Wow.This thread has really stirred up a s
storm
Where is Flying Lawyer on this one?
I love the idea on name and shame but in reality I think it Pprune would be diving deep into Libel territory for hosting that one.
Not to mention that it would be abused more than used. I fear the vigilanty more than the PPL hopping around the darker side of the grey areas.
As with all laws, good or bad, are there for the guidance of wise men and the obeyance of fools.
I do like all the hypothetical senarios to justify what the pilot him/herself will know is either right or wrong. This I think will always remain an emotive topic because I feel that this problem will continue to exist within the aviation business.
NB