8Driver, no argument, it should be a choice, but right now it's their choice, against our COS, and because it suits some, many others suffer.
The solution is simple: We all agree (and it seems the company finally does too) that the COS does not allow it, but we all agree to give into the company's desire to keep using F PX when the rostering of PX follows certain rules that suit us. Win-win: They save money some or most of the time, and we get what we want (either PX or no PX depending on the situation).
But that would make everyone happy through compromise.