why is it the ones who shout loudest have the weakest argument.
For info I've worked for airlines throughout Europe and Asia and was always supplied with a briefing report......perhaps its time you worked for a real airline.
Oh and they have removed the authority from the captain to admitting whoever they want. Yes the Capt still has the final say, but they have removed the right of choice.
Also if you read the statutory Doc's they have made it an offence of strict liability. I'll let you read up and make your own opinion