PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   The Pacific: General Aviation & Questions (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions-91/)
-   -   Susi Air incident in Papua (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions/651234-susi-air-incident-papua.html)

Cedrik 30th Dec 2023 04:26


Originally Posted by Mach E Avelli (Post 11564213)
People like pilots, merchant sailors, journalists etc often get to fly into dodgy places. It comes with the job. They are not stupid, irresponsible tourists, for whom much of the smart traveller advice is written. Are you saying that if an Aussie crew transiting some sh!thole country got thrown in jail or were taken hostage, our government shouldn't make noises to get them out?

You make my point, it comes with the job.

No I'm not saying governments shouldn't try and help but people go to those places with their eyes wide open.

Salusa 31st Dec 2023 12:48


Originally Posted by Cedrik (Post 11564238)
You make my point, it comes with the job.

No I'm not saying governments shouldn't try and help but people go to those places with their eyes wide open.

Between PNG, and Papua I have been around this region for almost 15 years+

My eyes are very much wide open.

Its my own humble opinion and most of the expat aviation community that I know in Papua, is that Phil has basically been abandoned and that the Kiwi government is neck down in sand with fingers in their ears singing la la la....

I also agree, that were Phil a citizen of USA, it would be different discussion..

I don't know Phil personally, I have never met him in person but I feel for him and I will continue to stir the pot as much as I am able.






Cedrik 31st Dec 2023 20:30


Originally Posted by Salusa (Post 11565113)
Between PNG, and Papua I have been around this region for almost 15 years+

My eyes are very much wide open.

Well then you will have seen or heard what's gone on in West Papua

Salusa 1st Jan 2024 07:44


Originally Posted by Cedrik (Post 11565280)
Well then you will have seen or heard what's gone on in West Papua

Indeed, I already mentioned that I believe?

Happy New Year.

chimbu warrior 6th Feb 2024 22:34

Today marks one year since this pilot was taken captive.

It also sadly shows the weakness of the NZ government. Garuda and Batik continue to fly into NZ; if the new government were serious about resolving this situation they would put a stop to that immediately.

Mach E Avelli 6th Feb 2024 23:34


Originally Posted by chimbu warrior (Post 11591827)
Today marks one year since this pilot was taken captive.

It also sadly shows the weakness of the NZ government. Garuda and Batik continue to fly into NZ; if the new government were serious about resolving this situation they would put a stop to that immediately.

How would that work? Neither of those airlines are owned by the rebels. The Indonesian Government is not going to roll over for one hostage. No government would.
Perhaps the Kiwi Government could take a leaf out of Israel's book and go lay waste to the rebels?
NZ is not Israel. They would.never dare infringe another sovereign territory without permission, and even if they got that permission it's unlikely that they have the expertise to do the job without the hostage being killed in the attempt, plus losing their own troops.
The best that NZ can do is support any Indonesian efforts to secure his release by fair means or foul - as odious as those efforts may be.

Massey058 6th Feb 2024 23:43


Originally Posted by chimbu warrior (Post 11591827)
Today marks one year since this pilot was taken captive.

It also sadly shows the weakness of the NZ government. Garuda and Batik continue to fly into NZ; if the new government were serious about resolving this situation they would put a stop to that immediately.

Not that it would happen anyway but neither Garuda nor Batik Indonesia fly to NZ. Batik Malaysia (Malindo) do fly Auckland-Perth though. But as they are on a Malaysian AOC not relevant.

josephfeatherweight 7th Feb 2024 09:31


it's unlikely that they have the expertise to do the job without the hostage being killed in the attempt, plus losing their own troops.
​​​​​​​That part I disagree with…

Kagamuga 14th Feb 2024 04:36

‘I love you’, scruffy hostage pilot tells family in video after a YEAR held captive by bow & gun-wielding jungle rebels | The Sun


Today's UK Sun, tabloid paper.


All times are GMT. The time now is 18:44.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.