PDA

View Full Version : Training Captain Pay versus ATCO OJTI


GM WAN TO BE
21st Jul 2005, 21:52
Does anyone one know approximately how much extra training captains get paid in relation to a standard captain(no offence meant)? With the continued pressure to train ATCO's during higher and higher traffic levels, i was wondering if our renumeration was on a similiar scale?

Just found some easyjet stats

Training Captains\' Pay
Line Training Captains £75,305 (12.5% on basic salary)
Type Rating Instructors £76,979 (15% on basic salary)
Type Rating Examiners £78,652 (17.5% on basic salary)
Airborne Base Instructors £80,326 (20% on basic salary)

tobzalp
21st Jul 2005, 22:20
In Oz ATC get 6% to train and only when actually plugged in doing it or debriefing.

5milesbaby
21st Jul 2005, 22:55
In NATS (UK) we get an extra spine point on the pay scale (approx 3%) and then if we meet the required targets for training unit based over 3 months we then get a bonus of something like 1% basic (average after tax £250).

Basically it doesn't compare to pilot training pay at all.

Barnaby the Bear
22nd Jul 2005, 00:17
Outside of NATS, you are lucky to get a luncheon voucher! :}

Friio4
22nd Jul 2005, 05:13
Mine doesnt compare at all with pilots. About 1.2% above basic. I'm afraid having an OJTI ticket is all but useless when it comes to renumeration. The responsibilty that is attached to it appears to be lost on the bean counters, in my opinion.

Lock n' Load
22nd Jul 2005, 05:49
AAAARRRRRGGGGGHHHHHH!!!!

People, please. The word is reMuNeration.
Class dismissed.

VectorLine
22nd Jul 2005, 11:16
AAARRRGGGH!

LOCK N' LOAD f :mad: :mad: k off! The grammar/spelling police are not welcome here. Go back to your "Eats, shoots and leaves"

30W
22nd Jul 2005, 12:41
Basically guys, stop training and when they ask why tell them it's not financially worth the hassle.

Only when they aren't able to train will they be forced to address why and do something about it..........

For what it's worth, my company pays Type rated Examiners 20% above basic, Line Training Capt's 10% above basic.

30W

Lock n' Load
22nd Jul 2005, 13:13
Vector Line; using the correct word is nothing to do with grammer. It has a lot to do with precision and this is a precision job.
I corrected the use of the wrong word in good humour, and your epithet-laden response is far more unwelcome.
In the words of Billy Connely, YOU F*** OFF!

rodan
22nd Jul 2005, 13:19
Billy Connely
I believe the great man spells his name 'Connolly'.

Del Prado
22nd Jul 2005, 13:44
....and it's grammar.

Legs11
22nd Jul 2005, 13:59
pedants unite:rolleyes:

Loki
22nd Jul 2005, 19:47
Once you`ve got an OJTI ticket, it can prove a tricky business getting rid of it, or not making use of it when required.

The attitude of one major UK employer historically is that training is part of the atco`s normal task.

GM WAN TO BE
22nd Jul 2005, 22:48
An ATCO top of the scale gets an extra 3% for being an OJTI. Perhaps things will improve with the new structure we've been promised, otherwise there could be a lack of OJTI's in the future!!

Jerricho
23rd Jul 2005, 00:45
Nav Canada pay a flat rate of $8.50 per hour, no matter what level of the pay scale you're on.

After tax, it equates to about a happy meal at McDonalds.

cossack
23rd Jul 2005, 17:10
After tax, it equates to about a happy meal at McDonalds
Every hour!!!
:yuk: :yuk: :yuk:

Jerricho
23rd Jul 2005, 17:12
Hows about 2 double-doubles and a box of Tim-bits ;)

Scott Voigt
23rd Jul 2005, 22:14
In the US FAA controllers get 10% extra while plugged in and getting shots at your ticket made by trainee <G>....

regards

Scott

DirtyPierre
23rd Jul 2005, 22:23
Tobzalp,

Don't we get 8.5% above salary increment now for OJTI? And as Scott says all the shots your trainee can take at your licence.

Tower Ranger
24th Jul 2005, 10:16
Yes, there is a total lack of understanding from management that you are putting your licence on the line and there have been many days when it just ain`t worth the risk, about £1 a day after tax in my case, but..............

