PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   The Pacific: General Aviation & Questions (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions-91/)
-   -   Susi Air incident in Papua (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions/651234-susi-air-incident-papua.html)

grizzled 7th Feb 2023 18:38

Susi Air incident in Papua
 
This is a nasty situation for the pilot to be caught in, and potentially very dangerous for him.

https://www.wingsmagazine.com/separa...tage-in-papua/


Ascend Charlie 7th Feb 2023 21:37

Wow. Indonesia will not give up Papua just to save one Kiwi pilot, so sad. And these rebel dills think that something that Australia or NZ could do would influence the way the Indons treat the Papuans. Never happen.

I worked in Irian Jaya on the top left of the island, and regularly saw Indon soldiers armed with submachine guns looking aggressive when we landed in the boonies.

bluesideoops 8th Feb 2023 00:41

New Zealand Pilot Taken Hostage PNG
 
NZ caravan pilot taken hostage and threatened with execution!

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-64562315

Salusa 8th Feb 2023 01:48

Aerial shot of the airstrip at Paro village showing the Pilatus on fire.

OPM have apparently declared Nduga Regency where Paro is located a no fly zone.

No news since initial report but a lot of Police and Military movement in local area.




https://cimg9.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....c68ac9d31c.jpg

The Wawa Zone 8th Feb 2023 02:07

Salusa, is that a zoomed in satellite image and if so what is the link ?
The pilot would need to be doing all that he can to avoid being 'rescued' by Indonesian 'military' forces.

Salusa 8th Feb 2023 02:27


Originally Posted by The Wawa Zone (Post 11381990)
Salusa, is that a zoomed in satellite image and if so what is the link ?
The pilot would need to be doing all that he can to avoid being 'rescued' by Indonesian 'military' forces.

Image aparantly taken from an Indonesian Air Force Boeing 737-200. One always seems to around Papua and is active today.

Mumbai Merlin 8th Feb 2023 05:23

TV and print media report that the pilot has been taken as hostage and will be executed if the rebels demands are not met !

Mumbai Merlin 8th Feb 2023 05:37

New Zealand Susi Air pilot held hostage by separatist fighters in Papua, Indonesia | CNN

Pilot: Philip Merthens

Pinky the pilot 8th Feb 2023 07:50


will be executed if the rebels demands are not met !
I think that it should really be called murdered because that it precisely what it would be!:mad:

And regrettably, if such a criminal act was committed by the separatists, don't the 'separatists' realise that it would give the Indonesian Military a perfect excuse to go in with all available force with the sole aim of wiping out, to the last man/woman, the entire separatist movement?:hmm:

Something which I'm sure that Kopassa would absolutely love to do!!!

The Wawa Zone 8th Feb 2023 08:55


Originally Posted by Salusa (Post 11381994)
Image aparantly taken from an Indonesian Air Force Boeing 737-200. One always seems to around Papua and is active today.

Sal, thanks, and I betcha it can capture more than just visible light imagery such as this.

The Wawa Zone 8th Feb 2023 08:57

Pinky, one would like to think that the NZ military would join in as well with the clean up, if the Kiwi pilot got knocked off.

Salusa 8th Feb 2023 10:53

Cancel cancel cancel

Gary Brown 8th Feb 2023 11:07

Nothing about that threat in the article - indeed, quite the opposite.


Salusa 8th Feb 2023 11:09


Originally Posted by The Wawa Zone (Post 11382117)
Pinky, one would like to think that the NZ military would join in as well with the clean up, if the Kiwi pilot got knocked off.

They (OPM) won't knock him off. Forget about military intervention and gung ho.

It's just about $$$

​​​​​​Corruption at end of the day

My gut feeling is that he will be fine and released when all the media attention dies down.

The more attention we give them then the worse it gets m

And yes, I'm guilty of it to.

For now I'm sure Phillip will be fine and though in discomfort will be okay

chimbu warrior 8th Feb 2023 16:24

To be clear, this was in the Indonesian province of Papua, not in PNG. Two different countries.

