Tips for the perfect landing?
Guest
Posts: n/a
Piltdown Man
From the flight manual I'm looking at, the PA28-181 stall speed (full flap) is 49kias.
49 * 1.3 = 63.7
When they put digital speedos on with a resolution of .1 kts, I'll fly her at 63.7, until then, with middle aged eyesight and a small analogue ASI I'll make do with 65 - is that all right by you?
From the flight manual I'm looking at, the PA28-181 stall speed (full flap) is 49kias.
49 * 1.3 = 63.7
When they put digital speedos on with a resolution of .1 kts, I'll fly her at 63.7, until then, with middle aged eyesight and a small analogue ASI I'll make do with 65 - is that all right by you?
Guest
Posts: n/a
Vs 1.23.....
60.27knots .... mmmm
Personally I'd be happier trimming for 65 and then easing back to 60 over the fence using back pressure for a light aircraft.
60 "feels" a little further towards the back of the drag curve than I would be comfortable trimming for, as a go around might provide a sharp nose up pitching on the application of full power.
60.27knots .... mmmm
Personally I'd be happier trimming for 65 and then easing back to 60 over the fence using back pressure for a light aircraft.
60 "feels" a little further towards the back of the drag curve than I would be comfortable trimming for, as a go around might provide a sharp nose up pitching on the application of full power.
Last edited by Final 3 Greens; 28th Sep 2006 at 08:24.
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: He's on the limb to nowhere
Posts: 1,981
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Not in a warrior, it's 1.3 by regulation. I also think your landing comments are also more relevant to non-light aircraft operations. From observations made when sitting in the back, airline type aircraft do not land in the same way as a warrior
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: He's on the limb to nowhere
Posts: 1,981
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Best thing to do is trim for 63 (or whatever the correct speed is) some way out on final, and maintain that pitch by looking outside all the way down until you are ready to flare. When do you start to flare? Well, that depends, but it usually would be around 2 seconds before you would hit the ground if you didn't flare.
Other tips and tricks on when to flare appreciated
Gender Faculty Specialist
Not in a warrior, it's 1.3 by regulation.
I also think your landing comments are also more relevant to non-light aircraft operations...
airline type aircraft do not land in the same way as a warrior
Guest
Posts: n/a
The problem with these little tips is that what happens if there is no fence?
Not a tip, just a preference.
Fence = colloquial term for the 50' threshold crossing height from which the landing performance is calculated.
Trim speed is 64kias, I use 65 'cos there's no marking at 64.
Slim, time to take some contra-literal tabs
Not a tip, just a preference.
Fence = colloquial term for the 50' threshold crossing height from which the landing performance is calculated.
Trim speed is 64kias, I use 65 'cos there's no marking at 64.
Slim, time to take some contra-literal tabs
Last edited by Final 3 Greens; 28th Sep 2006 at 21:23.
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Oxford
Posts: 2,042
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
airline type aircraft do not land in the same way as a warrior
Tim
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Here and there. Here at the moment but soon I'll be there.
Posts: 758
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: He's on the limb to nowhere
Posts: 1,981
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Call me a hopeless romantic, but the 'fence' is the ricketty barb wired structure that was around the farmer's field back in the days when you would come in with your biplane at the heading which gave you a headwind. There may have been pieces of fence missing, probably due to people coming in at greater than book speed, and starting the flare at a silly height and rolling through the piece of fence at the opposite end.
So you say you start your pitch back to 60 when at 50ft. Back of a fag packet calculations say that approaching at 65knts on a three degree glideslope you are 1000ft out. That works out to be ten seconds out. Count ten seconds, it's a long time, far too early to be starting your flare.
If you aren't starting your flare and just messing with your speed, then you are too close to the field be finally adjusting your pitch, you should be stable a lot further out than 1000ft (or ten seconds).
IMHO of course.
A student should be trimming it up for 63knts (or whatever) a couple of miles out and should "cross the fence" at that speed. If you start your flare two seconds before you would hit the ground you are just over 10 feet AGL which seems far more sensible. 50ft AGL is too far out for a student to be messing with pitch and it will inevitably end up in tears. I am all ears for other suggestions.
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: UK,Twighlight Zone
Posts: 0
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I think I have to give up flying now, I did the 1st and therefore only perfect landing in 2000hrs of flying last night in the chippy, perfect approach speed, perfect flare and perfect 3 pointer touching down on the numbers and coming to a perfect short smooth stop. my passenger only realised we were on the ground when we stopped.
I think it best of I dont push my luck any more.....
