Squeaks, calm down, I never meant this to go to where you would lose the will to live or to play mind games.
I apologize for what some are calling shifting goal posts, I simply neglected to provide too much info so as to try and get a good cross section of opinions, which I did, so thanks to those who posted.
I will now "come clean". The sim in question is the S61, so anyone who really does have time in the old girl will tell you an OEI landing on a deck, unless extremely light, is not an option. The sim is night only.
The situation we were dealing with is an ARA and giving an ENG FIRE where the weather was set so that the crew may become visual. The problem was exactly the same as the discussion going on here now......many opinions/options and the fact that we could not say what the "right" choice was has resulted in this:
No ENG FIRE drills if the rig weather is set to a level that will allow it to become visual.