EP-3 Hainan Incident 2001
I don't own this space under my name. I should have leased it while I still could
Interesting indeed. One item drew my attention; the Chinese did not immediately change the comma procedures.
That could be a subtle ploy and a method of letting false data being collected. This ploy was used in WW 2 though should have been less effective in this case as the Chinese would know the US knew they knew.
That could be a subtle ploy and a method of letting false data being collected. This ploy was used in WW 2 though should have been less effective in this case as the Chinese would know the US knew they knew.
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: bristol
Age: 56
Posts: 1,051
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I remember reading about this at the time. I was surprised to hear just how little effect the axe could have made to prevent data being read from the hard drives after they were retrieved.
“If I would have put it in the water, it would have killed us all,” he told The Intercept. “I had no flaps [to slow the plane],
I always wondered whether zero flap was the way to go given that it had been proven empirically to work (albeit once on type), rather than theoretically.
Last edited by Avtur; 11th Apr 2017 at 23:32.
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: N London
Posts: 120
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Certainly an interesting read. I see the US has not learn t from the USS Pueblo (AGER-2) report about the amounts of unnecessary documents and code keys carried.
They also had a similar problem because they were carrying keys for Crypto that was not only compromised to the N Vietnamese and thus the soviets but they had lots of it inc KY28s so could read the mail for potentially months. They got the kit when they overran a store containing lots of it,
Whilst at a St Mawgan we had a go at destroying some old kit with a fire axe and we were well up for it. But we soon found out even with a lump of concrete to work on and not an aircraft deck or equipment rack it was slow work and not particulary effective. Lots of damaged cases but many PCBs intact
The same time we tried burning a pile of old obsolete un-classified documents in a bin with the approved destruction equipment. (1 Jerry can of waste fuel and a box of matches) to see how effective it was. It took ages and also was not effective, lots of document pages could still be read after we raked out the ashes. This was an experiment to see how long it would take us to destroy 1 cabinets worth of documents and spare kit. The conclusion was It took longer that we were allowed and was wholly ineffective. I see nothing has really changed.
I see that vehicle denial has moved up a bit though. I was reading that the recommended denial process for specialised vehicles is grenades inside.
Now that would be fun to have a go at !
They also had a similar problem because they were carrying keys for Crypto that was not only compromised to the N Vietnamese and thus the soviets but they had lots of it inc KY28s so could read the mail for potentially months. They got the kit when they overran a store containing lots of it,
Whilst at a St Mawgan we had a go at destroying some old kit with a fire axe and we were well up for it. But we soon found out even with a lump of concrete to work on and not an aircraft deck or equipment rack it was slow work and not particulary effective. Lots of damaged cases but many PCBs intact
The same time we tried burning a pile of old obsolete un-classified documents in a bin with the approved destruction equipment. (1 Jerry can of waste fuel and a box of matches) to see how effective it was. It took ages and also was not effective, lots of document pages could still be read after we raked out the ashes. This was an experiment to see how long it would take us to destroy 1 cabinets worth of documents and spare kit. The conclusion was It took longer that we were allowed and was wholly ineffective. I see nothing has really changed.
I see that vehicle denial has moved up a bit though. I was reading that the recommended denial process for specialised vehicles is grenades inside.
Now that would be fun to have a go at !
I don't own this space under my name. I should have leased it while I still could
The Vulcan had a panel, front left near the radome labelled Destructor. Never found out if it could be activated or how it would work though one rumour was explosive charges in the fuel tanks. It could not be reached unless the undercarriage was retracted. A similar device would not havevy worked in the P3 case.
Wonder why stuff was not just jettisoned. It might have been recoverable but not easily.
Wonder why stuff was not just jettisoned. It might have been recoverable but not easily.
Ecce Homo! Loquitur...
Thread Starter
At the subsequent Courts Martial.
"Did you attempt to destroy the Top Secret documents in accordance with your standing instructions."
"No sir - we just threw them out the door intact".
You attempt to destroy them IAW SOPs and it doesn't work - not your problem.
You attempt to destroy them any other way and it doesn't work - definitely your problem.
"Did you attempt to destroy the Top Secret documents in accordance with your standing instructions."
"No sir - we just threw them out the door intact".
You attempt to destroy them IAW SOPs and it doesn't work - not your problem.
You attempt to destroy them any other way and it doesn't work - definitely your problem.
I don't own this space under my name. I should have leased it while I still could
ORAC, as it happens, during training our paper work was shredded out of the window.
We would write out the airways crossing requests on a proforma and pass this to the pilot 10 minutes in advance. This was the duty of the 2nd nav. Once finished the pilot would crack the side window open and feed the paper into the air flow where it would be shredded.
