The 'dying' Royal Navy; what the US can learn.
Deeply depressing. I used to go past Devonport in the train and look at the warships and joke to Mrs TTN - "that's probably the whole of the fleet in there".
Now it seems I wouldn't be too far off
Now it seems I wouldn't be too far off
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: London
Posts: 7,072
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
That's what happens when Governments prioritise tax cuts and handouts (education, social security, pensions) over defence
No-one goes into bat for defence and the Ministers are all second raters with no stroke
No-one goes into bat for defence and the Ministers are all second raters with no stroke
"No votes in defence" - allegedly.
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: Home
Posts: 3,399
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Hampshire
Age: 78
Posts: 211
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I undersatand from an Authority close to a Cmdr (E) up at the Clyde ,that the Modules once built at Portsmouth,then transported up to Scotland,sometimes dont marry up to their counterparts.Even watertight doors are not able to actuate in their slots,and then small items like a Plinth onto which a Phalanx mounting is bolted,has its bolt holes not lining up with its flange plate,so someone could not even drill out from a template accurately.I suppose when the Aircraft wont arrive until 2020,someone can redo the job properly!!!!Can hope I suppose,but the sooner eveything is removed fom the Wicked Witch of the North's domain and returned South,then maybe we can have a Navy that will work!!!??
No-one goes into bat for defence and the Ministers are all second raters with no stroke
Billions have been chucked away on a university system where thousands of academically mediocre students are pushed through and given joke degrees. Meanwhile if we suddenly decided we were going to seriously invest in defence, would there be a sufficiently large skilled workforce to make the kit?
(btw PPRuNe spell checker, its defence on this side of the pond, not defense
)
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Hanging off the end of a thread
Posts: 33,105
Received 2,952 Likes
on
1,259 Posts
The bit that rankles is when politicians witter on that we may have less ships but they have greater capability and weaponry.
Great, but it doesn't hold water when you need one ship covering the South Atlantic and one in the Gulf region, and you have replaced the two lesser capable ships with one, that cannot be in two places at once.
Great, but it doesn't hold water when you need one ship covering the South Atlantic and one in the Gulf region, and you have replaced the two lesser capable ships with one, that cannot be in two places at once.
I undersatand from an Authority close to a Cmdr (E) up at the Clyde ,that the Modules once built at Portsmouth,then transported up to Scotland,sometimes dont marry up to their counterparts.Even watertight doors are not able to actuate in their slots,and then small items like a Plinth onto which a Phalanx mounting is bolted,has its bolt holes not lining up with its flange plate,so someone could not even drill out from a template accurately.
Issues with marrying up large blocks will always arise. The difference in doing them between different shipyards is that it gets contractual rather than just the heads of the steel fab and shipbuilding departments in one shipyard having a shouting match and then just fixing the problem. Mountains and molehills one suspects - possibly compounded by RN personnel with limited experiences of working in build yards (as opposed to refit).
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Hanging off the end of a thread
Posts: 33,105
Received 2,952 Likes
on
1,259 Posts
Maybe there reducing section sizes as the budget shrinks 
Billions have been chucked away on a university system where thousands of academically mediocre students are pushed through and given joke degrees.
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: England
Posts: 908
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
In a roundabout way, Mr Putin and his foreign ventures just might help these things change. I wander how an electorate that is forced to send £15 billion abroad as aid, is told there isn't enough money to defend them whilst they sleep.
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Racedo blows goats
Posts: 677
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Perhaps our technological edge is being eroded:
Are Russia's military advances a problem for Nato? - BBC News
Are Russia's military advances a problem for Nato? - BBC News
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Moscow region
Age: 65
Posts: 567
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
What a quick diversion from the RN to Russian army :-)
Engineer, please, look at the author of that artice - "a diplomatic correspondent" talking about electronic warfare :-) Plus an abracadabra about "Russian military operations in Ukraine". The guy is totally inconsistent: if the Russians are so smart, why did not they overtake Kiev in two days? The answer is obvious: there are no regular Russian troop in Ukraine :-) Advisors, some volunteers - yes, but on the other side there are many NATO advisors and volunteers from West and nobody cries about that.
Coming back to RN, this is probably a reflection of the "threat model" currently used by the politicians. Clearly it is not needed as far as Russia is concerned, but (from a trespasser point of view) regarding issues like Falklands, it should be kept in a good shape....
Engineer, please, look at the author of that artice - "a diplomatic correspondent" talking about electronic warfare :-) Plus an abracadabra about "Russian military operations in Ukraine". The guy is totally inconsistent: if the Russians are so smart, why did not they overtake Kiev in two days? The answer is obvious: there are no regular Russian troop in Ukraine :-) Advisors, some volunteers - yes, but on the other side there are many NATO advisors and volunteers from West and nobody cries about that.
Coming back to RN, this is probably a reflection of the "threat model" currently used by the politicians. Clearly it is not needed as far as Russia is concerned, but (from a trespasser point of view) regarding issues like Falklands, it should be kept in a good shape....