PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   The Pacific: General Aviation & Questions (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions-91/)
-   -   TAS Border Control (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions/630730-tas-border-control.html)

nomorecatering 20th Mar 2020 10:37

TAS Border Control
 
Is the state of Tasmania constitutionaly able to close its borders. is any state able to do so.

I just did a quick check on NOTAMS, there's no prohibition on flying a private aircraft from any point in mainland to any point in Tasmania. If you don't put a plan in, they won't even know you did it.

Styx75 20th Mar 2020 10:42

Putin's selling S400 SAM systems to just about anyone these days...

Squawk7700 20th Mar 2020 11:00


Originally Posted by nomorecatering (Post 10721413)
Is the state of Tasmania constitutionaly able to close its borders. is any state able to do so.

I just did a quick check on NOTAMS, there's no prohibition on flying a private aircraft from any point in mainland to any point in Tasmania. If you don't put a plan in, they won't even know you did it.

I had an appointment in Burnie in the morning tomorrow and was going to fly a small single there... the ruling is apparently not excluding essential flight crew. I guess as the pilot I’m good to go! I will have to cancel to play it safe.

Turn off your transponder, iPad, iPhone, OZRunways and Avplan if you do!

Unprecedented times, who would have EVER imagined this and it’s just the start!

Sunfish 20th Mar 2020 11:32

Unfortunately Squawk is right.

Pearly White 20th Mar 2020 11:32


Originally Posted by Squawk7700 (Post 10721448)
I had an appointment in Burnie in the morning tomorrow and was going to fly a small single there... the ruling is apparently not excluding essential flight crew. I guess as the pilot I’m good to go! I will have to cancel to play it safe.

Turn off your transponder, iPad, iPhone, OZRunways and Avplan if you do!

Doesn't sound like a prudent measure for an over-water flight. Good luck with that!

swells 20th Mar 2020 11:56


Originally Posted by Pearly White (Post 10721483)
Doesn't sound like a prudent measure for an over-water flight. Good luck with that!

sure go for it ... if you land at an regional airport - expect someone to notice, expect someone to make a phone call to police... and yeah you might get away with it perhaps ... you might not too, and you won’t get any sympathy from the Govt who will use their full powers

peoole are scared, it’s not the time to prove a point

Okihara 20th Mar 2020 13:43

You can always be creative: Transponder off for the crossing, then touch and go at a small CTAF aerodrome, e.g. George Town in order to switch transponder on during the roll and on to Burnie. That's it, methinks.

Of course there will be a telling gap between flights if you look it up on the likes of flight radar but I'd like to think that government is currently busier doing more relevant things than running consistency checks on private GA aircraft.

Obviously, don't ask for SKEDS.

swells 20th Mar 2020 13:55


Originally Posted by Okihara (Post 10721607)
You can always be creative: Transponder off for the crossing, then touch and go at a small CTAF aerodrome, e.g. George Town in order to switch transponder on during the roll and on to Burnie. That's it, methinks.

Of course there will be a telling gap between flights if you look it up on the likes of flight radar but I'd like to think that government is currently busier doing more relevant things than running consistency checks on private GA aircraft.

Obviously, don't ask for SKEDS.

posts like this make me want you to have an engine failure enroute

Okihara 20th Mar 2020 14:17

Well that is not a very nice thing to say, swells.

cowl flaps 20th Mar 2020 14:46


Originally Posted by swells (Post 10721621)
posts like this make me want you to have an engine failure enroute

Lighten up, .. you goose.:rolleyes:

Asturias56 20th Mar 2020 16:11


Originally Posted by Styx75 (Post 10721422)
Putin's selling S400 SAM systems to just about anyone these days...

:ok: like it................

