Accident Report on Coulthard's Lear 35 Released
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: _
Posts: 350
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Accident Report on Coulthard's Lear 35 Released
The Accident Report on the crash of the Lear 35 at Lyon on 2 May 2000, which David Coulthard & co survived (despite the tragic deaths of the 2 pilots) has been released. All in French, I'm afraid, except the CVR transcript at the end of the document, in English:
http://www.bea-fr.org/docspa/2000/g-...-ri000502.html
(Don't think it's been left out, but couldn't see any form of approach briefing or any proper checklists being carried out...any comments bizjet people?)
http://www.bea-fr.org/docspa/2000/g-...-ri000502.html
(Don't think it's been left out, but couldn't see any form of approach briefing or any proper checklists being carried out...any comments bizjet people?)
Join Date: Oct 2000
Location: London, UK
Posts: 329
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
- Mechanical failure within left engine resulted in failure, led to engine being shut down.
- Aircraft made final approach on single engine but this was never stabilised.
- A little before the threshold and increase of thrust on the right engine was requested.
- The aircraft banked heavily to the left and struck the ground.
Probable cause: loss of roll control apparently owing to lack of monitoring of the flight symmetry at the moment that additional thrust was requested on the right engine, following non-stabilised approach.
- Aircraft made final approach on single engine but this was never stabilised.
- A little before the threshold and increase of thrust on the right engine was requested.
- The aircraft banked heavily to the left and struck the ground.
Probable cause: loss of roll control apparently owing to lack of monitoring of the flight symmetry at the moment that additional thrust was requested on the right engine, following non-stabilised approach.
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: over here
Posts: 472
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The BEA will probably release an English transcript in the fullness of time - they usually do this with commercial jets and of course in this case the aircraft was British registered. Guess the CAA will do something too.
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Herefordshire
Posts: 545
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Accident Report on Coulthard's LearJet Released
Such a tragic story. Good to know though that single-engine approach training (UK and USA) has been modified a result of lessons learned. Disappointing that checklists don't appear to have been used but such emergency procedures are often recited/carried out by memory with checklist back-up/confirmation. For all their aircraft/sim training this crew may never have carried out a single-engine and approach and landing culminating with the selection of full flap. BM
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Beverly Hills 90210
Posts: 88
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Can someone explain to me how the plane rolled over even though it had plenty of speed and didn't stall.
I believe that they applied full power at the last second but the data recorder indicates a reduction of power ??
My impression is that they had 20 degrees flaps. Did anyone read that they went to full flaps at the last second ??
Keep the blue side up; whever up is
I believe that they applied full power at the last second but the data recorder indicates a reduction of power ??
My impression is that they had 20 degrees flaps. Did anyone read that they went to full flaps at the last second ??
Keep the blue side up; whever up is
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: The world's biggest beach
Posts: 222
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I appreciate it's incredibly easy to criticise on here, but I have to agree with the above, on the initial read of the CVR transcript there were way too many freq' changes.
Join Date: May 2000
Location: US
Posts: 896
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Info on Lear 35 single engine controllability
Lear 35's have more than sufficient power and controllability while single engine. The are limitations on lateral fuel inbalance though. An AFM limitation is 600 pounds imbalance while hand-flying, or 200 pounds inbalance with the AFCS engaged.
This is a serious problem when the imbalance is based on tip tank fuel, because this scenario presents the largest "moment."
The Lear 35 systems allow the easy crossflowing of fuel from one wing to the other wing. One of the first steps (but not THE first) taken with an engine shut down is to open the crossflow valve. This will allow the gravity crossflowing of fuel to the wing with the operating engine to minimize the imbalance. Occasional activation of a fuel boost pump is also recommended to keep the imbalance closer to zero.
With a large imbalance, there can be a serious controllability issue, especially significant while single engine.
I would only be speculating if I said this was the problem in this sad accident.
This is a serious problem when the imbalance is based on tip tank fuel, because this scenario presents the largest "moment."
The Lear 35 systems allow the easy crossflowing of fuel from one wing to the other wing. One of the first steps (but not THE first) taken with an engine shut down is to open the crossflow valve. This will allow the gravity crossflowing of fuel to the wing with the operating engine to minimize the imbalance. Occasional activation of a fuel boost pump is also recommended to keep the imbalance closer to zero.
With a large imbalance, there can be a serious controllability issue, especially significant while single engine.
