PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Fragrant Harbour (https://www.pprune.org/fragrant-harbour-19/)
-   -   Emerging KA Crewing Crisis And Contact Compliance? (https://www.pprune.org/fragrant-harbour/600108-emerging-ka-crewing-crisis-contact-compliance.html)

BlunderBus 7th Oct 2017 21:31

Easy... direct entry capt means only one pilot to train. No need to find and train someone to replace the upgraded f/o.
And you can bet .. just as in ASL years ago that management pilots will ‘train’ and pass them ... new contract conditions too of course.

And Then 14th Oct 2017 03:13

I feel tensions are building on the line far quicker than anticipated. The operation is such a mess from so many factors, anyone who cares will be stretchered out of the flight deck on a defibrillator. The email from a CX manager, many had only heard about on pprune, was an indication of how far removed and misunderstood the KA operation is.

KA Flt Op's managers sense the urgency. Sweet emails lauding the professionalism of well handled events would be received with considerable cyniscm. Yes, the new people communication skills are very obvious. But they are a veritable kiss and fu@& principle. Op's management offer professional encouragement whilst the real goal is contract concessions from up the command chain.

Besides, the half-life of KA managers is about 9 months. Nobody seriously believes any ( bar a favourite ) any will be around in the long term.

Hard working G day workers and trainers keeping the A320 operation afloat, now face the prospect of hinted DECs on the 330. Learning their effforts are of no consequence to career aspirations. Project Altitude synergies wouldn't harness weeping career hopes of pilots. With A321s on the way in numbers and a potential flood of departures, A330 DECs whether off the street or via integration offer the greratest on paper savings. The fallacy of course being, the intangible measure of morale or more so, what mangagers love to term as keeping the show on the road.

Be safe.

Apple Tree Yard 14th Oct 2017 04:20

Add to the mess the evident decision for CX pilots to have less pay and benefits than their KA brethren (not to discredit their conditions, just the absurdity of it). I can safely say to CX management that you have no idea how much of a sh*t storm you are about to be engulfed in. The latest letter to the trainers is plain evidence of our management 'losing the plot'. How will you do as an airline when you don't have a training department by the end of the year?

brucealmighty 14th Oct 2017 04:33


Originally Posted by And Then (Post 9924486)
Hard working G day workers and trainers keeping the A320 operation afloat, now face the prospect of hinted DECs on the 330. Learning their effforts are of no consequence to career aspirations. Project Altitude synergies wouldn't harness weeping career hopes of pilots. With A321s on the way in numbers and a potential flood of departures, A330 DECs whether off the street or via integration offer the greratest on paper savings.


KA currently hiring DEFO onto the A330 ahead of A320 FO's waiting for CCQ.
DPA turn blind eye. They will work hard to block this one and protect captains

raven11 14th Oct 2017 06:49

Agreed AppleTree...CX management love to roll out the "but your pay and conditions are well above other local carriers." While ignoring the obvious fact that the KA IS ALSO A LOCAL CARRIER AND SHOULD THEREFORE SERVE AS A VALID COMPARISON OF MARKET RATES AND TERMS.


My advice to KA pilots:
Do you seriously believe that your terms and conditions will remain at present levels once CX achieves their goal to hack away the terms and conditions from CX pilots?

Trafalgar 14th Oct 2017 06:55

Although we've had our petty differences, it is imperative we all band together now. We are under attack today, you will be tomorrow. Time to shut the whole operation down. It is flu season after all.

TheGreenDragon 14th Oct 2017 10:52


How will you do as an airline when you don't have a training department by the end of the year?
You are missing the point. They have a second training department in Cathay Dragon. KA trainers will be called upon to cover the shortfall. Wether good or bad, the precident is set. Many guys want to join the KA training dept. Many KA trainers would like to train in CX.

The answer, make KA trainers into CX managers. They can be then directly employed out of seniority, onto CX A330s.

Far fetched? Time will tell.:p

tripleslavin 15th Oct 2017 08:18

KA have hired DEFO into the A330 for years nothing new there.

cpahka 16th Oct 2017 12:46


Originally Posted by tripleslavin (Post 9925567)
KA have hired DEFO into the A330 for years nothing new there.

rumors said DEC in KA very soon...thanks with Green's care!

Farman Biplane 16th Oct 2017 12:53

Maybe KA will be taking all the cos99 CX Captains that are forced out at 55y.o?
By the sounds of the impending ARAPA reduction, these 55y.o’s might even get a pay rise out of it!

bringbackthe80s 18th Oct 2017 10:43

So you really think DEC are happening?

Dead Serious 18th Oct 2017 11:20

CX senior FOs' being asked if they would accept a KA command for 3 years !

TSIO540 18th Oct 2017 12:30


Originally Posted by bringbackthe80s (Post 9928768)
So you really think DEC are happening?

