I am with Step on this. The subject is important enough to warrant its own venue
It is precisely because the subject is so important that is should not have its own venue.
If pilots are of a mind to review and discuss accidents, they can come here to do it.
Do a little pprune research. Check out some of the comments on accident threads on the PF forum. Look at one or two accident threads since this forum has started up.
You will see two trends...
Less traffic and fewer of the "emotive" comments I mentioned.
The pilots of "a mind to review and discuss accidents" are coming here...it is one who are not of that mind that we should be worried about.