No, it's a victory for BASSA. It must be, I'm told there's a thread on the BASSA forum titled 'Tough luck pilots - you lost'. I'd love to know the fantasy contents of that but last time I checked it wasn't the pilots in dispute. Meanwhile Duncan is trying to rally the troops by saying what they've achieved from the dispute is not tangible or financially significant but dignity, pride and respect. Aaah I see, a moral victory. Well moral victories are for losers. And he still can't bring himself to be honest about the actual deal.