If you`re just training someone to get a few extra pennies you`re in the wrong place. I see training as one of the more important parts of the job. It gives us the chance to pass on our experience to the people who within a couple of months will be making all the decisions for themselves.

If you can`t get satisfaction watching a trainee going from a zero hours newbie to a validated controller and on the way picking up something it took you years to learn then don`t bother.

How many of the people complaining about not getting enough cash for training were trained by people getting paid nothing for the pleasure of watching them stumble out of the starting blocks. Always remember where you came from you may be going back some day!

Behindblooeyes
24th Jul 2005, 10:22
Doesn't that rather make the assumption that we're all out there doing the job just for the love of it? I work because I need the money, and as we are forever being told that air traffic is now a commercial business like any other, I would like to think that specialist skills and work over and above the basics should be rewarded accordingly.

If I employ a plumber to fix my bolier I would expect him to charge me X, if I then ask him to sort my cistern out at the same time I would then expect to pay X + a lot! Is there a difference?

DFC
24th Jul 2005, 20:22
If I employ a plumber to fix my bolier I would expect him to charge me X, if I then ask him to sort my cistern out at the same time I would then expect to pay X + a lot! Is there a difference?

The plumber will not for ever whinge about having to train an apprentice or expect to be paid lots mor for doing it.

The plumber will not for ever whinge about what would happen to his job if the apprentice mucks up on a boiler repair and people are killed in the explosion 10 days later.

The plumber can be paid more than an ATCO and TRE combined per hour!

There's 3 good ones. :)

Regards,

DFC

Behindblooeyes
24th Jul 2005, 23:41
Errrm, explain please? The plumber will not appear in court if his apprentice kills people through his ommisions, I might!

Frunobulax
25th Jul 2005, 10:03
@ Tower Ranger:

I couldn't agree more.

VectorLine
25th Jul 2005, 11:02
Behindblooeyes

as we are forever being told that air traffic is now a commercial business like any other, I would like to think that specialist skills and work over and above the basics should be rewarded accordingly

I absolutely agree. Taking it from a NATS perspective, as that's the only one I have;

The Red Barron has been banging on about his order book flying overhead everyday and, I paraphrase from a recent open meeting, "The only reason you run a business is to make money"

Air traffic controllers sell their skill to the company for the a salary (and a pretty decent one at that). However, we sell our skill (or lack of it?) as teachers to the company for very little extra. Also, in my opinion, the training we get in OJTI is woefully inadequate.

Maybe it's time to reduce the number of OJTIs. Make the course longer and more in depth. Highly specialised OJTIs, selected for their ability in this task and pay them more for it (ATCO1 at LACC?). It could be considered a 'skill' counting towards minimum unit requirement, so one could drop a sector or T/P.

However,
The plumber will not appear in court if his apprentice kills people through his ommisions, I might!

The plumber probably would. It's still negligence and people die.

tori chelli
25th Jul 2005, 14:43
Under the law of Tort (neat pun :O :D ) and vicarious liability, the plumber, as an expert in his field, would definitely be responsible for the (vicarious) actions of his apprentice (trainee).

Tori

Number2
25th Jul 2005, 14:59
Are controllers really experts in their field?!

Frunobulax
25th Jul 2005, 16:15
No, they're not.
A monkey could do it better ;)

VectorLine
25th Jul 2005, 16:42
Monkeys don't live in fields

CosmosSchwartz
25th Jul 2005, 17:37
Can you really compare an atco to a pilot...........


Crash helmet - check, emergency rations - check

Blue touch paper - lit! :E

rodan
25th Jul 2005, 20:56
Can you really compare an atco to a pilot...........
Good point, actually. How much more than pilots do you think we ought to be paid? ;)

Captain Mayday
25th Jul 2005, 23:06
So..... what if I'm an ATCO ..... and a pilot ... ? And an instructor on both ...... ? :E

PAN-MAYDAY-FLICK-SPIN-CRASH :\

CosmosSchwartz
26th Jul 2005, 11:43
:p :p

To be honest, as a pilot I find myself comparing pay to Train drivers, seeing as they earn more than me!:rolleyes:


I'm not kidding!:ouch:

Seriously!:sad: