Nitty
Here's the thing. Assuming you are correct, and I am sure you probably are to a point; the Polar FE's may not return. However, as long as Atlas is flying the Polar flights, the FE's would be drawing a salary for sitting at home, and the Captain downgrades would be paid a Captain's salary while sitting in the right seat (according to the CBA). So it isn't a one shot deal. I am sure the slugs at AAWWH will not stand for that. Like I said, ponificate all you want but would not it be better to see what the arbitrator decides and the AAWWH counter offer to the union? Speculation for speculation's sake ony fans the fires of discontent.