PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - BA CC industrial relations (current airline staff only)
Old 24th Oct 2010, 12:29
  #791 (permalink)  
flapsforty
Moderator
 
Join Date: Feb 1998
Location: Europe
Posts: 3,051
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Last post on this thread diversion Lady Fly Fly.

Please read and digest carefully.

Description of Personal Attack

A personal attack is committed when a person substitutes abusive remarks for evidence when attacking another person's claim or claims. This line of "reasoning" is fallacious because the attack is directed at the person making the claim and not the claim itself. The truth value of a claim is independent of the person making the claim. After all, no matter how repugnant an individual might be, he or she can still make true claims.

Not all ad Hominems are fallacious. In some cases, an individual's characteristics can have a bearing on the question of the veracity of her claims. For example, if someone is shown to be a pathological liar, then what he says can be considered to be unreliable. However, such attacks are weak, since even pathological liars might speak the truth on occasion.

In general, it is best to focus one's attention on the content of the claim and not on who made the claim. It is the content that determines the truth of the claim and not the characteristics of the person making the claim.

There are two types of personal attacks:
Saying bad things about another poster. For example: "You are an idiot."
Hurling insults at another poster. For example: "Screw you."

Saying that cabin crew should get a job as doorman does not say anything about another poster. Hence, not a personal attack.
Saying that people here are so pompous does say something about other posters and is a personal attack.

I say again, learn the difference if you want to enjoy your pruning.

Good link: What is a personal attack.
flapsforty is offline