I used to enjoy this board when it was a Professional Pilots Forum.
Now its turned into a reggie spotter-Microsoft pilot expert - I have a controversial opinion even though I don't know what I am talking about board.
The guy made a decision based on his companys procedures and the facts that only he knew at the time. That is why he is Captain of his aircraft. The professionals here know that we don't do "probably" or "should be ok".
All the professional pilots here know that.
Now - if anyone has a knowledgeable/ sensible/ useful comment to make AND they are a professional pilot then please go ahead. Everyone else, feel free to read, but please don't bother posting. This will save those of us for whom this board was set up a lot of time. Thanks.