rustle,
By nature of the beast, bulletin boards will nearly always be one sided. One of the reasons names are not mentioned.
As contributors we have to take posters comments as fact, challenge or ignore responding. Ignoring every disputable comment would lead to a very dull board.
Now, whether the above situation has actually happened or not, it appears to be a common issue for people, so surely it is a positive debate as long as instructors names are not mentioned?
Regards,
LF