I would only be speculating if I said this was the problem in this sad accident.
Last edited by Check 6; 2nd May 2003 at 09:07.
Guest
Posts: n/a
Gidday,
Yes the fuel balance for the Lear can be a trial, I operated 31s in the pure training mode and in the early days we didn't have a Sim, so all endorsements were done "live".
Most of us got a fright or two when things were busy doing "failure" work.
As you slow down the aileron required just runs out, student miss control can hide the initial onset as they use rudder, then it all runs out at the same time.
Mr Garrett's spin up has saved the day but if it is actually shut down, the ball is difficult to play for sure.
Stay safe.
Yes the fuel balance for the Lear can be a trial, I operated 31s in the pure training mode and in the early days we didn't have a Sim, so all endorsements were done "live".
Most of us got a fright or two when things were busy doing "failure" work.
As you slow down the aileron required just runs out, student miss control can hide the initial onset as they use rudder, then it all runs out at the same time.
Mr Garrett's spin up has saved the day but if it is actually shut down, the ball is difficult to play for sure.
Stay safe.
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Canada
Posts: 1
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Another thing to consider is fuel dumping...if they did have a fuel balance problem.
All the tip fuel in the 35 can be dumped in 5 mins. If the tip tanks are full that decreases landing weight by about 2400 pounds.
It seems as though they were at Max Landing Weight of 15 300 which equals a ref of 129 and a 20 flap ref of 139.
Although I may have lost something in the translation, it seems like this wasn't considered....easy to second guess, but something I hope I'd consider in this situation.
All the tip fuel in the 35 can be dumped in 5 mins. If the tip tanks are full that decreases landing weight by about 2400 pounds.
It seems as though they were at Max Landing Weight of 15 300 which equals a ref of 129 and a 20 flap ref of 139.
Although I may have lost something in the translation, it seems like this wasn't considered....easy to second guess, but something I hope I'd consider in this situation.
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Home
Posts: 329
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The report says that fuel imbalance was not an issue.
Transl: In both cases [two estimations of possible imbalance] the value calculated was less than the 600lb landing maximum...
The report criticises the multiple frequency changes in section 2.4.
Dans les deux cas la valeur obtenue reste inférieure au maximum démontré à l’atterrissage de 600 lb, tel qu'il figure dans les procédures du manuel de vol.
The report criticises the multiple frequency changes in section 2.4.
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: out of my suitcase
Age: 51
Posts: 59
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It would be interesting to know if the yaw damper was on. The 35 is difficult to fly Single engine if you approach Vref and you are fighting a crosswind (in this case they land 36L and the wind is 200 at 10 or something like that ...) I saw it a couple of times in the sim where people didn't reengage the YD and were chasing the needles with the pedals. Just my first thoughts, who knows what happened.
Join Date: May 2000
Location: US
Posts: 896
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
LearJet GA, I agree. Add to this multiple power changes on final near Vref and you have a bull by the horns.
I am speaking hypothetically, as I have no idea what the cause of the accident was.
I see you fly Learjets out of Lux?
I am speaking hypothetically, as I have no idea what the cause of the accident was.
I see you fly Learjets out of Lux?
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Toledo, OH
Posts: 409
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I don't remember any fuel imbalance limit other than 600 pounds. I checked all my manuals and can't find it. But it could be due to UK certification or because it was a FC530 A/P. All my books are for the FC200.
Also it became a requirement last year, but has been a prefered option for at least 4 years that engine out landings are make with flaps 20, not full flaps.
I don't believe that the Y/D was that much of an issue.
Unstablized approach with the 'wrong' engine inop, can make for an interestinjg time.
Also it became a requirement last year, but has been a prefered option for at least 4 years that engine out landings are make with flaps 20, not full flaps.
I don't believe that the Y/D was that much of an issue.
Unstablized approach with the 'wrong' engine inop, can make for an interestinjg time.
Join Date: May 2000
Location: US
Posts: 896
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Rick, I do not have my reference books here at home, but the 200 pound imbalance may be in the AFCS supplement. However, I did not realize this was an FC-530 AFCS, so the 200 pound figure I cited may not apply.
Do you fly for American Jets in Houston? If so, I just took a refresher course at SimuFlite with two of your co-workers, or maybe you.
Do you fly for American Jets in Houston? If so, I just took a refresher course at SimuFlite with two of your co-workers, or maybe you.