whattimedoweland
Get back to me with a post when U.S. carriers have sorted out their own CR*P standards.
I don't think I would go quite that far w.r.t. long haul but I would agree that in general the US lag in service. My personal view for long haul club would be
1st Cathay
2nd Virgin/BA perhaps Virgin a little ahead
3rd AA
4th US
In 1st, BA and Cathay are very simliar with the later having better wine these days.
Above over about 30 sectors in the last year, and many many more over the last 20 years.