To vote yes is, fairly clearly, to give up any leverage over the company for the foreseeable future.
There will be no CC/TB unless we decide to cancel this agreement and abandon the meagre salary raise, 25 years housing (-ish) and HKPA raise, which most will not want to do in the future when (not if) the company starts having a go at our contracts again.
In essence, this amounts to completely disarming the HKAOA, pretty much forever, or at least long enough for the company to unleash their worst. And this is exactly what they want.
This is not what anyone wanted to hear, but this is a choice between the status quo and spending the rest of our careers here facing a bully with our hands tied behind our back.
To save our lunch money today is to lose it for the rest of the week (month/year, decade,...).