them, thus making an immigration application more likely to succeed but on it’s own a STEM degree is often not enough.
If you want to move to the US, for medicine or dentistry it’s best to just do your degree in the US or Canada on a student visa and then get a job as a doctor or dentist (it’s easy to work in either country with a degree from either country but it’s very expensive and time consuming since you need an undergrad life science degree first).
I can’t speak much for other careers but it may well be easier to do a degree in the US or Canada and then try to get a job so you can stay in the country however even if that’s feasible (definitely check) I presume it’s cost prohibitive especially due to lack of student loans.
There is a “cultural” difference between the USA and Europe as in instruction is a common if not the most common way in the USA to get started in aviation while in Europe it is much more of a niche employment.
Which means in the US probably 80+% of zero-CPL candidates do their instructor rating (CFI) also.
So instructors are a dime a dozen in the USA and it takes a lot of experience to stand out.
Like 2-3 years of ‘regular’ instruction followed by relevant experience in turbo props or jets to instruct in those.
Places like FlightSafety and Simuflight have people lined up around the block to become ground or simulator instructors on business jets.
Which means in the US probably 80+% of zero-CPL candidates do their instructor rating (CFI) also.
So instructors are a dime a dozen in the USA and it takes a lot of experience to stand out.
Like 2-3 years of ‘regular’ instruction followed by relevant experience in turbo props or jets to instruct in those.
Places like FlightSafety and Simuflight have people lined up around the block to become ground or simulator instructors on business jets.
Join Date: Feb 2024
Location: Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Posts: 5
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'd have to agree with the others that getting some higher education under your belt first would serve you well long term, especially if you're serious about pursuing a flying career abroad down the line. I know it's a big investment of time and money, but it may open more doors for you.