PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Accidents and Close Calls (https://www.pprune.org/accidents-close-calls-139/)
-   -   Cardiff City Footballer Feared Missing after aircraft disappeared near Channel Island (https://www.pprune.org/accidents-close-calls/617514-cardiff-city-footballer-feared-missing-after-aircraft-disappeared-near-channel-island.html)

anchorhold 22nd Jan 2019 22:50

While I agree with the above that AOCs provide a level of safety, nothing is being done about WINGLY flights either. In fact someone is offering WINGLY flights from Cardiff to Jersey and Alderney in a PA28 during the winter months, it is unlikely that the WINGLY pax understand that these pilots are not professionals and that they really should be wearing immersion suits in the event of a engine failure.

Fostex 22nd Jan 2019 23:01

Agree, it is just a matter of time before Wingly claims it's first victim.

Interestingly, my insurance policy explicitly forbids Wingly style flights - I wonder how many people are offering Wingly flights in aircraft for which this is the case.

Mike Flynn 22nd Jan 2019 23:37


cncpc 23rd Jan 2019 02:58

I used to fly piston Malibus, but I've never heard of an unpressurized one.

cncpc 23rd Jan 2019 03:11


Originally Posted by DaveReidUK (Post 10367417)
Sala was reportedly making a return/farewell visit to Nantes, having signed the transfer deal in Cardiff on Saturday 19th.

It may of course be coincidence, but Malibu N264DB was noted departing Rhoose on Saturday morning, flightplanned to Guernsey.

It's an entry-level, piston-powered Malibu 310P (Continental TSIO-520).

I wouldn't describe it as entry level. A 172 is entry level.

There have been a number of Malibu accidents.


cncpc 23rd Jan 2019 03:23

Stand corrected. The poster above is right on the unpressurized Matrix model.

saffi 23rd Jan 2019 03:44

Newspaper claims this is his last audio message sent from the airplane, complaining about the rough ride.

https://www.ole.com.ar/informacion-g...MKFFqSb_h.html

atakacs 23rd Jan 2019 05:34

Hmm would be interesting to know which cell tower relayed that message.


Mike Flynn 23rd Jan 2019 06:14

The football club spend £15million on a player and then use a single crewed Malibu instead of at least a King Air beggars belief.

Two pilots up front might have helped but as the recent San Sebastian accident demonstrates marginal VFR flying at this time of the year is a killer.

I flew a PA 28 many times from Cardiff to the Channel Islands for the cheap fuel 30 years ago.

Would I do it today? I’m a lot older and the answer is a big no.


DaveReidUK 23rd Jan 2019 06:41


Originally Posted by cncpc (Post 10367931)
I wouldn't describe it as entry level.

Well OK - it's the initial, lowest-powered, out-of-production version of the Malibu, if you prefer. :O

The Old Fat One 23rd Jan 2019 06:46


Even so, many life policies specifically exclude deaths in non-commercial or GA aircraft.
One hopes it is no way relevant to this thread, I'm merely correcting a falsehood having worked in the life insurance industry, the quoted statement is completely wrong.

What follows is valid in the UK and throughout Europe

Life insurance policies cover flying activities of all kinds through their special conditions, which appear to the customer (the insured) through extended questioning on said flying activity at the point of application and which will be legally recorded in the statement of particulars. All insurance providers differ in a marginal manner as to how they treat all manner of special conditions.

Generally, life insurance providers will not load for occasional flying activity (ie as an occasional passenger) but if they did for any reason, it would be clearly indicated in the life insurance cover documents.

Regular flying (ie as crew) will usually be covered following an analysis of the activity and with a subsequent premium loading.

Once on cover, and assuming nobody has told any fibs in the application, life insurance policies very, very, very rarely fail to pay out - the industry is massively regulated.

Sorry for the derail

DaveReidUK 23rd Jan 2019 06:49


Originally Posted by Edddrewre (Post 10367816)
I know there is an N reg in the hangar at Swansea - I have a photo of it. Not the same as the Norfolk pa46.

Thanks, but the question was which Malibu could have been used for Sala's round trip from Rhoose to Nantes. If it was the Swansea aircraft, nobody seems to have recorded it passing through CWL.

Incidentally, it's misleading to refer to N264DB as "the Norfolk PA-46".. I don't know where it's actually based, but it's probably not East Anglia, ditto the other 900-odd aircraft registered to SAC at that Bungay HQ address.

Air Soul 23rd Jan 2019 06:55



N264DB hasn’t ever been tracked by ADS-B Exchange, who don’t filter anything.

sellbydate 23rd Jan 2019 07:07

1984 PIPER MALIBU 46-8408037 N264DB owned by a lady Nr Mansfield, registered to what looks like a family consultancy business

ETOPS 23rd Jan 2019 07:22

Sorry sellbydate buts that's a misunderstanding.

