How can you compare a green doctor going through residency to a young pilot being subjected to the rigors of being a rampee? It is not just about the money. It is about the fact that operators exploit these desperate wannabes who are in a desperate situation. How in all good conscience can you condone this as a viable career path?
If a 22 year old kid can be put in command of a high performance jet in the military I see no reason that why these rookies are not cut out for the right seat of a prop. Yes, you can preach about the highest standards of training etc, but is this guy learning anything hauling bags and cleaning planes which is in any way related to his intended profession?
This is a very innovative way to abuse a section of the workforce who have spent their time and money to get that license. To perpetuate this system is sad and unacceptable. Even the thread starter has aptly quoted this career choice as 'slaving it'. The perception fits reality. If this is the only way an operator can gauge a guys work ethic and critical thinking skills, then it is best these so called operators find another job.