Originally Posted by
puddle-jumper2
Obviously a single engine failure is not a singular reason to fall out of the sky, please don't be so patronising. I don't rule it out to being a hole in the Swiss cheese though. Something like that can set off a chain of events - i.e. it's the start.
I would rather at this stage believe that than the version where they just stalled a perfectly serviceable A/C into the ground with both engines running.
I think it is looking more and more like they "stalled a perfectly serviceable A/C into the ground with both engines running"
Lost in Siagon,
and you don't think that a witness hearing engine noise could be hearing the live engine when trying to recover then ?
No. The witnesses, and the aircraft's flightpath all point to a stall and attempted recovery with both engines.