American registered aircraft cannot be owned by foreign nationals thus there is a system of "trusteeship" to get round that. All the UK based N reg aircraft are registered to just a handful of such entities such as Southern Aircraft. It also has the side effect of hiding the true owner.

ATC Watcher 23rd Jan 2019 07:27

To correct a few points : Guernsey is class D airspace at this altitude, so you need a transponder to enter, they normally do not give exceptions .. Any aircraft whatever its registration nationality that wants to fly in EASA airspace requires a mode S transponder . Mode A/C are no longer to be used,, In the USA you can still use the old A/C transponder but then you cannot enter, let alone be based in European airspace.
Same for ELTs, to fly in a powered aircraft in the EASA airspace you need a 406 ELT. As correctly said they normally activate on impact . but if antennae is damaged on impact or under water it does not work ( i.e AF447 , MH 270, etc.. )
To cross a EU border you need a flight plan , and yes there was an IFR one filed . not night VFR

Sadly this morning on French radio played a recording of Sala from inside the aircraft ( in Spanish) said to be afraid of the poor state of the aircraft .:-(

sellbydate 23rd Jan 2019 07:29

Wrong - title is to Southern Aircraft Consultancy but actual ownership is an individual in Mansfield

Flyguy2006 23rd Jan 2019 07:37

There is a video on the BBC website titled My Life as a ferry pilot and it's show this aircraft mentioned above. It feels very eerie listening to what he says.

Gurnard 23rd Jan 2019 07:42

Thinking of 1981...
Some aspects of this tragic event bring back memories of the loss of P.68 EC-DHE on 3rd October 1981. The aircraft departed from Cardiff with pilot plus 4 pax on board on a night IFR to Alicante but disappeared off Guernsey and has never been found. Reports suggest there had been loss of an engine but I recall icing was talked about at the time.

Flyguy2006 23rd Jan 2019 07:47


Originally Posted by ATC Watcher (Post 10368052)
The French media have released the name of the pilot : " D.H. age 60 flying the aircraft since 2006" could that be the same individual ? .

DH is the guy shown in the video I mentioned. I can't link it as I haven't reached 10 posts.

Gurnard 23rd Jan 2019 07:54

"My Life as a Ferry Pilot" BBC News 12 October 2015. In it DH talks of the challenge and of a number of ferry pilots he knew who never made it. He stands alongside N264DB and demonstrates its instruments. Eerie indeed....

Mike Flynn 23rd Jan 2019 08:12

zNewspapers are carrying details of one of the last messages from the passenger.


A transcript of the audio reads: "Hey brothers, how's everything going? Brother, I'm dead. I was in Nantes doing stuff, stuff, stuff and stuff... neverending, neverending, neverending, neverending. So anyway boys, I'm now on a plane which seems to be falling apart.

"And now I'm leaving for Cardiff, crazy that tomorrow I'll be training in the afternoon with my new teammates. We'll see what happens.

"So how are things with you brothers? All well?

"In an hour and a half if you haven't had news of me, I don't know if they'll send someone to look for me, because they're not going to find me. But, you know...

"Dad, I'm so scared."



Gurnard 23rd Jan 2019 08:21


Originally Posted by Oldpilot55 (Post 10368082)
DH is not the pilot missing in this accident.

Another case of unhelpful media then. They are taking a long time to reveal the identity of the individual while the passenger's name was revealed almost as soon as the PA46 was reported missing.

WHBM 23rd Jan 2019 08:21


Originally Posted by Gurnard (Post 10368069)
"My Life as a Ferry Pilot" BBC News 12 October 2015. In it DH talks of the challenge and of a number of ferry pilots he knew who never made it. He stands alongside N264DB and demonstrates its instruments. Eerie indeed....

This seems the story

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/magazi...-a-ferry-pilot

piperboy84 23rd Jan 2019 08:34


Originally Posted by sellbydate (Post 10368039)
Wrong - title is to Southern Aircraft Consultancy but actual ownership is an individual in Mansfield

I think ETOPS is correct. "Ownership" of the aircraft is listed on the title and shows on the FAA website, whether that's one individual or more, a corporate entity or in this case a trust, due I suspect to it being an N reg based in the UK. Whatever arrangement the trust has with the individual who is in possession of the plane is irrelevant to the FAA. Not all N reg in the UK are owned by a trust however, if you are a US citizen you can hold title in your own name without the need for a trust.

Mike Flynn 23rd Jan 2019 08:40

BBC reporting the football club are claiming the player booked the flight.


Cardiff City chairman Mehmet Dalman said players and fans were in a "state of shock".

"We are still praying," he said, adding that the club had received messages of support from around the world.