I think it best of I dont push my luck any more.....
Guest
Posts: n/a
Slim
Were you p&ssed when you wrote your last post
Only a pillock (or inexperienced pilot) would drag a PA28 down a three degree glideslope from afar, if the engine quits, you won't make the threshold.
And I'm not talking about flaring, I'm talking about slowing the aircraft down to 60 knots by holding some extra back pressure instead of trimming very late in the approach. I believe that this is in line with Piper's advice for handling the PA28.
60kts = appx 27 metres per second and to get from 50 feet to 5 feet (at -600fpm) takes approx 4.5 seonds, which means you start the flare about 122m into the runway and touchdown in perhaps another 60-90m, following which you stop fairly smartly.
A an 2 mile final ?????????????? My last PA28 operating base gave a 1/2 nm final due to a CATZ, which is more than adequate for a SEP if you set up base correctly, as you said "From observations made when sitting in the back, airline type aircraft do not land in the same way as a warrior ."
Bose
Congratulations, I've never got near that smooth a landing, the best you can say aboutm ine is that they are safe.
Were you p&ssed when you wrote your last post
Only a pillock (or inexperienced pilot) would drag a PA28 down a three degree glideslope from afar, if the engine quits, you won't make the threshold.
And I'm not talking about flaring, I'm talking about slowing the aircraft down to 60 knots by holding some extra back pressure instead of trimming very late in the approach. I believe that this is in line with Piper's advice for handling the PA28.
60kts = appx 27 metres per second and to get from 50 feet to 5 feet (at -600fpm) takes approx 4.5 seonds, which means you start the flare about 122m into the runway and touchdown in perhaps another 60-90m, following which you stop fairly smartly.
A an 2 mile final ?????????????? My last PA28 operating base gave a 1/2 nm final due to a CATZ, which is more than adequate for a SEP if you set up base correctly, as you said "From observations made when sitting in the back, airline type aircraft do not land in the same way as a warrior ."
Bose
Congratulations, I've never got near that smooth a landing, the best you can say aboutm ine is that they are safe.
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Flirting with Angels
Posts: 38
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm suprised no one has said this yet...
If you walk away from it it is a good landing, if you can get in the crate to fly it again it's a brilliant landing surely that's the realy factor? Bringing yourself in alive and giving the clapped out Warrior back to the club for the next hapless victim, I mean student.
If you walk away from it it is a good landing, if you can get in the crate to fly it again it's a brilliant landing surely that's the realy factor? Bringing yourself in alive and giving the clapped out Warrior back to the club for the next hapless victim, I mean student.
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: Vancouver Island
Posts: 2,517
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Man, I had forgotten that I typed so much to get across a simple message.
Landings are all about " seeing " the only time " feeling " comes into the equasion is when the wheels touch the runway.
Landings are all about " seeing " the only time " feeling " comes into the equasion is when the wheels touch the runway.
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: New South Wales
Posts: 1,794
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Find a long, wide runway.
I rarely go near tarmac and usually screw up a landing on a long, wide runway now. In the Super Cub, I get the feeling that I am a helicopter hovering above these vast acres of tarmac and then I realise that although I am close to a helicopter, I still am not quite one! Crunch.
QDM
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Wor Yerm
Age: 68
Posts: 4
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Final 3 - Your numbers are fine and I assume that the manual you have is appropriate for your aircraft. I'll also not argue about a knot or two. But, as I'm sure you'll agree, each aircraft type and version has its own specific numbers and these are listed its handbook. Therefore, from a practical viewpoint, we should start with the books and then apply the information contained during flight. It is also important to use the speeds for your own specific aircraft obtained from its manual and not ones from Pprune ("Oh that's Okay your Honour. I used the performance data I got from an internet forum!"). I'll have to agree that from memory the stall speeds for most of the PA28 family is of that sort of order. But for many types, that is not the case. I think we have a duty to help people to do things properly, especially those who are learning!
PM
PM
Join Date: Apr 2000
Location: South Pacific
Posts: 17
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Some are nearly right
It is not the total responsibility of the pilot to land the aircraft.
The pilots job is to fly an accurate approach so that the runway dos not jump up and down and sway from side to side.
The pilots final responsibility is fly accurately from a good flare hight and fly as close to the ground as long as possible.
Do that and the aircraft will land itself
The pilots job is to fly an accurate approach so that the runway dos not jump up and down and sway from side to side.
The pilots final responsibility is fly accurately from a good flare hight and fly as close to the ground as long as possible.
Do that and the aircraft will land itself