So what is the crime? Are you saying that the Company are no longer arguing over the rights or wrongs of the discretion issue, but have focussed in solely on the "did not bring aircraft home" line?
Where and what is this Company line:
(similar to what our Head of Flight Ops stated on the company website but more severe as it was not made in public).
Cos I haven't seen that one [been too busy trying to vote with my feet, but suffered a minor setback -will just have to tunnel in a different direction].
Surely the Company will HAVE to provide a written accusation of some description to someone - you can't just make it up as go along........