PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   201 Sqn to be re-badged? (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/390467-201-sqn-re-badged.html)

FarQueueHall 28th Sep 2009 18:42

201 Sqn to be re-badged?
 
Heard a rumour today from a mate on 201 that the Boss plans to drop the words "Flying Boat Sqadron" from the Sqn crest and add "Guernsey's Own".

I know that it is known as "Guernsey's Own" but what a shame, unilaterally changing a sqn's history like that by altering the crest. Bloody young whipper-snappers.:rolleyes:

anita gofradump 28th Sep 2009 18:46

Will it make them any good?

hello1 28th Sep 2009 18:53

Not his badge, tis the Queen's. Therefore, not his call:=

Pontius Navigator 28th Sep 2009 19:19

True. It's a good way to unite the squadron:}

When I was on the Shinies we had just lost our 'B' Flt to centralised servicing but the one sqn Ldr on the sqn was OC "A" Flt. The sqn was 12(B) Sqn.

The boss, as we only had one 'flight' proposed dropping the OC "A" Flt and the 12(B) Sqn until someone pointed out what the (B) meant.

It is quite an education to walk down the gallery at the RAF Club and note the original sqn badges.

Union Jack 28th Sep 2009 19:46

Not his badge, tis the Queen's. Therefore, not his call

Absolutely right - HM takes a very close interest in such matters, all of which must receive Her personal approval and signature.

Jack

Spam_UK 28th Sep 2009 20:52

In fairness to the Boss,

I believe that the official squadron crests (i.e whats on the standards) no longer has "Flying Boat" on. Same as 42 no longer has "Torpedo Bomber" Etc. So he's not changing the Official Sqn Crest.

I still prefer it the way it is now though.

Vage Rot 28th Sep 2009 21:39

I'll have a look tomorrow - think there's a new standard on the offing soon though!

getsometimein 28th Sep 2009 21:42

Well I think he's fully entitled to change the sqn crest in terms of the badge worn by the aircrew... However he's not going to get the sqns flag changed...

Doesn't it read "Squadron" on the flag anyway, no F-B-S...

/me reaches for his "Flying Goat Squadron" badge.

lauriebe 29th Sep 2009 02:12

It seems that the official crest does indeed include the words "Flying Boat Squadron". See here:

Royal Air Force Heraldry Trust, the Squadron Badges List

snapper41 29th Sep 2009 07:31

Gentlemen, please; it's a BADGE, not a crest, and a STANDARD, not a flag!:ugh:

Wrathmonk 29th Sep 2009 07:47

I seem to recall there was a GAI / DIN a few years back (around the time that XIII Squadron reformed IIRC) that directed that the only squadrons that could include letters after their squadron number on badges (and I mean badges, for the use on flying suit:hmm:), letterheads etc were those officiclaly accredited with either being a BofB squadron (F) or an Army Co-operation Sqns (AC). The reasons given, I believe, were that in many instances the letters no longer reflected the true role of that particular squadron. This would not affect the official crest or standard though.

Perhaps someone with a bit more historical knowledge/memory may be able to shed more light on this?

Seymour Belvoir 29th Sep 2009 10:05

lauriebe,

From your link:

Royal Air Force Heraldry Trust, the Squadron Badges List

it would suggest that 84 Sqn should have the word 'Bomber' incorporated in the Sqn badge. The badge issued by the College of Arms dated April 1946 and approved by HM King George VI does not have 'Bomber' in it. I would suggest that that link is not the definitive list of RAF Sqn badges.

zedder 29th Sep 2009 10:36

Does anybody know the Latin for "It's not Ideal". 42 (Torperdo Bomber) Sqn might be looking to change what's at the bottom of our Badge the way things are going at the moment!

ian16th 29th Sep 2009 11:13

Is there a definitive source of Sqdn badges on the net?

Are the 'location' associations, such as ‘Guernsey’s Own’, permanent?

Of personal interest, 214 Sqdn, was ‘214 Federated Malaya States Sqdn’, on the badge this was abbreviated to ‘214 FMS Sqdn’. When I ordered my blazer badge, because I described it as 214 FMS Sqdn, the manufacturer assumed that I wanted the badge with a King’s crown. They seemed to think the ‘FMS’ was dropped by 1952, but during my time on the Sqdn, between 1959 and 65, ‘FMS’ was always on the badge.

