PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Nimrod to go by March (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/399125-nimrod-go-march.html)

getsometimein 20th Dec 2009 10:44

Is it just me, or is this thread getting a little too close to capabilities....

Biggus 20th Dec 2009 10:57

We'll be alright as long as nobody mentions the shields or phasers.......damn, too late!!!

camelspyyder 20th Dec 2009 11:03

Biggus to be honest those systems seem more likely to be real than AUTOLYCUS-

an aircraft that sniffs for diesel fumes for chrissake!

Who'd believe that existed?

CS:)

Shack37 20th Dec 2009 11:14


Biggus to be honest those systems seem more likely to be real than AUTOLYCUS-

an aircraft that sniffs for diesel fumes for chrissake!

Who'd believe that existed?

I would, worked on the original, efficacy questionable but lots of room for tobacco products in the ioniser.

aw ditor 20th Dec 2009 11:47

Autolycus: useful for homing on the Ruhr when there was an easterly' in the North Sea. Rumour had it there was at least one "contact" during the Cuban Crisis. Don't knock it till youv'e tried it!

Vage Rot 20th Dec 2009 11:48

Still, at least we can afford to spend millions replacing CS95 with a new pattern DPM.


When I'm skint, I don't buy new clothes - mind you, the wife still does! Is there a woman in charge of defence?? what was wrong with the old stuff?

Biggus 20th Dec 2009 12:25

VR

Two sets of old stuff, greens and desert, only one set of new....

Cost saving measure (eventually)!!!

VMD+12 20th Dec 2009 15:47

Haddon - Cave demonstrated what happens when you make savings (take risk) without understanding the potential consequences. I think this 'gapping' of the Nimrod's long range SAR capability and SAR scene controller may tragically come home to haunt those who decided to risk this gap in capability without understanding the limitations of those assets said to be providing it in the meantime.

nigegilb 20th Dec 2009 17:18

Bringing forward Nimrod OSD was muted several months ago when the costs of getting the frames to an acceptable airworthiness condition became apparent. It was considered to be too expensive to fix. This is purely about trading off capability against cost. On paper there is a capability gap for a few short years, but there is a BIG risk in this decision. I am already hearing of problems with MRA4, (related to H-C). This is a calculated gamble, only time will tell if it is the correct decision. I and I suspect many others, would rather have seen the money spent on the existing airframe, which is already safer than it has been for many years.

Must be fairly desperate times in the Puzzle Palace...

Lyneham Lad 20th Dec 2009 17:35

Pedant mode on.


Bringing forward Nimrod OSD was muted several months ago
Presumably you really meant to write 'mooted' rather than 'muted'. At least I hope so!

muted
Function: adjective
Date: 1855
1 a : being mute : silent b : toned down : low-key, subdued

moot
Function: transitive verb
Date: before 12th century
1 archaic : to discuss from a legal standpoint : argue
2 a : to bring up for discussion : broach b : debate

Pedant mode off!

JamesA 20th Dec 2009 17:44

The Belgian Invasion
 
Old Fat One
Your retaliation has been scuppered - No more Eurostar till after Christmas. Obviously the Belgiques got wind of your masterplan.
However, I think they would have thwarted the Brits in the first place. Using their secret weapons, readily available at all good stores and pubs on the mainland i.e. excellent beers (real Belgiques don't drink Stella), and chocolates, what chance would U.K. stand.

davejb
I think you were taking a snipe at us Paddys. If it was a joke then I have bitten. Re WW2 and the Irish help, check how many allied aircrew were interned for the duration and how many senior British politicians and military staff were flown from Foynes to the U.S. and back. I think there was a fair amount of help for a 'neutral' country. Also, if a U-boat crew was ashore they were not at sea sinking allied ships - just a thought.

nigegilb 20th Dec 2009 17:53

Thanks LL, you have no idea how knackered I am tonight. You obviously have the same OCD issues as myself......Ha ha.

Nomorefreetime 20th Dec 2009 18:15

Platforms come and go...Bases get the chop...Lots more will be going in the next 10 years, but as always we overcome the problems.
I can imagine the uproar when the Flying Boats went out of service.("whats going to do its job now we can't land on the water")
Its a shame that a lot of the outgoing planes were British Built and will not survive to fly onwards like the Vulcan

davejb 20th Dec 2009 18:24

Sorry James,
whilst 'returned rather than interned' aircrew was the norm, and a fair few Irish citizens made their way north to enlist, de Valera also refused the RN the use of the treaty ports - given the urgency of the Battle of the Atlantic (especially when you note that some of the shipping under threat was destined to supply Eire) I still think that suggests it'd be a rather stupid strategy that relied on the Irish filling in any gaps in UK defence.

Eire | Oxford Companion to World War II | MyWire

- I'm not saying the Irish OUGHT to join in, I'm saying we'd be bloody stupid to rely on it.

bakseetblatherer 20th Dec 2009 21:15

@Biggus, I thought so to. But according to BBC the new uniform is only replacing the green stuff, desert will remain so still... 2 sets no money saved.

Could be the last? 20th Dec 2009 23:07

I assume that they will be changing the FRCS95 to match the new DPM?:confused:

The Old Fat One 21st Dec 2009 01:06


Old Fat One
Your retaliation has been scuppered - No more Eurostar till after Christmas. Obviously the Belgiques got wind of your masterplan.
Fear not, I have a back up plan. I've picked up a load of second hand 737s from some geezer called Elias Elias, I met in the pub.

PingDit 21st Dec 2009 02:17

Hang on a mo; I put down a deposit on those well before you!?

navibrator 21st Dec 2009 06:06


I hope you've got good cards Sirs.

PS Fortunately, your opponent is not the sharpest cookie in the box.
Trouble is he holds a trump card called The Treasury

bobward 21st Dec 2009 13:44

Boeing 737's
 
Here's a bit of thread creep.
Aren't Boeing building an ASW version of the Bo737 (P8?)
If we end up canning the MRA 4, what the betting that we get these instead?

...and, as a stop gap, people like EasyJet and Ryanair may have a couple we can lease. Look on it as training for the new tankers - you know, the ones we can lease to the airlines when the RAF are't using them.

Cynically yours.......


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:35.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.