Random Alcohol Breath Testing for the RN
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: inside the train looking onto the platform.
Posts: 195
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Random Alcohol Breath Testing for the RN
I see in todays Torygraph that "RN Commanding officers will be given equipment to enable spot checks to be carried out to ensure sailors are not reporting for duty drunk". I wonder if this will become a pan defence policy? Surely it has merit when you consider the state some of those working on aircraft and 'crewing in' down route and 'on det' turn in for duty especially when there is less supervision away from hombase. Albeit the minority I might add.
There still pervades in the minority the belief that this is all part of service life; it certainly was a few years ago and I was as guilty as anyone. However, in todays post Haddon Cave environment surely it wouldnt be too hard to tweak the CDT teams to also test for alcohol on personnel.
I for one would welcome it.
There still pervades in the minority the belief that this is all part of service life; it certainly was a few years ago and I was as guilty as anyone. However, in todays post Haddon Cave environment surely it wouldnt be too hard to tweak the CDT teams to also test for alcohol on personnel.
I for one would welcome it.
We have had post-incident drug and alcohol testing in the RAF for years and the net is thrown quite wide to include support staff, ATC etc. Mil crews are also subject to overseas random testing too. I for one have been test in the USA and it gets your attention when it happens.
Join Date: Nov 2000
Location: Deepest Kernow
Posts: 15
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It's not random testing that's being introduced but will be an option for confirming the suspicion of being unfit for duties due to alcohol and included in the Armed Forces Act, so will be pan-defence. The limiits are going to be more widely briefed soon but are in line with UK Drink-drive laws for non-safety critical duties and "effectively zero" for safety critical (inc aircrew, ATC & engineers) personnel.
I don't own this space under my name. I should have leased it while I still could
IIRC the AFA only required for an officer to charge someone with being drunk. This was years before drink-driving or breathalysers. Clearly there were margins for error and probably erring on the too lenient rather than the too strict.
Has that now changed?
Has that now changed?
It's come about post-ASTUTE shooting. The man who shot the WEO was still over the limit (or very near to it) when he signed for his rifle. It's quite hard to determine, as Officer of the Day, the morning after is someone is over the limit or under it.
As someone who will be affected by this, I can only approve to be honest.
As someone who will be affected by this, I can only approve to be honest.
IIRC the AFA only required for an officer to charge someone with being drunk. This was years before drink-driving or breathalysers. Clearly there were margins for error and probably erring on the too lenient rather than the too strict.
"He was unsteady on his feet, his breath smelled of alcohol and his speech was slurred. Sir, he was drunk"
Another nail in the coffin of morale in that all events involving alcohol I.e. Thursday bops, exchange drinks, games nights and mess functions will have to move to the weekends where no-one will go to them. I'm not advocating people turning up drunk for duty however if a level of zero alcohol. in the blood stream is used for critical staff then it in effect introduces a drinking ban for them mon-fri or any other flying days and as we all know in the interests of fairness we'll all get tarred with the same brush.
Another nail in the coffin of morale in that all events involving alcohol I.e. Thursday bops, exchange drinks, games nights and mess functions will have to move to the weekends where no-one will go to them.
So, when it was put to the vote at an extraordinary mess meeting, the beanstealers lost and dining-in nights continued to be held on Fridays...
I once had an Annual Medical the morning after the medical centre's midweek Christmas function. The quack was clearly suffering; he reeked of stale booze and was sweating like a pig. So when it came to the usual question "How much do you drink in a week?", I simply replied "A damn sight less than you did last night!".....
No reason for mid-week functions to end. It just means people will need to exercise self-discipline.
Red On, Green On
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Between the woods and the water
Age: 24
Posts: 6,487
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Another nail in the coffin of morale in that all events involving alcohol I.e. Thursday bops, exchange drinks, games nights and mess functions will have to move to the weekends where no-one will go to them.
Trust me - it's not true.
An average male starting at 19.00 can have two pints, two glasses of wine and two singles of spirits and be completely clear of alcohol by 07.00 the following morning.
Most professional civilians don't drink all that much mid-week. A lot I know just have a glass of wine with their evening meal, if that. There's no reason why people in uniform should be any different.