Xhorst 8th Feb 2023 17:04


“Our new target are all foreigners: the US, EU, Australians and New Zealanders because they supported Indonesia to kill Papuans for 60 years. Colonialism in Papua must be abolished.”

The separatists have previously attacked and shot dead foreigners working for Freeport Indonesia, which operates the Grasberg mine in Mimika, one of the world’s largest gold and copper deposits.

Even before the kidnapping of the New Zealander, the TPNPB had been involved in a series of deadly attacks this year including the shooting of five military officers who were rebuilding a bridge in Maybrat, one of them was killed. They also set fire to a school in Oksibil, in the newly designated province of Highland Papua where Mehrtens was taken hostage, and shot at a cargo flight at the Oksibil airport as it was descending, forcing the pilot to abandon the landing.
https://www.theage.com.au/world/ocea...08-p5civk.html

​​​​​​​

grizzled 8th Feb 2023 19:52


Originally Posted by chimbu warrior (Post 11382348)
To be clear, this was in the Indonesian province of Papua, not in PNG. Two different countries.

Right on, Chimbu. Also, it was a Turbo-Porter, not a Caravan...

And if the OP had taken a brief look he would have seen the event had already been posted in an adjacent forum.

Sigh...

plutoo 8th Feb 2023 22:31

pprune won't let me quote but regarding the tracker map:

Please, please delete this, Phil is a friend and I've been receiving updates round the clock and still hadn't seen this til now, there's absolutely no reason to post this.

havick 9th Feb 2023 00:15

This sounds like a perfect job for the SAS?

TBM-Legend 9th Feb 2023 04:33


Originally Posted by plutoo (Post 11382534)
pprune won't let me quote but regarding the tracker map:

Please, please delete this, Phil is a friend and I've been receiving updates round the clock and still hadn't seen this til now, there's absolutely no reason to post this.

Hi is Phil related to Brett Mertehans who used work for me.

fingers crossed and prayers for him!

Salusa 9th Feb 2023 06:14

I have deleted as requested.

However the info was and is already in the the public domain on various Indo news media outlets and social media.

Apologies if it caused offence for anyone.

Sal

Zombywoof 9th Feb 2023 19:47


Originally Posted by chimbu warrior (Post 11382348)
To be clear, this was in the Indonesian province of Papua, not in PNG. Two different countries.

Thank you for that. Being thousands of miles/kms from said territory, I'm grateful for the clarification. It's hard sometimes to understand what goes on down there.

Cloudee 10th Feb 2023 06:57


Originally Posted by chimbu warrior (Post 11382348)
To be clear, this was in the Indonesian province of Papua, not in PNG. Two different countries.

Yeah, just another arbitrary line on a map draw by colonial powers dividing people and causing this sort of mayhem for decades into the future.

Pinky the pilot 10th Feb 2023 08:49


Yeah, just another arbitrary line on a map draw by colonial powers dividing people and causing this sort of mayhem for decades into the future.
Plus the acquiescence of various Countries in allowing Indonesia to claim the Territory for themselves after WW11. After all, it is shown in some maps as being 'West Irian.'

Incidentally, langtaimbak, a Friend used to fly from Wewak into Jayapura on a regular basis. He told me that once he walked into a Newagency/bookshop in Jayapura and happened to notice a School Atlas put out by the Indonesian Government for sale to Schoolkids. He picked it up and flicked through it. PNG was called "East Irian.'

Australia was listed as being 'South Irian.':hmm:

Curiously, the next time he went there, the Atlas was no longer for sale.

excrab 10th Feb 2023 13:09

The Indonesians weren’t the only ones who were liberal with the truth. I remember visiting what is now the Hillcrest school in Sentani and seeing that library books had been edited by blacking out references to things like dinosaurs, fossils and anything else which went against the teaching that God created the world in 6000BC.

Hopefully this will have a happy ending for the pilot, but it won’t for the OPM. The indigenous population of West Papua was abandoned by the UN during the “act of no choice”, and no governments outside of Indonesia care any more.

43Inches 10th Feb 2023 21:57


Originally Posted by Cloudee (Post 11383268)
Yeah, just another arbitrary line on a map draw by colonial powers dividing people and causing this sort of mayhem for decades into the future.