Tea White Zero 29th Sep 2009 11:38

Surley there must be a link to current badges and standards on the net?!?!

All the ones I've seen so far ar Kings Crown?

TWZ:confused:

Gainesy 29th Sep 2009 12:24

"201 was affiliated with Guernsey in April 1939 as part of the Municipal Liaison Scheme" it sez here. Presumably selected with a pin by some Air Ministry blunty.

Interestingly (or not) 216Sqn was designated Bomber Transport Squadron.

J.A.F.O. 29th Sep 2009 13:15

And I'd never noticed the GR in front of 206 Sqn either.

It's a bloody shame if people start wiping out a unit's history, though (even if the unit is 201).

Wader2 29th Sep 2009 13:22


Originally Posted by Gainesy (Post 5221298)
"201 was affiliated with Guernsey in April 1939 as part of the Municipal Liaison Scheme" it sez here. Presumably selected with a pin by some Air Ministry blunty.

Given that the squadron was based at Calshot, IIRC, and that is not a hundred miles and less than a day's flying for a flying boat . . .

Besides, it doesn't have the same ring as Falmouth's Feckers.

Archimedes 29th Sep 2009 15:09

Air Ministry Orders in 1939 and then again in 1941 stopped the practice of including roles (e.g Flying Boat) in badges. In effect, there are two official badges - the current one, without a role included in the border and the old-style one.

Links with locations (74 [Trinidad]; 139 [Jamaica], etc, etc) were brought to an end in 1952.

There were several reasons for this - these included the fact that some squadrons had adopted these names for reasons which weren't entirely clear, and even the Air Ministry had been a bit too busy between 1939 and 1945 to see whether the link should be made official. Also, as it was appreciated that many squadron numberplates would disappear as the RAF reduced in size, there were concerns that disbanding a unit could cause problems, particularly if the unit had the name of a country in its title.

This didn't stop squadrons from continuing their links with other nations, though - when 139 disbanded, the Jamaican government demanded (as near as damn it) that the squadron be reformed instantly, since it was an insult to Jamaica. A polite 'don't tell us how to number our squadrons' missive was sent to the Jamaican govt, pointing out that no RAF squadrons had been known by their affiliation since 1952 (at least not officially, although they didn't say this), as the result of an AMO, and therefore, the FCO and their Airships regretted that 139 could not be granted special treatment - although there was a possibility (this was true) that it might appear as a Buccaneer squadron in due course.

By the by, II(AC) were at one point in breach of two AMOs - one which required all squadrons to use Arabic instead of Roman numerals, and another which said that a role, current or historic, shouldn't be stated in brackets after the number. II(AC) appear to have mislaid the instruction, and allowed the bureaucracy to come round to their way of thinking in due course...

monkeytamer 29th Sep 2009 16:53

It's not ideal but.. in latin
 
Zedder,
Some random internet converter thinggy came up with:

is est non specimen tamen

Probably has duff grammar and the likes...

MT

ian16th 29th Sep 2009 19:06

Archimedes

Links with locations (74 [Trinidad]; 139 [Jamaica], etc, etc) were brought to an end in 1952.
Are you aware if this was at the time of HMQ arriving on the throne and the change to the 'Queens Crown'?

Vage Rot 29th Sep 2009 19:52

The crest in the frame outside the Boss' office has the King's Crown and is signed by HRH Edward. It also has a blue Petrel as the bird where as the 201 Crest on the Kinloss website has a sh1tty purple colour bird!

Zedder, as for latin mottos, I could think of a few apt ones for 201 as well!

"Anarchos"
or even "201, magic carpet Sqn"!!!!!:}


FarQueueHall - thanks for bringing up the issue!

Archimedes 29th Sep 2009 20:07

Ian - the AMO was issued in June 1952 (and had to be repeated 10 years later because some squadrons were ignoring it...). AIUI, the study by the Air Ministry into the use of names had begun some time before, when George VI was still monarch, so the change of sovereign - and the type of crown - would appear not to have been the driving force from what I can ascertain.

