I do not head for Canada in the winter so it is not a problem for me if we do or do not do it and if it does go I wait with interest to see what the company does, my own feeling is that they will shed more permanent pilots and use more temp pilots in the summer which actually achieves the reverse of what everyone wants,and I very much doubt that this will actually cause them to retain any more, if you feel that is not the case then good luck to you - I will not stand in your way.