Complete and utter waste of time and will end up with those thinking they know better using the position to brow beat others as already happens now but with an official stick.
Then of course what happens to those who think they should be asked due to considerable experience and are vetoed by the self appointed experts because they will have no doubt crossed swords at some stage.
It is not broke and does not need fixing. If people find the forum to volatile then they can go elsewhere. I personally find Paul does a pretty good job at moderation.
And at the end of the day, this is a rumour network not a kindergarten for those who need hand holding. There is a perfectly good students forum here and on flyer.