I have been thinking about how to put my perspective on this into words, but Genghis has already done this for me! Thanks!
The problem is that I haven't taught this particular lesson for a few years and the industry has moved more towards the equivalent of an EFB in every Cessna within these years. Before that, I saw students who were unable to figure out which way is north using a map, who were easily confused when presented with a couple of motorways to follow and every combination of this. Fortunately, most of them were able to acquire the needed skills in due course, but I really wonder how many are still able to use them today. For day-to-day operations in good weather, no problem, but what happens on those days when you need your plan B...