Well, the companies may be competing, but the pilots aren't!
As a member of ALPA and a United pilot, we always looked forward to Delta, or American, or any other company topping our contract....it simply meant we had a higher base to start from.
I believe that AIPA understands that their fortunes go with our fortunes and they will try as they can to help us improve our conditions. Not so sure AFAP has the same vested interest in us.
So yes, I believe that AUS ALPA and a combination of all pilots in Australia working together will lead to the best outcome. Not an easy task and one that AFAP will not be a part of.
I'm not sure where the information is coming from, but AIPA now represents the majority of Jetstar pilots. AIPA is firmly committed to consolidating the pilots in Australia. Tough task, but at least they are trying....can't say the same for AFAP.