That way those interested could get two different points of view without having every thread shutdown.
Maybe it hasn't occurred to you but could it be possible that the people on the forum where you have decided to post DON'T HAVE TWO DIFFERENT POINTS OF VIEW to discuss. Those in this forum can see through the smoke screen of carrots and can only see the negatives and are trying to warn you about them... If you want the other point of view, perhaps go to the J* interview room and talk to those lining up outside with stars in their eyes and fat wallets...
Agree with Bing Gordon, it is the manner in which this cadetship is setup that is really getting up people's nose more than the fact that it is a cadetship. If it wasn't such a money making venture designed to both make money off training pilots and screw down their T&C's at the same time it would probably be a different story... There might actually be a different point of view to discuss...!