What's the Job Worth ?
Guest
Posts: n/a
What's the Job Worth ?
Bus429 seems to have rattled a few cages in the thread about wages and there appears to be no support for our cause from within the crew faction, time we stood our ground.
2 Question's:[list=a][*]What's the Job REALLY worth ??[*]What will it take to get it ??[/list=a]
[This message has been edited by IMA Conehead (edited 28 September 2000).]
2 Question's:[list=a][*]What's the Job REALLY worth ??[*]What will it take to get it ??[/list=a]
[This message has been edited by IMA Conehead (edited 28 September 2000).]
Guest
Posts: n/a
Engineers in our industry are underpaid and not respected, but this doesn't necessarily reflect in our pay packets. The day of the airline perk is drawing to a close, but what about other periferals such as membership to fitness clubs, or subsidised social outings? Do any of us get them? I certainly don't. Yet the hi-tech engineers working on developing hard and software all seem to. Even shop floor workers at a car plant near where I work get better perks than me. Time that the feel good factor was restored to aviation maintenance instead of 'If you cannot get that aircraft out the door in 9 days, we will all be down the road' attitude that now prevails. What will happen if loweat quote maintenance wins the day and all heavy work goes to Asia and the Far East? No health and safety regulations, minimum wage or working time directives over there. But there is limited hangar space too. No doubt He With The Biggest Cheque Book would win the day there, so I recon that our jobs are safe for a few years yet.
Guest
Posts: n/a
Unfortuneately, the major problem is public ignorance of Aircraft Maintenance Engineers, hence the low priority. As I'm sure everyone has experienced, when my wife says 'my husbands an aircraft engineer' the usual ignorant reply is 'oh I suppose there must be mechanics for planes like there are for cars'. This is not lost by the folk in the upper echelons of both airlines and engineering companies, hence the people in the departments where the general public can relate to have a higher profile. This was most apparant during my time in an office at Failing Line Services. The previleges and jollies afford me and my office colleagues compared to what the guys on the line and in the hangar was, well, embarrasing.
A similar problem also occurs in the unionised airline environment. The airline that I once worked for, the maple leaf type, had Licensed Aircraft Engineers, Flight despatchers and car mechanics all in the same union. The despatchers were paid the most because they had to pass an exam to become a despatcher. The difference between a car mechanic and an A/C engineer was £50 per month. Sadly, despite pressing the issue, no one wanted to break away from the transit van mechanics because we were all working men together.
A/C engineers must first of all shake off the other clingers on and be self representing before any further progress can be made in attaining What The Job Is Worth.
A similar problem also occurs in the unionised airline environment. The airline that I once worked for, the maple leaf type, had Licensed Aircraft Engineers, Flight despatchers and car mechanics all in the same union. The despatchers were paid the most because they had to pass an exam to become a despatcher. The difference between a car mechanic and an A/C engineer was £50 per month. Sadly, despite pressing the issue, no one wanted to break away from the transit van mechanics because we were all working men together.
A/C engineers must first of all shake off the other clingers on and be self representing before any further progress can be made in attaining What The Job Is Worth.
Guest
Posts: n/a
Good point, what are we worth? Without us the airlines cease to operate but then this is true of many other jobs within the airline. No point having serviceable aircraft fully crewed if nobody has sold any tickets! One big difference though is that the airlines can not recruit and train a person from scratch quickly, to be able to certify an aircraft (or be competant to do so). In short, we are worth what we are prepared to do the job for. Problem has always been, if I ask for a higher rate some other snake will offer to do it for less. Times though are changing, many old school are retireing, and the internet lets us communicate to each other and find out what we are charging for our services, or at least it should. What I suggest is that we each record what we earn at each company and at each contract, actual figures not bullsh*t. This gives us a base for negotiations for pay purposes and hopefully will stop some of the sometimes severe undercutting that keeps contract pay (and hence regular) pay down. What do you all think of this idea? Best regards to you all, trapper>
Guest
Posts: n/a
Guest
Posts: n/a
I saw a documentary last year about BA trainee first officer. It takes 18 months to train a first officer from scratch, to a right hand seat position on A320's. I don't know what these people get paid as a first officer but I bet it is more than a five year indentured apprentice. As a requirement of JAR66 5 years is now the minimum experience requirement for the right to 'apply'. Pay scales are significantly different and previously stated, it is because we as engineers, allow it to be so by being tied into union bargaining groups where mechanics get the same % rise. This is not to denigrate the mechanic, (you must first be the mechanic before the engineer)but we must make the separation. If we value our skills, knowledge and qalifications then fight for our cause and not everyone else. This will no doubt upset the staunch unionites, but what an insentive for a mechanic that would be, to get a license and the associated pay hike. In the company I work for certain mechanics can earn 40K, by working shifts and overtime. This is a great deal more than an inspectors basic and license pay. Granted 40K including shift and overtime but, also with 0 responsibility and 0 license with the associated responsibility that entails. Thats just as,I,see,it.
