PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Airlines, Airports & Routes (https://www.pprune.org/airlines-airports-routes-85/)
-   -   BELFAST CITY AIRPORT (BHD) (https://www.pprune.org/airlines-airports-routes/474930-belfast-city-airport-bhd.html)

BFS watcher 8th Jul 2017 09:27


Originally Posted by EI-A330-300 (Post 9823988)
Shame to see them ending early but W routes are always a pain for operators. If they are not making money they are not worth it.

The 21.99 rescue fare by FR tells it's own story.

A couple of thousand people left in the lurch by Aer Lingus and you say it is a shame that they ended early. It is an absolute disgrace and it looks like the Consumer Council are going after them. It shows the Aer Lingus arrogance that they think they could take on Easyjet from the "higher yield" City Airport and win! Throw Ryanair and Jet2 in as well and game over.

mart901 8th Jul 2017 09:54

By that argument then if they were flying from BFS still everything would be well.

Cozy F 8th Jul 2017 10:12

This is about Aer Lingus and their dalliances with Northern Ireland - not about BFS or BHD.

Presume they must have a load of seats still to sell to Spain this summer out of Dublin with not only a lot less northerners going to DUB, but more and more people from ROI using Belfast as a departure point because of the exchange rate. Solution for Aer Lingus - can your Belfast departures in the height of the season and try to give people already booked with them little choice but to go on their Dublin flights.

It's nothing new. They turned up on Belfast transatlantic services just after the nineties ceasefires in NI and once they were satisfied nothing too challenging was going to happen from Belfast they ran back to Dublin under cover of the 9/11 aftermath.

Then they rocked up in a blaze of glory in 2007 when the DUP and Sinn Fein co-joined to make a go of Government in NI and once the economics turned sour they gradually drew back from that preferring to promote their Dublin flights to NI based customers.

Predictable history is only repeating itself again now. They have no interest in Belfast, unless they feel there is a reason to have a presence here to mind their established market in Dublin.

Given current general uncertainties and dynamics no doubt there'll be further examples of their Hokey Cokey approach yet to come!

BFS watcher 8th Jul 2017 10:16


Originally Posted by mart901 (Post 9824275)
By that argument then if they were flying from BFS still everything would be well.

Nothing to do with that at all just Aer Lingus' complete disregard for Northern Ireland.....I have never ever seen a carrier of the "quality" of Aer Lingus just stop early because the route was not performing with only 6 weeks notice. Even you have to see that it is a complete disgrace.

mart901 8th Jul 2017 10:17

I totally agree on that point yes

mart901 8th Jul 2017 10:21

I think it's worth remembering it was only ever a matter of time before EI went to BHD, IAG would never have had them operating from both. I'd say next year we'll see FAO and AGP as they seem to be the most popular sunshine routes for EI. On the point of disregard for Northern Ireland I'd say EI have a disregard for anything outside DUB, in the same way as BA have disregard for anything outside London.

Cozy F 8th Jul 2017 10:37

I don't think IAG had anything Directly to do with Aer Lingus going to BHD in 2012.

Rather BA had just taken over BMi and Aer Lingus already had a relationship / codeshare with BA, thought that BA management would just fold up short haul and hand the Heathrow and Gatwick feed to a 'partner' to monopolise from Edinburgh, Belfast, Manchester, Glasgow .. At that point Aer Lingus were just trying to establish pole position for that day.

BA didn't actually do that, and now five years on, things with BA and EI have progressed another stage.

On your point about disregard outside Dublin, this is exactly why NI air travellers should treat Aer Lingus with considerable cynicism - and for that matter arguably BA too.

They don't have the track record of Flybe, easyJet or Jet2 from Belfast.

mart901 8th Jul 2017 10:43

In fairness through I know people who have been left high and dry by EZY cancelling routes out of MAN and we all know FR's record in the not too distant past on such matters.

Cozy F 8th Jul 2017 11:12

Granted, but no one does the will they / won't they lack of respect for Belfast flyers quite so prolifically as AerLingus.

BFS watcher 8th Jul 2017 11:23

[QUOTE=mart901;9824309]In fairness through I know people who have been left high and dry by EZY cancelling routes out of MAN and we all know FR's record in the not too distant past on such matters.[/QUOTE In general Flybe and Easyjet have been loyal to the Northern Ireland market. As for the 2 carriers from Dublin they treat us with the same level of respect as Shannon Cork and the other regional airports in The Free State. London Airways not much better either!

EI-A330-300 8th Jul 2017 12:06


A couple of thousand people left in the lurch by Aer Lingus and you say it is a shame that they ended early. It is an absolute disgrace and it looks like the Consumer Council are going after them. It shows the Aer Lingus arrogance that they think they could take on Easyjet from the "higher yield" City Airport and win! Throw Ryanair and Jet2 in as well and game over.
Except it's not a couple of thousand, if it was the routes would still operate.....