They have mentioned it in memos but it's a massive ask getting through the command check with the tiny bit of training provided unless you have significant Airbus and china experience... and that should mean you can better money elsewhere.

bringbackthe80s 18th Oct 2017 13:06

Thank you. I was just asking because it's not advertised on their website

Lowkoon 18th Oct 2017 13:26

They honestly think that captains with three months of validity on their commands would risk a KA command course, and if they miss out take a RHS and 12 months to cool off before having another crack? Who is kidding themselves now???! Surely they would just march across the road and take the $300,000 sign on bonus next door or go to china...

This of course has nothing to do with "suddenly needing captains". The 321s are years away, and current 320 captains arent even in Ot let alone under staffed. This is purely a trojan horse to get direct commanders into KA if the negotiations go sour when they try and pinch the housing off the B scalers. A trojan horse for scabs if it all goes bad. Lucky we have ex 89ers in the training department that will see it for what it is.

The simple reality is, they cant attract AND retain experienced pilots with the withered carrot they are dangling. We have lost more than we have hired this year, and how many more are waiting for a start date? Are they so in touch that they choose a time where they are losing guys at a record rate to take on the pilot body? Breathtaking in its stupidity.

LongTimeInCX 19th Oct 2017 02:18

Lowkoon, you mentioned:

Are they so in touch that they choose a time where they are losing guys at a record rate to take on the pilot body? Breathtaking in its stupidity.
They see the current (soon to be no longer able to be taken advantage of) fuel hedging loss as justification for 'the sky is falling'. They feel if they don't act now, against both sets of 'group' pilots, they'll lose that chance. It was never about sacking 600 relatively low paid workers in the paper shuffling department, that was simply justification for their real goal - ARAPA.
So stupidity? Yes in many ways they are.
For years they have chased cents whilst missing dollars, and never missed an opportunity to demean and degrade the pilots in the eyes of all the other staff.
From taking away the expat travel desk in the early 90's, to giving everyone a mug with their name on except pilots, to comparing hard landing costs with billions of dollars of fuel hedging losses.

If this was a genuine crisis, our swire mangers (sic) would be greeting workers with a bow at the front of HelloKittyCity, apologizing for their incompetent management skills and the billions of dollars of losses, and leading from the front with, limiting themselves to the same ARAPA type levels as existing staff who are on it, (and to remain so until ARAPA staff get an increase), double digit percentage pay cuts themselves, and zero bonuses, from either swire or cx.

Until they lead from the front, then there is NO REAL CRISIS.

This is just a money grab, to reduce costs now under a convenient, possibly even engineered loss, type of excuse in order to maximise profits AND huge bonuses, only equaled by the champagne popping laughing backslapping that will occur if this ARAPA attack is allowed to continue without an equal reaction back.

This is the line in the sand, they've crossed it. Time to push back.

I hear there's a lot of flu, bad backs, migraines and diarrhea around very shortly, and it's likely to be very contagious
Is this to be led by the AOA and our president? Of course not, he's out stealing another spine from a jellyfish.
Rod - where are you?

So Lowkoon, you asked are they that stupid, yes sir, I think they are.

OK4Wire 19th Oct 2017 02:40

Long time.

I agree with everything you have said, except I don't think their real goal is ARAPA. That is a classic mis-direction which appears to be working just fine.

I think the real aim is much bigger - to them and to the pilot body - and much more costly to all of us.

Imagine the savings to be had if all 3000 (4000?) pilots can now fly to 90 or 92 hours free of overtime? That would make the ARAPA cuts seem like a rounding error.

And what's more, this will come like a bolt out of the blue to those on HKPA because they think they've dodged a bullet up till now.

So yes, we are that stupid.

Krone 19th Oct 2017 04:12

The issue is safety. The old days you paid a premium to attract experienced crew .
Now Loco is no less safe just because its paying 50% less salary. CX look across at HKA and HKE and easyJet etc and say why are we still paying a premium when the jobs now inherently safe? Our SOs etc are making safe FOs and Capts, so we paying too much lah.

Gnadenburg 19th Oct 2017 06:02

Reduced Rostering Scheme will buy off the senior vote. There's already whispers of an expanded scheme- though nothing in writing but don't let that make a KA pilot stop and think !

Are the CX pilots aware of this scheme? I always wondered why they were paranoid about KA pilots seeking their bases.

FreemaninHK 19th Oct 2017 13:32

Senior KA crew being asked if they'd like a SYD base too..

WTF people.. who makes this :mad: up? I can't believe anyone would even repeat half the :mad: posted here. It does no one in our pilot group any good.