Even PNG is not stable, let alone the barely governed West Papua. They used helicopter gunships to protect the electrical and mine workers in the highlands for good reason. Life is very cheap for the locals and some very eye opening occurrences when locals disagree can end up in very violent endings.

Kagamuga 15th Feb 2023 01:27

BBC World News pictures

Video released of captured NZ pilot by Papua separatists - BBC News

chimbu warrior 15th Feb 2023 07:35

https://www.rnz.co.nz/international/...-nz-pilot-safe


"He is safe with our boys in the field, and everything is okay. He's staying with our friends and family at the ... headquarters. He has good skills, and we will look after him and he will train our soldiers for how to fly an aircraft."
​​​​​​​I hope the rebels understand that learning to fly takes more than a few days.............and destroying the aircraft adds a degree of complexity to their desire to become pilots.

RichardJones 15th Feb 2023 12:24

Must be getting to the stage now, if it hasnt happened already, Madam Susi's pilots in the region should cease flying in those areas.

grizzled 15th Feb 2023 15:23


Originally Posted by RichardJones (Post 11386222)
Madam Susi's pilots in the region should cease flying in those areas.

I certainly agree with that. But it would have to be a united action by the pilots (which is difficult to accomplish at Susi Air) because it is extremely difficult -- some would say impossible -- to get Susi herself to budge from a position based on risk.

Massey058 15th Feb 2023 17:36


Originally Posted by grizzled (Post 11386311)
I certainly agree with that. But it would have to be a united action by the pilots (which is difficult to accomplish at Susi Air) because it is extremely difficult -- some would say impossible -- to get Susi herself to budge from a position based on risk.

Well it's been done before and it can be done again.

grizzled 15th Feb 2023 18:10


Originally Posted by Massey058 (Post 11386400)
Well it's been done before and it can be done again.

Agreed, but as you must know, it's not easy in the given context.

Massey058 15th Feb 2023 18:12


Originally Posted by grizzled (Post 11386423)
Agreed, but as you must know, it's not easy in the given context.

Nope but Susi is in a weaker position to protest than she has been in the past.

Pinky the pilot 21st Feb 2023 23:23


Nope but Susi is in a weaker position to protest than she has been in the past.
Massey058; Got any info as to why? Genuine question btw.

Massey058 22nd Feb 2023 02:06


Originally Posted by Pinky the pilot (Post 11389516)
Massey058; Got any info as to why? Genuine question btw.

A few. But at a basic level the current global pilot market means that replacements for "insubordinate" pilots are not as easy to find. There has always been an acceptance that it's a challenging place to fly and the fatality rate across operators bares that out. This risk of being taken hostage will now be greater across the region and this is a much harder risk to avoid in some ways than avoiding CFIT, LOC-I or an overrun etc.

There is another fairly significant issue that I'll refrain from mentioning here but it does put the ball in the pilots court.

megan 22nd Feb 2023 05:08


There is another fairly significant issue
Makes you wonder if they've thought their tactics through, where would no air service leave them?

Massey058 22nd Feb 2023 05:23


Originally Posted by megan (Post 11389576)
Makes you wonder if they've thought their tactics through, where would no air service leave them?

​​​​​​For the TPNPB it doesn't seem they have and that probably doesn't concern them. They have bigger goals. Are they achievable? Probably not in their lifetimes. It will take a concerted global effort to achieve freedom for West Papua.

Hopefully a negotiation position can be found that enables this particular situation to end.
​​

Salusa 22nd Feb 2023 08:28

I have an update from an International Security consultancy firm.

I won't post here considering the last flak I got.

​​​​​​PM with professional credintials and I will consider sharing .

Obvoulsy no journalists.

​​​​​​

Office Update 22nd Feb 2023 08:48

Salusa, have you ever heard of social media, free to air newspapers, or even better still just Google ?

There is no secret !

Salusa 23rd Feb 2023 06:59

https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....bd18e2441d.jpg


All times are GMT. The time now is 20:54.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.