Prof2MDA:
Re, "All the stuff about size of the tail, etc., does not hold up when actually analyzed. The "fear factor" has a greater impact on how pilots fly it than anything else. "
Who is doing the aeronautical work regarding analysis of the tail?
And speaking of not holding up, where is "fear factor" in the report?
In re the "size of the tail", there are some pretty clear indications from experienced and knowledgeable aviators who, we see, have lots of time on the aircraft and who are, in my view, qualified to make the statements they've made.
Comments regarding the size of the horizontal stabilizer have also been made in private communications.
On the other hand, nothing has been mentioned regarding "fear factor" but instead what has been mentioned is the aircraft's clear demand for competency and training. In this, there is nothing new even as standards are lower today, with increasinly visible results.