I don't recall EI saying anything about higher yielding airport in NI.

Awful soar grapes over a commercial decision!


This is about Aer Lingus and their dalliances with Northern Ireland - not about BFS or BHD.

Presume they must have a load of seats still to sell to Spain this summer out of Dublin with not only a lot less northerners going to DUB, but more and more people from ROI using Belfast as a departure point because of the exchange rate. Solution for Aer Lingus - can your Belfast departures in the height of the season and try to give people already booked with them little choice but to go on their Dublin flights.

It's nothing new. They turned up on Belfast transatlantic services just after the nineties ceasefires in NI and once they were satisfied nothing too challenging was going to happen from Belfast they ran back to Dublin under cover of the 9/11 aftermath.

Then they rocked up in a blaze of glory in 2007 when the DUP and Sinn Fein co-joined to make a go of Government in NI and once the economics turned sour they gradually drew back from that preferring to promote their Dublin flights to NI based customers.

Predictable history is only repeating itself again now. They have no interest in Belfast, unless they feel there is a reason to have a presence here to mind their established market in Dublin.

Given current general uncertainties and dynamics no doubt there'll be further examples of their Hokey Cokey approach yet to come!
EI having an excellent summer DUB, if anything its FR who are diluting their passengers who would of used DUB or do you believe only NI people flew EI from DUB and put 2 and 2 to come up with 5??

OneBellEnd 8th Jul 2017 12:32

Assume if your handle is anything to go by, we can expect a balanced assessment!

Who actually mentioned Ryanair here?? They're still flying passengers from Belfast to Spain this summer, while Aer Lingus are leaving local NI travellers in the lurch mid-season.

Take it on the chin and concentrate on something that's defensible.

AerRyan 8th Jul 2017 12:39

Quite the conspiracy theory.

I'm afraid anything will work to help you deny that the market simply isn't there, and they Aer Lingus simply don't want to fight off EZY, RYR, Jet 2 and others.

West Brit 8th Jul 2017 12:57


Originally Posted by AerRyan (Post 9824400)
Quite the conspiracy theory.

I'm afraid anything will work to help you deny that the market simply isn't there, and they Aer Lingus simply don't want to fight off EZY, RYR, Jet 2 and others.

There is a market, just too many seats put up!

AerRyan 8th Jul 2017 12:59


Originally Posted by West Brit (Post 9824417)
There is a market, just too many seats put up!

Well that's kinda what I implied.

EI-A330-300 8th Jul 2017 13:25


Assume if your handle is anything to go by, we can expect a balanced assessment!

Who actually mentioned Ryanair here?? They're still flying passengers from Belfast to Spain this summer, while Aer Lingus are leaving local NI travellers in the lurch mid-season.

Take it on the chin and concentrate on something that's defensible.
Nobody directly but the poster just assumed with less people using DUB EI are pulling BHD to fill seats ex DUB......

Just pointing out not everybody in NI uses EI ex DUB and if anything FR are the biggest carrier f pax ex NI at DUB.

Startledgrapefruit 8th Jul 2017 16:31


Originally Posted by EI-A330-300 (Post 9823988)
Shame to see them ending early but W routes are always a pain for operators. If they are not making money they are not worth it.

The 21.99 rescue fare by FR tells it's own story.

Yup. Wee fecked them now we make ourselves look like we are the heros.

mart901 9th Jul 2017 07:56


Originally Posted by GAZMO (Post 9823521)
Looks like FR picking up the mess that EI have left customers in
Passengers angry over Aer Lingus cancellations - BBC News

Ryanair the white Knight ♞.... anyone tried to find a £21.99 fare will find there isn't any in September!!!

DC9_10 9th Jul 2017 14:34

Belfasts favourite airport ?

cuthere 9th Jul 2017 14:49

As the only airport in Belfast surely it is both Belfast's favourite and least favourite airport? Or does Belfast include Antrim in your world?

A320.b744 9th Jul 2017 15:28


Originally Posted by cuthere (Post 9825435)
As the only airport in Belfast surely it is both Belfast's favourite and least favourite airport? Or does Belfast include Antrim in your world?