Staggers 19th Oct 2017 23:09

What about my Chengdu basing:)

Dragon Master 20th Oct 2017 05:18

Staggers there is a bit of a waiting list for a CTU basing, popular base, you might not even be senior enough to bid for the O day there. Lovely location

stoked365 20th Oct 2017 07:37

For those looking for a CTU base with improved salary Longreach aviation have a roadshow on 24-26th. Many of your KA capt friends will be there

ANTIPHOLUS 20th Oct 2017 08:08

Chengdu..FFS. Are they investing in breathing equipment ? Drager, sort of thing firemen use.
Longreach...the pilots' friend...especially when taking their 12%, or is it 15 these days. ?

Dead Serious 21st Oct 2017 05:15

Hong Kong is fast becoming a "graveyard" for unemployed pilots from around the globe whose state airlines have gone bankrupt ( Alitalia ) or independents that have failed ( Air Berlin and Monarch ).
CAD will accept any license it seems although this is not reciprocated with by other agencies. The executive pilot experience levels are frightening.
As a result the old players( CX and KA ) are taking advantage and reducing packages to the lowest common denominator and will pay market rates.

Elsewhere, in the real world, airlines are cottoning on to a worldwide pilot shortage and upping their deals to attract new talent now.

Like the housing market in Hong Kong the pilot demand and supply model is badly broken and when the "crash" comes !

Staggers 21st Oct 2017 07:32

I know I know but think of all the pandas😂

ANTIPHOLUS 21st Oct 2017 08:25

Aah the pandas. Worth it then. Worth it. 500 pounds of permanently loafing bamboo recycling giant raccoons. Lazy :mad:

Dan Winterland 21st Oct 2017 16:45


Hong Kong is fast becoming a "graveyard" for unemployed pilots from around the globe whose state airlines have gone bankrupt ( Alitalia ) or independents that have failed ( Air Berlin and Monarch ).
Doubt many will be coming here. Lufthansa are in the market for Alitalia and Air Berlins and will probably take on most, if not all their pilots. And when the 400 Monarch pilots were let loose on the job market, there was a feeding frenzy. Jet 2, Virgin, easyJet, Aer Lingus, Emirates, NetJets, Titan, Wow and Parc all set up fast track recruitment for them. Three of my Monarch mates have already accepted jobs with easyJet - one as a direct entry TIRE. Even the RAF invited the ex military guys to get in touch. The pilot shortage is very real.

CX/KA are no longer the employers of choice. Morale is very low in both companies and if even 10% of the guys who say they will leave if their Ts and Cs are cut do actually go to other employers, they will spark a major crewing crisis.

Dan Winterland 21st Oct 2017 16:47

And don't forget Sichuan Airlines! https://youtu.be/gCvuLb4i4iQ

Staggers 21st Oct 2017 23:56

and the Owl soufflé is heavenly not to mention many other delicacies.

Flex88 22nd Oct 2017 01:27

Recruit from where ?
 
SCMP today HKA going to purchase zillions of 787's.
A big factor in the decision making process,,,,,,, Boeing probably already issues FCOM & doc's in Spanish & Portuguese.

Both countries collapsing mi Amigos - bring on the Paella ;)

ANTIPHOLUS 22nd Oct 2017 02:14

Yes don’t forget “baby baby squeak squeak “. Gravid mouse, squeezed until immature foetuses pop out. Eaten with chopsticks of course. Best washed down with a bottle of glycerin and arsenic laden beer.

Freehills 22nd Oct 2017 02:54

Like the europeans don't eat some odd stuff

Rotten fish
Rotten cheese
Live oysters

ANTIPHOLUS 22nd Oct 2017 03:12

And your point is. ? Excellent all of them. And I think our Americans readers might resemble that remark.

Toruk Macto 22nd Oct 2017 05:10

http://sc.mp/XVoPmC

Trafalgar 22nd Oct 2017 05:11

More to the point, HKA will be trying to attract CX Boeing pilots, who can do a quick rating on the 787. The industry will be doing all they can to strip away CX's pilots, and you can be assured that within 24 months CX will be in the midst of an irreversible crewing crisis. At that point, no matter what they do, it will be futile. Their name is already anathema to most career minded pilots, and will be even more so as the months go by.

Dan Winterland 22nd Oct 2017 06:44

Will Cathay Pacific face a pilot exodus to mainland airlines as it cuts salaries and benefits? | South China Morning Post

raven11 22nd Oct 2017 14:07

Quote: “Our resignation rate and early retirement rate … are both a very manageable and in the appropriate range as we continue with our plans to recruit, train, and retain the appropriate mix of skilled pilots to meet our growth plans...”

Wishful thinking...whistling past the graveyard...optimism bias...ostrich effect....

bringbackthe80s 22nd Oct 2017 14:14

Guys an honest question. How many pilots from KA have gone to a mainland carrier? Even if they pay much more money.

TSIO540 22nd Oct 2017 15:56

I know of three in the last two months..


All times are GMT. The time now is 19:18.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.