Join Date: May 2006
Location: 2 m South of Radstock VRP
Posts: 2,042
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Yet another, predictable, knee jerk response to a less than once a Preston Guild incident. As Beagle said, the real key is self discipline.
So you can turn to after extended watches/duties (or, otherwise, little sleep from having a real life off duty) totally knackerd, so long as you're stone cold sober?
So you can turn to after extended watches/duties (or, otherwise, little sleep from having a real life off duty) totally knackerd, so long as you're stone cold sober?
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: South of England
Age: 74
Posts: 627
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
4 Posts
You and BEagle are right the real key is self discipline; shouldn't drink too much. Trouble is, after too many sherbets, self discipline tends to wane.
Then his or her buddies really should look after him or her for everyone's sake. Doesn't always happen.
I remember a General Court Martial, yonks ago, where a regiment gunner came off duty, had a fight with his girlfriend and then got absolutely arxxholed.
His weapons authorisation chit had 4 hours to go and so he went to the armoury and drew a 9 mm Browning and some ammo. His buddies in the Armoury ignored the fact that he could hardly stand up and issued the stuff anyway; because his chit was still current!
He then went on a rampage across the station. Eventually he was persuaded to hand over his weapon by a very courageous Sgt rock.
He went down for 4 1/2 years in civvy prison, for firearm offences and threats to kill - but it all wouldn't have happened if the armourers had said "no you're too pissed - go back to the block and get some rest".
Rgds SOS
Then his or her buddies really should look after him or her for everyone's sake. Doesn't always happen.
I remember a General Court Martial, yonks ago, where a regiment gunner came off duty, had a fight with his girlfriend and then got absolutely arxxholed.
His weapons authorisation chit had 4 hours to go and so he went to the armoury and drew a 9 mm Browning and some ammo. His buddies in the Armoury ignored the fact that he could hardly stand up and issued the stuff anyway; because his chit was still current!
He then went on a rampage across the station. Eventually he was persuaded to hand over his weapon by a very courageous Sgt rock.
He went down for 4 1/2 years in civvy prison, for firearm offences and threats to kill - but it all wouldn't have happened if the armourers had said "no you're too pissed - go back to the block and get some rest".
Rgds SOS
Last edited by SOSL; 25th Mar 2013 at 14:59. Reason: units
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: inside the train looking onto the platform.
Posts: 195
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Self Discipline
The self discipline argument is flawed byt he actions of those who get on a bender on a monday nt are still in the bar at 0200, have met brief at 0830 and are at their desk, on the hangar floor or in a cockpit that morning....it still happens and I saw it happen no less than a month ago in Oxfordshire. Drts are even worse for a complete ack of self discipline, we all know that and still see it. When you try to remonstrate down or up the CoC it goes something like, 'look we will just put him on admin duties, no he hasnt worked on any aircraft this morning but yes he is still in work, hey do you really want to push this and ruin his career. I still remeber the ginger beer refusing to man the start of an aircraft as he believed the aircrew were unfit to fly......but that was in 2007.
The fact that iaw the AFA you can now request a breath test of an individual at work then I am all in favour of it and it wont hit morale, it hasnt in the ATC world and they are to my mind the most observant of the regs regarding alcohol.
The morale argument doesnt wash, the self discipline argument doesnt wash and I for one am glad that if he/she reports for duty, reeks of alcohol he can be random breath tested then the dangerous part of what we do might become a little safer.
The fact that iaw the AFA you can now request a breath test of an individual at work then I am all in favour of it and it wont hit morale, it hasnt in the ATC world and they are to my mind the most observant of the regs regarding alcohol.
The morale argument doesnt wash, the self discipline argument doesnt wash and I for one am glad that if he/she reports for duty, reeks of alcohol he can be random breath tested then the dangerous part of what we do might become a little safer.
I've been trying to find a report written in c2008, possibly by KCL, highlighting the extent of 'problem drinking' in the Navy. The percentage figures of those who regularly get blind driunk (which I won't try to recall) were simply staggering.
Echoing other posts, friends of mine in the City generally confine drinking almost exclusively to Friday and Saturday nights. Turning up for work 'worse for wear' is one step closer to being sacked these days.
Echoing other posts, friends of mine in the City generally confine drinking almost exclusively to Friday and Saturday nights. Turning up for work 'worse for wear' is one step closer to being sacked these days.