Roland Pulfrew 30th Sep 2009 07:16

I believe it's GAI 1057 you want. Some relevant bits....


Original Unit Badge

1. A unit badge is recognised as such only after it has been accepted for registration by the Inspector of RAF Badges and by RAF Ceremonial and then been approved by Her Majesty The Queen. A unit wishing to register a badge is to submit an application in writing to HQ AIR to establish its eligibility. HQ AIR should then forward the application together with its recommendations to RAF Ceremonial. If there is any deviation from the criteria for eligibility, as outlined in para 2, HQ AIR is to make appropriate comment and state whether or not it supports the application.

Change of Unit Title

7. There will be cases where a unit, while retaining its original entity, undergoes a change in unit title. In such circumstances a unit wishing to have a new badge reflecting its current title may apply through HQ AIR to RAF Ceremonial for a new painting. The new painting, prepared under the direction of the Inspector of RAF Badges, termed a 'close copy' will show the amended title in the frame; the design and motto will not be altered. The painting will be signed by the Inspector of RAF Badges but will not be submitted to The Queen. It will be registered in the same way as an original unit badge.

FrustratedFormerFlie 30th Sep 2009 10:50

Latin
 
How about 'minor quam perficio' (literally 'less than perfect')

doubledolphins 30th Sep 2009 11:25

Is it a standard or a Colour? The Senior Service and the Pongos have Colours. The RNA and the RBL carry Standards.

Wander00 30th Sep 2009 12:28

There are currently Queen's Colours for the RAF, the RAF Regiment, the RAF College Cranwell and No1 S of TT Halton. There is also a Queen's Colour for the Air Training Corps. Squadrons gave "Standards".

enicalyth 30th Sep 2009 12:52

ah ... try this
 
'non est optime parumper venatus militis'


which is loosely translated as "sod that for a little game of soldiers"

on the other hand a good squadron might like 'testes canis sumus' which is

"we are the dogs b******s"

Aggamemnon 30th Sep 2009 12:54

The ATC do not have a Queen's Colour - the Air Training Corps Banner is equivalent to an RAF Squadron Standard.

doubledolphins 30th Sep 2009 14:56

Thanks for that. I did wonder. By the way, do 1 Squadron still call them selves "Fighter" squadron.

Gainesy 30th Sep 2009 15:35

Yes, aka "F Troop".:)

ian16th 30th Sep 2009 16:14

Archimedes

Thanks for that.

Seeing as my service only started on May 22 of that year, by the time that AMO came out, I probably still didn't know what an AMO was :D

Wander00 30th Sep 2009 18:01

Aggamemnon - you are so right - web site I checked on was incorrect - ATC=Corps Banner

Old-Duffer 1st Oct 2009 05:46

Between The Brackets
 
If it was ever reformed, would 44 (Rhodesia) Sqn become 44 (Zimbabwe) Sqn?

Shack37 1st Oct 2009 16:54


Yes, aka "F Troop".

I think the late 206 Sqn rejoiced in that nom de guerre for a while.

camelspyyder 1st Oct 2009 17:04

I think you mean't the recently reformed 206 Sqn surely?

CS

Shack37 1st Oct 2009 20:38


I think you mean't the recently reformed 206 Sqn surely?


Must have missed that good news, more info appreciated.

Shirley:)

AQAfive 1st Oct 2009 22:32

F Troop
 
It was 120 Sqn who had that unofficial monica in the early 70's. It mainly came about because a certain bold boss of 201 creamed off all the experienced Shack men from the OCU, leaving CXX to struggle with 1st tourists.

What goes around comes around and 5 yrs later it was somewhat reversed.

Archimedes 1st Oct 2009 23:28

Shack - 206 - to be specific 206(R) - is now the numberplate of what used to be the Heavy Aircraft Test Squadron. A bit more detail here

Charlie Luncher 2nd Oct 2009 00:30

Phew:O
At least no one has mentioned the dark days of the nineties when we had the pink float:ugh: bugger:sad:
Charlie sends
CXX should have added the tactical sword to theirs


All times are GMT. The time now is 19:04.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.