I take back that you’re not a fan of ADS-B.
I don’t think anyone is saying ADS-B(IN) is a total replacement for alerted see and avoid (yet) but rather that it’s an additional thing to assist with situational awareness. At the moment there are no standards associated with ADS-B(IN) for use like a TCAS, so it actually can’t be a replacement anyway! Regardless it is handy is in helping paint a picture with what you see with the Mk1 eyeball and hear on the radio.