A mechanic has no certification responsibility and an LAE (licensed aircraft engineer) has. Some companies call the LAE an inspector, supervisor or LT (Licensed Technician. Line Engineers are usually more hands on, than hangar engineers on heavy checks. Inspect & Supervise
[This message has been edited by as,I,see,it (edited 07 October 2000).]
A mechanic has no certification responsibility and an LAE (licensed aircraft engineer) has. Some companies call the LAE an inspector, supervisor or LT (Licensed Technician. Line Engineers are usually more hands on, than hangar engineers on heavy checks. Inspect & Supervise
[This message has been edited by as,I,see,it (edited 07 October 2000).]
Guest
Posts: n/a
Could you translate “mechanic” to us almost english speaking folks? In the system you work in it sounds like a mechanic is someone without licenses who works on aircraft, and an engineer is someone with licenses. Do engineers work on aircraft, or do they just supervise mechanics?
Sorry if this seems a bit obtuse, but I’d like to get my apples matched to apples and my oranges compared to oranges.
[This message has been edited by redtail (edited 07 October 2000).]
Sorry if this seems a bit obtuse, but I’d like to get my apples matched to apples and my oranges compared to oranges.
[This message has been edited by redtail (edited 07 October 2000).]
Guest
Posts: n/a
perhaps if we had a body like BALPA looking out for our interests and getting us more public attention then maybe we feel abit better about ourselves. I wont slag the ALAE off because I am sure they try there bestwith limited resources, but we are PROS. If you describe your duties "basically" to the layman their initial reaction is always bloody hell "thats some responsability" and or "you most get paid a fortune" andf of course most of us dont recieve the salary the job should. Our job is never over. for example I bet most of you have sat at home or in the pub and thought now did I do that right , should I have done that etc when the thing goes wrong the hole system looks at you to get it fixed asap. OF COURSE WE UNDERVALUED AND UNDERPAID, BUT OUR DAY WILL COME MY SON, OUR DAY WILL COME!
Guest
Posts: n/a
Redtail - to answer your q, this is the U.K. system:
Mechanic:Non - certifying posn, tho' most companies grant "limited & simple" authorisations to cover daily checks & some component changes,i.e.wheels/brakes/filaments etc.
Within B.A. this posn is a "technician". They can hold approvals that cover more component changes but not function checks or trouble shooting (Ramp Maint Auth), or that cover a complete zone during hangar checks (Base Maint Auth).
Engineer (sometimes refered to as "Licenced tech"):Certifying Engineer, holding Licences & company approvals, signs for work up to the limit of their licence (airframe/eng/elec/isnt/radio etc).May be hands on or not dependant on Company & whether line or base maint.
Mechanic:Non - certifying posn, tho' most companies grant "limited & simple" authorisations to cover daily checks & some component changes,i.e.wheels/brakes/filaments etc.
Within B.A. this posn is a "technician". They can hold approvals that cover more component changes but not function checks or trouble shooting (Ramp Maint Auth), or that cover a complete zone during hangar checks (Base Maint Auth).
Engineer (sometimes refered to as "Licenced tech"):Certifying Engineer, holding Licences & company approvals, signs for work up to the limit of their licence (airframe/eng/elec/isnt/radio etc).May be hands on or not dependant on Company & whether line or base maint.
