From my quite close experience of 1F and Happy 4 on the boat over the last few years I would have no qualms about the RAF operating JCA off CVF - the guys on these 2 squadrons embrace the challenge, enjoy the experience and generally leave wanting to come back - the bunfights only occur higher up the food chain.
Does the new CAS hate the RN as much as Torpy? If so the bunfights will continue ..........................