Bo
You're right! I've not flown with these guys; I'm still an FO.
Ask any captain who has and sometimes (not always) and in some instances CAVOK wind calm conditions its like shtin bricks.
And you're right about that as well. But I've spoken with captains who've flown with new FO's with over 2000TT and they've had exactly the same experience as you described above.
The point I was trying to make was that JUST BECAUSE someone is a cadet, doesn't mean that they're going to be crap! Experienced GA pilots can be just as crap when flying "for the airlines"
Hope that explains
DIVOSH!