UK at risk from sea-borne attack, says Commons Defence Ctee
Red On, Green On
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Between the woods and the water
Age: 24
Posts: 6,487
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
UK at risk from sea-borne attack, says Commons Defence Ctee
BBC NEWS | Politics | UK 'at risk of sea-borne attack'
Given the length of coastline, it's hardly going to be possible to police it just from the surface. Some kind of air component would be needed surely?
Given the length of coastline, it's hardly going to be possible to police it just from the surface. Some kind of air component would be needed surely?
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: bored
Posts: 532
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Some kind of air component would be needed surely?
The Italians recently identified a similar issue - they too have a long coastline to patrol and the job currently shared between navy, guardia di finanza, and coastguard, with lots of different aircraft. They've started a process to bring the assets under a central coordination centre. They're also looking at DA42 MPP with look-down radar as a cheap solution with long range and endurance.
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: West Sussex
Posts: 1,771
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If I'm not mistaken we currently use Nimrods and 'other' aircraft & platforms, a true case of combined forces ?
I can say from experience, approaching the Southern English coast at night in my little - one might think stealthy - sailing boat with no lights on ( the battery was u/s ) we soon got hovered over by an equally unlit Lynx.
I'm always surprised when yachties with tall masts - stand by for the ooh er, missus comments - are asked to buy ever more expensive radar reflectors, while in WWII a U-Boat's periscope was recognisable ; and radar is of course not the only sensor available.
I can say from experience, approaching the Southern English coast at night in my little - one might think stealthy - sailing boat with no lights on ( the battery was u/s ) we soon got hovered over by an equally unlit Lynx.
I'm always surprised when yachties with tall masts - stand by for the ooh er, missus comments - are asked to buy ever more expensive radar reflectors, while in WWII a U-Boat's periscope was recognisable ; and radar is of course not the only sensor available.
Red On, Green On
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Between the woods and the water
Age: 24
Posts: 6,487
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
As the article suggests, there needs to be a centralised structure to coordinate the various assets.
I don't own this space under my name. I should have leased it while I still could
Interesting. I attended a security briefing two weeks back. Quite boring until they started passing out IEDs. However their view, it was at a local sea port, was that the maritime threat to the UK was next to non-existent. They rejected the idea that a ship might be hijacked, equipped as a bomb, and then driven into a port.
They also suggested that Arabs would get sea sick and be unable to sail a ship from the Indian Ocean. I, and a number of port maritime officials were greatly reassured by the brief.
They also suggested that Arabs would get sea sick and be unable to sail a ship from the Indian Ocean. I, and a number of port maritime officials were greatly reassured by the brief.
The Commons defence committee suggests developing a "deterrent capability" to ward off sea-borne attacks.
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: West Sussex
Posts: 1,771
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Melchett,
I suspect that while RAF Coastal Command do well, it would have been handy if we still had a Navy & Fleet Air Arm.
Touching wood it's notable that the FAA traditionally get shafted just before a major war !
We do have more assets than publicised, mostly airborne, as every other country does.
As to turning merchant ships into very nasty big-time bombs, with something beginning with 'N' wheeled up the Thames, I understand there are sensors available to stop that, and you can bet the meeting place of politicians will have the best protection.
Whether we have the means, ship, sub' or air / spaceborne, to take it out is another matter.
Regards from a minor one of the team on the first Sea Eagle firing !
I suspect that while RAF Coastal Command do well, it would have been handy if we still had a Navy & Fleet Air Arm.
Touching wood it's notable that the FAA traditionally get shafted just before a major war !
We do have more assets than publicised, mostly airborne, as every other country does.
As to turning merchant ships into very nasty big-time bombs, with something beginning with 'N' wheeled up the Thames, I understand there are sensors available to stop that, and you can bet the meeting place of politicians will have the best protection.
Whether we have the means, ship, sub' or air / spaceborne, to take it out is another matter.
Regards from a minor one of the team on the first Sea Eagle firing !
They also suggested that Arabs would get sea sick and be unable to sail a ship from the Indian Ocean.
No way we could get attacked by planes as we have Radar where as the Hijackers flew in first class and after visiting Mickey Rat they did the deed.
Presuming that LNG terminal is already been given adequate attention about and below sea.
Join Date: Sep 2000
Posts: 619
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Speaking from recent bitter experience I find it terribly sad that our once proud naval reserve is now nothing more than a suport organisation for the Royal Marines when deployed overseas. I know at least one senior officer who is trying to get a maritime element back into the Maritime Reserves but I fear the case is lost. This is a crying shame because coastal forces and seaward defence would be an ideal activity for the RNR. As it once was in the past for our predicessors. The Sea Fencibles, The RNAV and the RNVR. (Not to forget the RNXS, bless them!)
While many airborne assets are in theory available to police our "shores", that is not the same as saying they conduct regular patrols.
I would suspect that cost is a major factor in whatever actually takes place....
I would suspect that cost is a major factor in whatever actually takes place....
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Sandhurst
Age: 50
Posts: 202
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The joke used to be:
Q: Are you in the Army?
A: No I'm a Royal Marine.
Q: Ahh so your in the Navy then??
A: No, they are merely our Taxi service.
What a crying shame that an element of truth is creeping into that comment.
Gone are the days when the RN could handle any kind of sea battle, however I would doubt that any nation would rest if they knew that a few RN hunter killers were lurking around.
Q: Are you in the Army?
A: No I'm a Royal Marine.
Q: Ahh so your in the Navy then??
A: No, they are merely our Taxi service.
What a crying shame that an element of truth is creeping into that comment.
Gone are the days when the RN could handle any kind of sea battle, however I would doubt that any nation would rest if they knew that a few RN hunter killers were lurking around.
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: YES
Posts: 779
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Not only the danger of terrorists blowing up a tanker but the UK coastline is ideal for smuggling as well not only terrorists items like weapons and explosives but crime related smuggling is also a threat to our society like Drugs and people.
I do sometime wonder if a proper paramilitary border protection service would be a better option than the myriad of different services providing the current patchy service.
I do sometime wonder if a proper paramilitary border protection service would be a better option than the myriad of different services providing the current patchy service.
Join Date: Sep 2000
Posts: 619
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
GPMG, thanks for your sentiments. You are so right about our SSNs. First the Argies knew about it was Belgrano sinking. Result, 25 de Mayo runs for home and never comes out to play again. Problem is they are not realy coastal boats. We need SSKs (or a couple of German SSCs), that's Diesels to you chaps.
Nurse, you may be suprised to know that at one time a secondary war role for officers such as my self was to be a Customs Officer.
Nurse, you may be suprised to know that at one time a secondary war role for officers such as my self was to be a Customs Officer.