ZAZ 20th Mar 2020 16:41

Must be real important meeting make sure you are not dead on time.
FYi just looked at FR24 dozens of flights inbound to Melbourne from many carriers, cant be all freighters.
t

swells 20th Mar 2020 18:42


Originally Posted by Okihara (Post 10721645)
Well that is not a very nice thing to say, swells.

well if you’re gonna promote disabling safety features which are used to assist aircraft who cross bass strait routinely ... in order to attempt to go against what the state is doing ... even in jest, it’s not on

Dora-9 20th Mar 2020 19:51

Doesn't our constitution provide for "free and unfettered trade between the states"? Like nomorecatering, this one raised doubts of the legality of this move...

Sunfish 20th Mar 2020 21:09

Trade? You selling your body? Goods can move just not people.

Office Update 20th Mar 2020 21:50

Queensland Premier has just closed the Northern Territory to Queensland border!
(Saturday Cairns Post newspaper)

Lookleft 20th Mar 2020 22:30

The states closed their borders during the Spanish Flu pandemic in 1919/1920 so there is precedent. As the current restrictions show medical emergency trumps free and unfettered trade.

Squawk7700 20th Mar 2020 23:07

They aren’t stopping you flying there, you just have to isolate for 14 days... unless I’m mistaken on that.

Sunfish 21st Mar 2020 04:13

ScoMo is applying his marketing knowledge called “the Overton window”.

This is the range of policies that are possible at any given time:

‘A given policy is :-
  • Unthinkable, then
  • Radical, then
  • Acceptable,
  • Sensible,
  • Popular and finally
  • Policy.
For example we started with “no we won’t close our borders”, “well only to the Chinese”, “fourteen day voluntary quarantine”, “no europeans”, and after one or two more steps, “no foreigners and don’t leave Australia”.

Then “keep everything open”, “work from home”, “500 max”, “100 max”, “four square meters”, and now “maybe suburban lockdowns.”

That should tell you that we will be at total lockdown by the end of next weekend.

The Overton window approach is required to try and prevent the general population from panicking which would do more damage than Coronavirus.

Stickshift3000 21st Mar 2020 04:43

I think he’s actually started listening to the experts for once on this issue instead of making his usual smart ar$e response.

Edit: I agree that further restrictions will be in place in a week.

zanthrus 21st Mar 2020 08:58

Scummo can get stuffed! Life should go on. Steepen the curve and get this over with quicker.

Squawk7700 21st Mar 2020 09:40

Check NOTAMS for Flinders Island tomorrow. Strict entry requirements including flights from mainland Tasmania!

Capt Fathom 21st Mar 2020 09:48

YFLI . PPR from 19th Mar to 22nd Mar.

Is there more to come?

Asturias56 21st Mar 2020 10:00


Originally Posted by etrust (Post 10722481)
Is it possible the border closures are just a reflection of a common sense approach, and even if the resources are not necessarily there to police it, it is a sound policy to restrict infection? i.e. Use your own common sense in line with why it is being done?


Listening to teh BBC this morning they had a doctor on from Bergamo in Italy (he has the virus)

"This is not treatable by medical means. We have no inoculations, no injection, no medicine that stops this virus yet. Only isolation will stop or slow the spread"

Squawk7700 21st Mar 2020 10:40


Originally Posted by Capt Fathom (Post 10722699)
YFLI . PPR from 19th Mar to 22nd Mar.

Is there more to come?

All entry is likely to be via YFLI.

Sunfish 21st Mar 2020 10:42

Bergamo is one of my favourite cities - at least the old part. This is where Brembo brakes come from - the Brembo river runs past Bergamo. Such a tragedy.

Okihara 21st Mar 2020 12:38


Originally Posted by swells (Post 10721984)
well if you’re gonna promote disabling safety features which are used to assist aircraft who cross bass strait routinely ... in order to attempt to go against what the state is doing ... even in jest, it’s not on

I bet you're fun at parties.