BFS is 19.4 miles away from Belfast city centre. If BFS can't be Belfast then should CDG and FCO lose their 'Paris' and 'Rome' titles, as they're the same distance away from Paris and Rome as BFS is from Belfast. Or what about JFK (20.7 miles), MUC (23.7 miles), DEN (27.3 miles)? BFS isn't in the city centre, but it sure is Belfast's main airport.

cuthere 9th Jul 2017 15:45

Tongue. Cheek.

mart901 9th Jul 2017 16:10

Well we have a choice of airport and for that I am grateful.

panpanpanpan 10th Jul 2017 09:47

So lets leave aside all the politics of which airport is best etc etc save to say there are still 2 commercial entities that are in healthy competition and we are not dealing with a duplicate government dept that can be consolidated at the whim of some faceless civil servant. :cool:

Would anyone have a crystal ball and predict where NI aviation will be in 10 years time, if thats a bit ambitious maybe 5 years! I wonder will Aldergrove be another Heathrow by that stage, maybe Harbour will be a small biz jet airfield and Eglinton will be????

Or maybe it will just be groundhog day with the same old arguments and debates, I suppose that is one thing we are all experts at in good old Ulster.:p

West Brit 10th Jul 2017 14:07

Well Pan... I would suggest that if the current model exits then margins will be tight at both facilities, thus no real investment at both apart from little capital projects here and there within each facility. Thus stagnant!

What I would like to see is BHD closed and turned into a useful urban space - which would make much more money for the current owner than what is on offer at present. It would also improve the well being of 10,000s of folk living under the flight path at the moment.
BFS would have to accommodate 8m passengers per annum in the current climate, thus would have to build a proper facility to cope. Public bodies would have to invest in infrastructure to and from the airport. Everybody happy! Belfast would become a normal city within aviation terms for the size of its market. Until that happens stagnation will be the norm.

GAZMO 10th Jul 2017 14:48

If I could dream then one airport for NI with proper infrastructure in terms of road and rail connections. Proper terminal building. Not to start a debate but I feel BFS is the better location. Now back to my dream 💤💤💤💤

BFS101 10th Jul 2017 15:03

Eastern Airways announces Belfast - Newcastle route


A new regional air link is to be provided between Belfast City airport and Newcastle.
Daily weekday flights are to be run by Eastern Airways from September 1.
Fares start at £59 one-way, including taxes and charges.
Eastern Airways started its first scheduled service from Belfast City earlier this year by securing the future of flights to the Isle of Man following the liquidation of Citywing.
The new route announcement comes a month after Eastern Airways entered into a partnership with Belfast City’s largest carrier Flybe via a franchise agreement starting on October 29.
Eastern Airways head of commercial Mathew Herzberg said: “This new non-stop service from Belfast City Airport is not only providing a convenient link to the busy commercial centre of Newcastle, but it’s also the gateway to the rest of the north east of England including Northumberland, Sunderland and Teesside.

DC9_10 10th Jul 2017 17:10

Don't get to excited. It's just the Ncl/Iom/Bhd routing Ncl/Bhd/Iom and vice versa.

A320.b744 10th Jul 2017 17:21


Originally Posted by DC9_10 (Post 9826456)
Don't get to excited. It's just the Ncl/Iom/Bhd routing Ncl/Bhd/Iom and vice versa.

From 1st September the route of the aircraft is NCL-BHD-IOM-BHD-NCL, so both BHD-IOM and BHD-NCL will be non stop flights.

DC9_10 10th Jul 2017 17:43

That's what I just said.

BFS watcher 10th Jul 2017 20:49


Originally Posted by DC9_10 (Post 9826484)
That's what I just said.

Easyjet will be quaking in their Airbuses!

Startledgrapefruit 10th Jul 2017 22:01


Originally Posted by BFS watcher (Post 9826667)
Easyjet will be quaking in their Airbuses!

The flying monkeys cage has been rattled again

EI-A330-300 17th Jul 2017 23:54

EI have put AGP/FAO on sale for 2018 both start 1 May. Others may not return IMO but early days.

GAZMO 18th Jul 2017 07:42

Is this one month later than the start dates for this year? Think they started at the beginning of the summer schedule (late March 2017)

BFS watcher 18th Jul 2017 11:56

Death by a thousand shamrocks going on.

EI-A330-300 18th Jul 2017 12:24

Yeah April start 4 or 5 weekly mostly.

mart901 18th Jul 2017 13:59


Originally Posted by BFS watcher (Post 9834556)
Death by a thousand shamrocks going on.

In all fairness if it's not going to pay them there's little or no point. Last year and previous years they've put the flights on sale at the same time as EZY and in comparison with LS and the charter operators this is way too late. Normally PMI and ALC are announced later but obviously this may or may not happen.

EI-A330-300 18th Jul 2017 14:03

Easter on 1 April 2018 will not of helped in making the decision. If it was mid April I am sure they would of started earlier.

mart901 18th Jul 2017 14:16

Any word on the other routes EIA330-300

EI-A330-300 18th Jul 2017 14:18

No idea but given they are ending in August combined with the pain that W routes are one wouldn't hold out much hope.


All times are GMT. The time now is 03:38.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.