We would write out the airways crossing requests on a proforma and pass this to the pilot 10 minutes in advance. This was the duty of the 2nd nav. Once finished the pilot would crack the side window open and feed the paper into the air flow where it would be shredded.
Ecce Homo! Loquitur...
Thread Starter
As an aside we used large ledger type books as diaries and log books at the CRCs. Impossible to destroy locally so we shipped them off regularly to the RN at Faslane who apparently had an industrial scale shredder.
When it came to be replaced after many years and was removed it was found to have broken somewhere inside allowing some items inserted to fall through; and in the foundations beneath were found a very large quantity of intact diaries and log books dating about 10 years....
When it came to be replaced after many years and was removed it was found to have broken somewhere inside allowing some items inserted to fall through; and in the foundations beneath were found a very large quantity of intact diaries and log books dating about 10 years....
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: New Braunfels, TX
Age: 70
Posts: 1,954
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
A quick and sure method of destroying paper documents is to fill a large trash can half full with water, drop in the documents, and then use a paint stirring attachment on an electric drill to stir the mess. Job done in 1 to 2 minutes. Dump out the pulp and repeat as necessary.
Last edited by KenV; 12th Apr 2017 at 16:11.
I don't own this space under my name. I should have leased it while I still could
On burning, I used to use an incinerator. After burning one particular document to returned to my office to find a large carbonised sheet, about 6x4 inches and perfectly legible, that had blown 100 yards and entered my office through the ventilation fan.
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: New Braunfels, TX
Age: 70
Posts: 1,954
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: New Braunfels, TX
Age: 70
Posts: 1,954
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If you think that's messy, try burning documents in your kitchen or garage. Even burning on a patio or back yard is messier than the water method. And if you do the job in a 5 gallon bucket, you can safely flush the pulp slurry down the toilet. No more mess.
Last edited by KenV; 12th Apr 2017 at 17:11.
In my filing cabinets in a faraway place....
.....there were thermite grenades. Had we ever had to evacuate the trick was to slam all the drawers shut and pull the red T-handle and run away. Thankfully we never had to do it.
And if you think that having to account for missing crypto is a PITA, try finding it two months later, exactly where it SHOULD have been (after five fingertip searches). Don't ask me how I know.
The Ancient Mariner
And if you think that having to account for missing crypto is a PITA, try finding it two months later, exactly where it SHOULD have been (after five fingertip searches). Don't ask me how I know.
The Ancient Mariner
I don't own this space under my name. I should have leased it while I still could
Rosarian, or where the custodian issued only 2 days at a time but crews who needed day 3 would get a photocopy from another unit. The custodian tore out what little hair he had left when we returned photocopies.
Ecce Homo! Loquitur...
Thread Starter
When I were a Fg Off at 280SU in Cyprus I were OIC Docs. We had quite a few cabinets; when during the Turkish kerfuffle they shut down Gata they shipped everything the had up the hill - there was no proper check and the then OIC refused to sign for them - but they left them anyway.
4 years later CENTO was folding and a signal arrived saying all such docs had to be treated at one level above their face classification - which meant I now had a cabinet of TS docs. Problem - we had nowhere to store them and I wasn't cleared to read or check them.
After intense discussion with Episcopi - decision, destroy them all and date the day before signal. Result! So start page checking and find dozens of missing pages and amendments. Pull out drawers and find lots of additional bits and pieces at back - Stn Cdr 's eyes-only*, etc etc.
I had weekly visits by the plods from Episkopi over the following weeks and months as I checked more and more of the documents - they trying to pin everything on me because I should have picked everything up in the one day I signed for them and me pointing out where many of the errors had occurred years before.
It was eventually all swept under the carpet - but they did come back for me years later on other more personal matters - but that's another story.
*Such as a book of lists of prohibited organisations of which serving personnel had to be reported as being members.
4 years later CENTO was folding and a signal arrived saying all such docs had to be treated at one level above their face classification - which meant I now had a cabinet of TS docs. Problem - we had nowhere to store them and I wasn't cleared to read or check them.
After intense discussion with Episcopi - decision, destroy them all and date the day before signal. Result! So start page checking and find dozens of missing pages and amendments. Pull out drawers and find lots of additional bits and pieces at back - Stn Cdr 's eyes-only*, etc etc.
I had weekly visits by the plods from Episkopi over the following weeks and months as I checked more and more of the documents - they trying to pin everything on me because I should have picked everything up in the one day I signed for them and me pointing out where many of the errors had occurred years before.
It was eventually all swept under the carpet - but they did come back for me years later on other more personal matters - but that's another story.
*Such as a book of lists of prohibited organisations of which serving personnel had to be reported as being members.