The "family of football has a way of coming together at times of tragedy," Mr Dalman told BBC Radio Wales' Good Morning Wales programme.

He also confirmed that the club had not booked the plane for the trip, adding that Sala had "made his own arrangements".

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-wales-46966424

ohinever 23rd Jan 2019 08:59

Having been intimately involved with the signing of and life insurance exmainations for professional footballers for several years, I would be sadly surprised if all the insurance paperwork had gone through at this stage.

My experience is that this would be sorted once the player arrived for training.

Cardiff however could be much more "efficiently" run, and could possibly have some interim insurance to cover such eventualities.

My heartfelt sympathies to all involved.

Chris Kebab 23rd Jan 2019 09:03

So who is leading on the Accident Investigation on this - nothing from the AAIB.

bakerpictures 23rd Jan 2019 09:08

BBC R4 news reporting that it's possible that the footballer and one other person might have climbed into a life-raft.

That's surely based on the Ferry Pilot clip where it's explained that on trans-Atlantic crossings there is a life-raft in the back to buy him up to 8hrs although he adds that he wears a neoprene immersion suit. But they wouldn't have been wearing neoprene on this occasion (would they?) so unless based on rescue services knowledge, the lift-raft possibility would be way off the mark, no?

runway30 23rd Jan 2019 09:21

I have no reason to doubt the statement from the club but something doesn’t add up here
1) There are reports that his mother said the aircraft was arranged by the club
2) He doesn’t seem to be at all comfortable with light aircraft so was he someone who would lease a plane and then go out and hire himself a pilot
3) At the very least the club had knowledge of his travel plans and I would have thought would have taken a close interest in the safety of their very expensive “asset”

WHBM 23rd Jan 2019 09:21

It's a shame he didn't just book airline.

Most effectively AF/KLM through Amsterdam, as there is no reasonable connection at Paris. 1715 from Nantes arrive Ametsrdam 1900. 2120 from Amsterdam arrive Cardiff 2140. Seems little different to the light aircraft times.

Regarding the statement that the passenger had arranged the aircraft himself, I think we would be a bit surprised if he knew, personally, where to start with this. It will be notable to learn who/what else the owner had used this aircraft for over time.

AndoniP 23rd Jan 2019 09:29


Originally Posted by Chris Kebab (Post 10368137)
So who is leading on the Accident Investigation on this - nothing from the AAIB.

not under their jurisdiction I believe.

Gurnard 23rd Jan 2019 09:41

Icing sounds very likely, but what about the possible effect upon instruments if the passenger was not using his phone in "flight safe mode"? Evidently he was busy sending messages indicating that he was uneasy.

Right Way Up 23rd Jan 2019 09:56


I have no reason to doubt the statement from the club but something doesn’t add up here
1) There are reports that his mother said the aircraft was arranged by the club
2) He doesn’t seem to be at all comfortable with light aircraft so was he someone who would lease a plane and then go out and hire himself a pilot
3) At the very least the club had knowledge of his travel plans and I would have thought would have taken a close interest in the safety of their very expensive “asset”
One person who hasn't been mentioned yet in all of this is his agent! I would have thought the chances he booked the flight are fairly high.

hegemon88 23rd Jan 2019 10:04


Originally Posted by ATC Watcher (Post 10368035)
To correct a few points : Guernsey is class D airspace at this altitude, so you need a transponder to enter, they normally do not give exceptions .. Any aircraft whatever its registration nationality that wants to fly in EASA airspace requires a mode S transponder . Mode A/C are no longer to be used,, In the USA you can still use the old A/C transponder but then you cannot enter, let alone be based in European airspace.

Is it 100% accurate? Last year I bought off the Jersey Aeroclub fleet, consisting of two fairly old, Mode C-only PA28s. Not only had they been operated daily in that Class D airspace chunk (mostly VFR) but when I ferried them out of Jersey, each time on an IFR flight plan, Mode C was never a problem.

Now, flying -DT through Belgium later was a completely different matter - I had to circumnavigate every bit of controlled airspace while there. I think it still varies by country, as I have recently flown -DT into and out of EPLL whose TMA is Class C.

Clear as mud.

runway30 23rd Jan 2019 10:23


Originally Posted by Right Way Up (Post 10368197)
One person who hasn't been mentioned yet in all of this is his agent! I would have thought the chances he booked the flight are fairly high.

I know absolutely nothing about football but I do know that the agent is French. How would a football agent in France find an aircraft at Gamston then hire a pilot to fly it?

Clare Prop 23rd Jan 2019 10:23

I spent a few years flying VFR around the Channel Islands, the weather can change very quickly and there are some very strong sea currents around Alderney, so even if they got into a life raft they would still be in real trouble. How sad for all involved.


All times are GMT. The time now is 15:42.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.