Originally Posted by
Eclan
It appears from the discourse here that Dre is not as smart as he likes to hold himself to be and has soon resorted to playing the person as you call it, calling the person a flight simmer, casting aspersions on the person's aeronautical experience and qualification, etc, and then leaving.
Actually I had better things to do. The hypoxia theory relies on pilots performing complex tasks far greater after the event than they would be able to perform after suffering hypoxia for that long, after they’ve seemingly lost the ability to simple tasks like descend the aircraft.
Truth is until the FDR/CVR are found people are filling in the (very large) blanks with their own theories. None of them can be proven true.
Even if the FDR/CVR are found then that may not put speculation to rest. Chances are the CVR may only contain hours of silence. The FDR would contain the recorded control inputs, but then it may be unclear who or why or under what psychological state those inputs were made, leading to further debate and disagreement on what the root cause of the accident was.