Complicate the uncomplicated
I would have been absolutely pleased of this discussion if this thread was based on FACTS from the incident that has happened during that particular day and that particular flight from Doha! But with all my respect to the contributors here, you just don't know what were the events that have led to the crew decision!
I'm sure that many of you here are speaking out based on the superior knowledge and superior skills as superior pilots. But how relevant is that if you cannot construct the factors together and come up with a definite conclusion?
What is shocking though, is to see the great variation in opinions about handling RTO,s and making the Go/No-Go decision!