Alice Kiwican 21st Mar 2020 21:39


Originally Posted by Office Update (Post 10722255)
Queensland Premier has just closed the Northern Territory to Queensland border!
(Saturday Cairns Post newspaper)

Actually NT government closing borders from 1600 24th March.....

flywatcher 21st Mar 2020 21:45

Okihara, don’t bother coming to Tasmania, we don’t want you.

Okihara 21st Mar 2020 23:10


Originally Posted by flywatcher (Post 10723428)
Okihara, don’t bother coming to Tasmania, we don’t want you.

Actually you're pretty funny too. You guys cousins? Or more than that?

De_flieger 22nd Mar 2020 03:17


Originally Posted by Okihara (Post 10721645)
Well that is not a very nice thing to say, swells.

It's not a very nice thing to say, but talking about how best to evade the infection control measures being put in place to try and slow a pandemic that has already killed thousands isn't a very nice thing to do either.

CharlieLimaX-Ray 22nd Mar 2020 03:33

Flightaware showing arrival of a Sharp Metro from Essendon and Launceston today.


flywatcher 22nd Mar 2020 06:19


Originally Posted by Okihara (Post 10723490)
Actually you're pretty funny too. You guys cousins? Or more than that?

You are more disgusting with every post. You should have a long hard look at yourself.

Squawk7700 22nd Mar 2020 07:15

The current YFLI NOTAM should end tomorrow and the new requirements for entry promulgated. Essential flight crew only and you need to be part of an essential service if you’re a passenger. They aren’t messing around with it.

swells 22nd Mar 2020 08:05


Originally Posted by Squawk7700 (Post 10723677)
The current YFLI NOTAM should end tomorrow and the new requirements for entry promulgated. Essential flight crew only and you need to be part of an essential service if you’re a passenger. They aren’t messing around with it.

The flinders island NOTAM is an overreaction, but in which the ARO thought they were doing the right thing - but no, and this is fear related ... it is what it is - and it should / will be withdrawn

Where as Okihara ... go lick a cruise ship or something you goose

sprocket check 22nd Mar 2020 09:06


Originally Posted by Sunfish (Post 10722500)

The Overton window approach is required to try and prevent the general population from panicking which would do more damage than Coronavirus.

This method is also used to prevent revolutions and public uprising as well as implement any draconian or freedom restrictive policy on the subjects. Sometimes they take longer and with smaller steps...

Sunfish 22nd Mar 2020 09:26

Nothing prevents you overflying king island and landing somewhere in Tasmania. What happens then is a different matter.

Capt Fathom 22nd Mar 2020 09:57


Originally Posted by Squawk7700 (Post 10722684)
Check NOTAMS for Flinders Island tomorrow. Strict entry requirements including flights from mainland Tasmania!

Still waiting!
I’m sure your source is correct! Just the timing is somewhat lacking. Maybe tomorrow!

Squawk7700 22nd Mar 2020 09:58


Originally Posted by swells (Post 10723704)
The flinders island NOTAM is an overreaction, but in which the ARO thought they were doing the right thing - but no, and this is fear related ... it is what it is - and it should / will be withdrawn

In case I wasn’t clear, to fly into Flinders Island you will have to land at Whitemark and get cleared and then fly on to any of the other strips on the island. You can’t go direct to the smaller strips.

Same goes when flying in from mainland Tasmania.

The above is not relevant for flying into mainland / the big island Tasmania.

Aussie Bob 22nd Mar 2020 10:38

PRIOR PERMISSION REQUIRED FOR ALL ITINERANT FLT LANDING AT FLINDERS
ISLAND AIRPORT
24/7 CTC: AD REPORTING OFFICER (PRIMARY) TEL: 0429 813 929 OR AD OPS
OFFICER (SECONDARY) TEL: 0448 953 514
FROM 03 190342 TO 03 222200 EST

Have I missed something Squawk? Where is the NOTAM saying you can't say land at.... name an ALA? The island is covered in them.


All times are GMT. The time now is 03:17.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.