Guest
Posts: n/a
if the worst comes to the worst you can always get something new. Demand for engineers has never been higher as everyone gets into IT, there's not enough new recruits to go around.
if you want a shift I recommend checking out
http://www.aviationjobsearch.com
where you can find loads of engineering positions in the UK, Europe, Middle East and United States.
if you want a shift I recommend checking out
http://www.aviationjobsearch.com
where you can find loads of engineering positions in the UK, Europe, Middle East and United States.
Guest
Posts: n/a
Cotos is right. How often do you see an engineer on any of the fly on the wall TV documentaries, Airport, Airline etc. The public must think that all operations revolve around the decisions of camp dispatchers, dog handlers and traffic wardens. !
Also when asked what do you do for a living and you reply I'm an aircraft engineer. How people say Oh, and were do you do that?
[This message has been edited by unwrapping the aog (edited 28 October 2000).]
Also when asked what do you do for a living and you reply I'm an aircraft engineer. How people say Oh, and were do you do that?
[This message has been edited by unwrapping the aog (edited 28 October 2000).]
Guest
Posts: n/a
I have to agree that we are our own worst enemies. I have just spent a month on an aircraft manufactures course with 11 other engineers from all over the place.
none of them were even willing to talk about there pay in specifics just 'abouts' or ish !!!
Talk about reserved.
Does the ALAE hold a current database of what companies pay, that members work for.
I know BALPA have a sort of list for pilots pay from airlines.
I have never been asked by the ALAE has anyone else, maybe it is time they did what do you all think ????
Chad
none of them were even willing to talk about there pay in specifics just 'abouts' or ish !!!
Talk about reserved.
Does the ALAE hold a current database of what companies pay, that members work for.
I know BALPA have a sort of list for pilots pay from airlines.
I have never been asked by the ALAE has anyone else, maybe it is time they did what do you all think ????
Chad
Guest
Posts: n/a
Unwrapping the AOG, as it happens we (Aircraft Eng's) were mentioned once during a piece about an LH totty who puts pax on board a/c. The aircraft was due to depart shortly and the engineer was LATE, but they failed to mention that the poor sod was probably about to depart his tenth a/c that hour. Fortuneately for the viewing public the engineer was found on time and the a/c departed on schedule. And so the scene ended with the girlie saving the day!! Absolute load of arrrssseee.
Guest
Posts: n/a
Hmmm, so a girlie saved the day huh?
I can just see it now...
"Ladies and gentlemen, my name is Candy, I'll be your host on this flight. Unfortunately our AME is running late; so if you would be so kind as to seat yourselves. I'm just going to go down and do a quick line check (have a look-see at the tire pressures and fluid levels)...and I think I'll take a peek at that left main while I'm at it," with a wink and a placid smile "that strut looks like it may have a minor leak."
Who says girlies are only good for one thing?!
------------------
Patience is letting your motor idle when you feel like stripping your gears.
I can just see it now...
"Ladies and gentlemen, my name is Candy, I'll be your host on this flight. Unfortunately our AME is running late; so if you would be so kind as to seat yourselves. I'm just going to go down and do a quick line check (have a look-see at the tire pressures and fluid levels)...and I think I'll take a peek at that left main while I'm at it," with a wink and a placid smile "that strut looks like it may have a minor leak."
Who says girlies are only good for one thing?!
------------------
Patience is letting your motor idle when you feel like stripping your gears.
Guest
Posts: n/a
Chad, the ALAE did look into doing it at one stage there were reasons why it wasn't done, some of whioch you can read here. To actually get a co to say what it's employees earn is not something you get very easily and to be accurate that is the only way. A lot of people earn x but x can be made up of so many things, OT, license/approval pay etc etc.
to answer the original point
a. 50K
b. mass industrial walkout to grind all airlines to a halt, and this will never happen as there is no unity and some will always carry on regardless.
to answer the original point
a. 50K
b. mass industrial walkout to grind all airlines to a halt, and this will never happen as there is no unity and some will always carry on regardless.
