PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - The Generals Must Share the Blame
View Single Post
Old 15th Oct 2009, 13:19
  #6 (permalink)  
ArthurBorges
 
Join Date: May 2009
Location: China (CGO)
Age: 76
Posts: 164
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Gosh Folks

You really oughta read and digest some Col von Clausewitz.

For the few who may not know him, he was just a lowly staff officer -- but no general who had him on his staff ever lost a battle.

Anyhow, this guy is on a par with Sun Tzu Wu.

And he invented Catch 23 before Catch 22 ever got invented.

Essentially, he schematically paragraphs out what to do on a battlefield in every possible scenario, e.g. you're uphill fighting downhill or vice versa. Then he lays down the rules any sensible infantry officer should apply -- but at the end of lists of scenarios he has his Catch 23: "However, in the case of genius (leadership), ignore all of the above."

He never became a general because to rise that high, you seem to have to become sharp at office politics and Col. von Clausewtiz was perhaps too Prussian a professional soldier to stoop to that.

Generals are products of a bureaucratic apparatus.

Most anywhere except in revolutionary armies, which are inceasingly rare nowadays.

If anyone sees this as slandering any particularly high-profile celebrity general, I apologize forthwith.

Think it through anyhow.
ArthurBorges is offline