TDJ mk2, I think you will find it is a bit more than 'She said he said...'. I'm told the press reports do not capture the mood in the court room, nor do they report how strongly the tide is running against Ryanair (but this perception depends on the reporter, does it not?). But it does seem at this point as though there will be clear findings on important issues of fact. Of course, as you say, it really comes down to what the judge has to say ... and since the evidence is not all in as yet .... speculation here is hardly worth the effort.