Guest
Posts: n/a
As it happens, I spent a chunk of Friday writing a long and detailed letter to my boss explaining why I'd appreciate the courtesy of a measurable payrise this year.
In my search for some evidence to back me up, I discovered that the Engineering Council (they had to do something useful eventually) publish a salary survey of all UK Engineers on their website.
If anybody wishes to take a look at it, you'll find it at...
http://www.engc.org.uk/gateway/3/Sur...rants_2000.pdf (it's about 20 pages long and takes a minute or two to download)
The EC has three grades (and if you're not registered shame on you) - CEng is for Engineers, IEng is for well educated Technicians and poorly educated Engineers, and Eng.Tech is for averagely educated technicians. They don't deal with mechanics.
Incidentally, somebody up there asked about Engineers .v. technicians .v. mechanics. Since I don't think he got answered...
Engineer - highly educated, carries authority to make design decisions.
Technician - highly trained, carries authority to make maintenance or working decisions. Works to documents written by Engineers.
Mechanic - semi-skilled or untrained, works normally under supervision of a technician. Little or no direct authority.
By which definition, most people called "licensed aircraft engineers" are technicians. I hasten to add that they are usually bloody good ones, and in my experience although the best Engineers are better paid than the best Technicians - in our industry an average Technician is better paid than an average Engineer.
Genghis,
Good Engineer, average technician.
In my search for some evidence to back me up, I discovered that the Engineering Council (they had to do something useful eventually) publish a salary survey of all UK Engineers on their website.
If anybody wishes to take a look at it, you'll find it at...
http://www.engc.org.uk/gateway/3/Sur...rants_2000.pdf (it's about 20 pages long and takes a minute or two to download)
The EC has three grades (and if you're not registered shame on you) - CEng is for Engineers, IEng is for well educated Technicians and poorly educated Engineers, and Eng.Tech is for averagely educated technicians. They don't deal with mechanics.
Incidentally, somebody up there asked about Engineers .v. technicians .v. mechanics. Since I don't think he got answered...
Engineer - highly educated, carries authority to make design decisions.
Technician - highly trained, carries authority to make maintenance or working decisions. Works to documents written by Engineers.
Mechanic - semi-skilled or untrained, works normally under supervision of a technician. Little or no direct authority.
By which definition, most people called "licensed aircraft engineers" are technicians. I hasten to add that they are usually bloody good ones, and in my experience although the best Engineers are better paid than the best Technicians - in our industry an average Technician is better paid than an average Engineer.
Genghis,
Good Engineer, average technician.
Guest
Posts: n/a
I have to agree with the majority, wether we get it or not is a different matter. We ,despite public opinion, have as much power as the aircraft captain, long or short haul. Plus if we cock it up there's not always someone sat next to us watching,Like a first officer, also how many captains can fly more than one aircraft at a time, or even hold more than one current type rating, on different manufacturers aircraft.
Quite often in maintrol the captain of the aircraft asks for advice wether on the ground or in the air regarding maintenance problems, and base his/her decisions on my advice. Even when airbourne we have the power to ask an aircraft to return to base.
In fact I,ve just convinced myself, we are more powerful than a captain!
Let's say £50k Basic at least.
Quite often in maintrol the captain of the aircraft asks for advice wether on the ground or in the air regarding maintenance problems, and base his/her decisions on my advice. Even when airbourne we have the power to ask an aircraft to return to base.
In fact I,ve just convinced myself, we are more powerful than a captain!
Let's say £50k Basic at least.
Guest
Posts: n/a
Gengis, I think the statement " Mechanic - semi skilled or untrained " is a bit harsh. Most mechanics have gone through a 4 year apprenticeship, 3 or 4 years at college to attain ONC OR HNC qualifications, then they take an AEC (then taken away)or its replacement the AMC. In my experience a good mechanic is worth his weight in gold. Admittedly untrained people sneak in the back door to become mechs, but we should make sure this doesn't happen. No indentures no job. Incidently I know a few mechs that have an AMEL.
[This message has been edited by Dozy Bell (edited 29 October 2000).]
[This message has been edited by Dozy Bell (edited 29 October 2000).]